SOMD Panther: Loved the feature from the last chat. Who in the WPIAL earned their Yinzer Stripes last week? (Someone not named Zane)

Brian Batko: Greetings, Mr. Panther, thanks for the question. Do I want to know what SOMD stands for? Probably not.

Anyway, a couple teams who earned their stripes last week, in my mind: Belle Vernon, which beat Ringgold 31-10, and Rochester, which shut out Sto-Rox 27-0. Ringgold had scored 42 points in its first two games, but Belle Vernon waxed the Rams. Sto-Rox hadn't scored fewer than 36 points in three games, but Rochester dominated from start to finish.

One player who earned his stripes? Penn-Trafford QB Cam Laffoon. Any true yinzer would love this guy. Not only is he the QB, but he plays defense too, and coach John Ruane tells me he's not afraid to stick his nose in there on any play, offense or defense.

Advertise with us

twentytwo: Any word on what kind of interest/offers Darius Wise from Beaver has gotten?

Brian Batko: Wise has offers from Colorado State, Eastern Michigan, Miami (Ohio) and, most interesting to me, BYU. Wise is a mormon, so you have to think BYU has a real shot here. Does he deserve more? Tough for me to say not having seen him in person, but with what he's done this year, especially against Aliquippa when Beaver ends the Quips' long regular-season winning streak, I'd say he might garner some more interest.

Kevin: any more good wpial names?

Brian Batko: So many good WPIAL names, Kevin. I wrote about Upper St. Clair's stifling defense this week and the Panthers' leading tackler really stuck out to me: Eli Grape. Kind of a mix between Eli Apple, cornerback from Ohio State who was the Giants' first-round pick this year, and Gilbert Grape, Johnny Depp's title character from the fantastic 1993 movie "What's Eating Gilbert Grape?" Eli Grape is just eating up ball carriers this season.

Here's that story on the USC defense if you're interested.

Advertise with us

carl: Is claretone elite

Brian Batko: Carl, Claretone kind of sounds like some sort of hygiene/beauty product. If you're speaking of Clairton football, I think the Bears are indeed elite this season in Class 1A. With Lamont Wade and Noah Hamlin, I think they're the favorite over Jeannette in that class. But what about beyond 1A? Actually, we'll get to find out this year when Clairton takes on Aliquippa at Clairton two weeks from tonight...

SOMD Panther: Why does Notre Dame have such a big pull in Western PA? I didn't grow up in the area, and I understand the appeal that the school has everywhere, but its clear having lived in PGH for years now, that ND has some kind of over-indexed, inflated prestige in Western PA.

Brian Batko: Over-indexed seems like an under-indexed phrase. Nice work, Panther. I'm not sure what it is about Notre Dame in these parts. If anything, maybe it's because Pitt hasn't exactly been a premier program when a lot of these kids were growing up, so they gravitated toward being big fans of other schools, the ones with more of a national presence? Like you said though, Notre Dame has that appeal everywhere, so that's what I chalk it up to more than anything. Irish just happen to be having a great run recruiting Western Pa.

Mr. GOAT: Who was your favorite player to ref at the a ridge shootout?

Advertise with us

Brian Batko: Mr. GOAT, taking me down memory lane to my days officiating 3-on-3 hoops in Mars. It's funny, I didn't know it at the time because the basketball players I was reffing were middle-schoolers then. But as I think back, some of the kids who played each summer in the Adams Ridge Shootout included: Robby Carmody, John Castello, Andrew Petcash, maybe even current Central Catholic QB Troy Fisher?

Carmody and Castello were really really good even back then, so it's been cool to see the players they've become coming up through Mars basketball. But I do have to give a nod to Brandt and Jack Kepreos, they were always a blast to hang with too. Good kids, good family.

Kevin: should high schools ban kickoffs

Brian Batko: I don't really see any reason to. In my mind, the kickoff return isn't quite as dangerous in high school because you don't have as many ridiculously large, fast, physical athletes ramming into each other like in the NFL or even college. Then again, I'm a pretty open-minded guy, and kickoffs aren't really that great anyway. Although they get returned for TD's a lot more at this level than above, and that's an exciting play when it happens.

Simple Simon: I saw a report that said the number of high school players is up because more girls are playing. Any girls in the WPIAL?

Advertise with us

Brian Batko: Hi, Simon. I haven't seen that report, but yes, there are. Taylor Gunn is a kicker for Highlands, and she was our athlete of the week just last Friday. There have been other female kickers too, most notable Kristina Coyne from Char Valley and April Goss from Hopewell, who still kicks at Kent State. I do know from writing a season preview on Cornell that the Raiders have a female receiver and would've had a second girl too, but she got injured before the season.

Dallas hemphill: We are a few weeks into this season with the 6 classifications. What schools do you think benefited from the change and what teams actually suffered. I would say Qauker Valley stands out for me in terms of suffering from the change. Yea they played in the MAC with aliquippa and BF and beaver, but now they added central valley, hopewell. Quaker valley is a pretty good team. maybe not championship contender but quality team. They may only win one conference game (ellwood city). so what other teams do you see that the changed helped or maybe hurt them some?

Brian Batko: Thanks Dallas, good question. QV is a great example, especially when you look at what they did against Neshannock a couple weeks back. The Quakers will have a similar situation in basketball this year, too. I think the change helped North Hills, which got to bump down and be one of the largest 5A schools, and should have a chance to sneak into the playoffs. On the other hand, like QV, Highlands got tossed into a really tough league with South Fayette, Mars, New Castle and Montour. A decent team will miss the postseason there, too.

Brian Batkos high wasted pants: Who gets left out from the Beaver Valley Conference: Beaver, BF, Quip, or CV?

Brian Batko: Trust me, no pants on me are wasted pants. It's funny, when I see the questions in the chat queue, I can't always see the entire name. I did not expect that.

Advertise with us

Anyhoo, if I'm not mistaken, technically two of them could be left out if the two 3A wild cards go to the other two conferences. Although that seems highly unklikely when you look at the strength of Beaver Valley. I'll say CV gets left out. Just a hunch. I might've said Beaver before the season, but beating Aliquippa? That's impressive.

Douglas J: What are your thoughts on teams scoring 80 points and the defense posting a shut out?

Brian Batko: So basically, what do I think about teams winning 81-0 or more? Yeah, it's not good, you hate to see it happen, but it happens. Especially in those lower classes where a team like, say, Clairton is just so much more athletic and talented than some opponents. It's always a catch-22 because you don't want a coach to run up a score, but at the same time, you need to let your players play, to an extent. And sometimes, even the backups are too good for the other team's starters.

Dallas hemphill: with how CV played south fayette. I'll roll the dice and say Beaver and CV make it. If that happens. when was the last time aliquippa hasn't made the playoffs?

Brian Batko: That's certainly a roll of the dice when you pick against Aliquippa missing the playoffs. Quips haven't done that since 1994. And how much has changed in WPIAL football since 1994? Well, your champions that year were:

Advertise with us

Quad A: McKeesport (OK, sure)

Triple A: McGuffey (really?)

Double A: New Brighton (wha?)

Single A: Western Beaver (wow)

Douglas J: Zane Duden is good. Assuming he finishes the season at the top of the list, can he truly be considered the best since Wade and Murray (Steel Valley) either have played less games along with really only two quarters worth of playing time?

Advertise with us

Brian Batko: *Zane Dudek. I've heard a couple people get his name wrong (Dane Zudek, Zane Duzek, etc.). I guess that's one thing about Dudek, part of his prolific numbers come from the amount of carries he gets, but he does still average 9.5 yards a rush. Granted, that's not the 15 per tote those other two guys do, but they're also playing 2A and 1A ball while Dudek's in 5A playing McKeesport, Gateway, etc. So yes, I do still think he can be considered the best. Truly.

Dallas hemphill: hey, the big 7 was a powerhouse in the 90s. i remember watching neshannock get steamrolled by Rochester, Monaca, Western Beaver, and Southside beaver. If i remember correctly the single A champ almost always came from the big 7 in the 90s. im not completely surprised by western beaver. Southside won in 99 i believe.

Brian Batko: Yeah, that's before my time. But like I said, just goes to show how much WPIAL football has changed since then. You're right about South Side winning in '99, beating Monaca 21-14. Of course, Monaca technically doesn't even exist anymore, so yeah, much has changed.

Brian Batkos high wasted pants: I think Farrell was in the Big 7 conference as well.

Brian Batko: OK, that's enough out of my pants.

Advertise with us

Douglas J: Yes, Dudek. Typo... sorry.

Brian Batko: All good. Everyone will, or at least should, know his name by the end of the season. If they don't already. 1,200 yards in 4 games is ridonkulous.

twentytwo: How are the two wild card spots in 3A determined?

Brian Batko: You might see us writing more about this soon, as we get closer to playoff time. Believe it's best overall record, and failing that, it goes into some convoluted tiebreaker mechanisms. Be on the lookout for those explanations, possibly from the true living legend himself, Mike White.

Douglas J: With old coaching legends (Novak, Render, etc) getting towards their golden years of coaching, what are the names of some younger coaches who will follow in their footsteps of success?

Advertise with us

Brian Batko: Well in all honesty, I certainly don't know who will replace those two guys at their respective schools. But as far as other younger coaches in the area who look like they're headed for lots of wins in their careers, I'd look to John Ruane at Penn-Trafford, Eric Kasperowicz at Pine-Richland, maybe first-year McKeesport coach Matt Miller if he keeps it rolling there like George Smith did for a long time.

Douglas J: Wild card system is based off of conference record. If ties it goes to head-to-head match up (if the two teams tied played each other)If that is tied it goes to Gardner points.

Brian Batko: That's right, my mistake. Will make things tough on the Beaver Valley in 3A if those teams keep beating each other up, resulting in a lot of parity. Guess we'll see what happens. Wouldn't be surprising if those Gardner points and tiebreaker points come into play.

Brian Batkos high wasted pants: I will say this, I am rooting for you to beat Mike White in the picks section of varsity xtra. He used to bully that older gentleman on there. Just sayin'

Brian Batko: Thanks, pants. Although I'll say this, that act was just for the show. Behind the scenes, Terry Shields had Mike cowering in fear of him at every turn. Made for a lot of tension around the P-G office.

Advertise with us

Dallas hemphill: before my time as well. I was just a little guy back then.Almost sure you're older than me. 2009 graduate. One more question with the 6 classifications. How do you think it is going to come into play come state championship games for the WPIAL? Usually we had a pretty good showing in state championship games for the 4 classifications.

Brian Batko: I graduated high school in 09, as well. I'm not sure what attendance will be like or whether that'll be affected by the new system. Somewhat ironically maybe, I've been to basketball and baseball state finals now, but not football, so tough for me to say.

Brian Batko: OK, that's it for today. This was a good one. Thanks to everyone who dropped in and asked a question or commented. Appreciate that. Let's do it again next week, same time. Until then, enjoy tonight's action. Mike White will be at Keystone Oaks-Beaver, I'll be at Quaker Valley-Central Valley. See you on the other side.