Since last month, Peters Township High School's varsity football coach has been the subject of publicized allegations that he downplayed the gravity of concussions, clashed with athletic trainers, belittled staff and insulted players.

Two official inquiries found no wrongdoing by Richard L. Piccinini.

But since then, more detailed allegations have emerged. While not common, the type of thorny issues raised by Mr. Piccinini's critics occasionally appear in high school athletic programs.

"It's rare, but it's not unheard of," said Robert Ferraro, founder and CEO of the Pennsylvania-based National High School Coaches Association.

Advertise with us

Among the questions raised by the Peters controversy are: How should coaches approach concussions, a critical topic in sports today? How should school districts handle allegations of coaches crossing the line from being demanding to jeopardizing athletes' health? And what kind of role model should a coach be?

Increasingly, Mr. Ferraro said, coaches are steering away from the old-school mentality with "negative-type motivation" that critics have said Mr. Piccinini exhibits. The transition, in his opinion, is ongoing.

"We have a saying that the highest form of motivation is a good personal relationship," said Mr. Ferraro, who is not involved in the Peters situation. "Obviously when you're browbeating one of your athletes and embarrassing them and demeaning them, that's not gonna lead to a good personal relationship."

In Peters, athletic trainers, a former assistant coach and several parents said Mr. Piccinini, 43, of Green Tree, has displayed questionable behavior.

Other parents and the Peters Township School District back the head coach. Supporters acknowledge that he is not a gentle, nurturing type but said there is no evidence that he has put anyone's health at risk.

Advertise with us

The district conducted its own investigation, which could not substantiate allegations of bad behavior raised by Mark Mortland, an athletic trainer in Peters paid $40,000 a year by the school district. A police investigation found no evidence that Mr. Piccinini did anything criminal.

Robert G. Del Greco Jr., one of Mr. Piccinini's attorneys, said the inquiries exonerated his client.

"By the published accounts of Peters Township administrators, all of these allegations were fully and extensively investigated and declared to be unfounded," Mr. Del Greco said. "Inasmuch as two separate entities have investigated coach Piccinini with identical results, we consider this matter to be sufficiently concluded."

Mr. Del Greco declined a request to interview his client for this story.

The school board voted 8-1 last year to hire Mr. Piccinini, a veteran coach who most recently was an assistant at Upper St. Clair. Last month it rehired him for another year by a 6-3 vote.

Advertise with us

Those who opposed the rehiring criticized the district for rushing the vote, keeping them in the dark about the investigation and not having an independent inquiry.

As a result, Peters has found itself in a sticky situation grappling with allegations about a coach's conduct and its handling of the resulting controversy.

"I really believe that 99.9 percent of our coaches behave appropriately, are dignified, have an excellent sense of moral responsibility to kids," said Kathleen Harrington, chairwoman of the District VII Steering Committee for Sportsmanship of the Pennsylvania Interscholastic Athletic Association, who said she was not familiar with the situation.

"There's a way to be rough with kids without using bad language. You don't have to treat them like they're fragile in sports. It's the school of hard knocks. But I know great coaches out there and they don't curse, they don't knock you around, they get their point across by example, and kids will walk on water for them," Mrs. Harrington, a Peters resident and former principal at Pine-Richland Middle School, said. "You've got to conduct yourself with the proper ethics, morality and poise in front of kids."

Different perspectives

Advertise with us

In Peters, concerned members of the community have different perspectives on Mr. Piccinini's tenure as head coach.

Two of Mr. Mortland's trainers, Andrew Traber and Kim Windstein, said they felt Mr. Piccinini undermined their assessments of injured players. They said they believe he created an atmosphere in which players were subtly dissuaded from seeking medical help.

Speaking publicly for the first time about the situation, Mr. Traber and Ms. Windstein said Mr. Piccinini would often tell injured players that if they saw a physician, the doctor would likely keep them off the field for two weeks.

"The way it would be inflected would not be in a way of, 'Oh, I think something's really wrong.' It was more, 'You're gonna be out for two weeks and there's no reason you need to be out for two weeks,' " Ms. Windstein, 23, of Peters, said. "You're gonna make the kid think twice about going to the doctor."

Ms. Windstein said other comments by Mr. Piccinini marked what she saw as an attitude of placing winning and playing time over student safety.

Advertise with us

"It was just, 'Why isn't he practicing? There's nothing wrong with him. He's just soft.' That would be his response a lot of times."

Mr. Piccinini's supporters said they had no problem with how he handled injuries.

"We didn't have any issues with Coach Pic whatsoever," Cathy Evans said.

"[My son] did have an arm injury. But he did not tell me, he did not tell coach, he did not tell the trainer. Not because he was afraid of the coach but because there was no way he was not going to play. Because it's his senior season and he wanted to play at the next level."

Ms. Evans acknowledged that the coach might not have a reserved personality.

Advertise with us

"He is a gruff and tough coach, but football is not about warm and fuzzy. It is football," Ms. Evans said.

David Wall, whose son also played with a minor injury, said he did not believe Mr. Piccinini risked the young man's health.

"It wasn't like it was forcing him on the field when he was hurt. It was more, it's hard to explain. It was more of a 'suck it up, you're not hurt that bad [attitude],' " Mr. Wall said.

Mr. Wall, a Peters graduate, said he had no qualms about how Mr. Piccinini did his job.

"In the past we've had coaches that probably didn't take that hard line and Peters has been kind of a doormat of the conference. ... Every now and then you have to be a tough guy in football," Mr. Wall said. "Did he have to ruffle some feathers? Obviously he did. But I'm a Peters alumn[us] and I want them to win."

Advertise with us

Handling concussions

In August, the trainers said, two players suffered concussions. Both returned to the sidelines to watch the team while wearing sunglasses and hats to protect them from sunlight, which can aggravate concussion symptoms.

Mr. Traber, 26, of Bridgeville, said Mr. Piccinini told the players "not to wear sunglasses on his field."

"He kept saying ... that, 'He doesn't have a concussion. He needs to get back on the field.' He kept pressuring us to push up the date of his appointment with UPMC to be ready for the initial scrimmage," Mr. Traber said.

Matt Bianco, father of one player, said he became concerned when other parents told him their children were not reporting injuries because they were being "belittled" by the coach.

Advertise with us

Mr. Bianco said his son told him he did not remove his hat or sunglasses that day, but he later developed an arm hematoma and went to the hospital because he had left it untreated.

The teen was afraid to report the injury for fear of Mr. Piccinini's reaction, Mr. Bianco said.

Also in August, Mr. Traber said, Mr. Piccinini called from the field to the sideline for an "obvious forearm fracture" to be taped up without knowing the severity of the injury.

The phrases "It's not a concussion, it's just a headache" and "tape it up" became two familiar statements by Mr. Piccinini, trainers said.

Mr. Del Greco did not address specific questions about any of the players or his client's approach to dealing with injuries.

Advertise with us

Relating to players, staff

The trainers and former assistant coach Bob Kitchen, 36, of Bethel Park, said Mr. Piccinini belittled staff and regularly "humiliated" players.

"In practice in front of everybody he would say, 'What are you, stupid?' Or, 'How stupid are you?' It was the way he said it on a daily basis, threatened to have them not dress for a game," Mr. Kitchen said. "Totally degrading them constantly. In my 12 years of coaching I never heard a coach verbally talk to players like that."

Except for Mr. Kitchen, Mr. Piccinini's current and former staff either could not be reached for comment, declined interviews or did not respond to inquiries.

Mr. Piccinini's former boss, Upper St. Clair head coach Jim Render, spoke highly of his former assistant, a "football junkie." He described him as "knowledgeable" and "likable," and said he worked well with staff.

Advertise with us

A 'look-into'

On Aug. 22, Mr. Traber sent a text message to Peters athletic director Brian Geyer that read: "I feel like everytime [sic] an athlete from football comes to me for anything, and if I have to refer to a physician or someone else. Pic always finds a way to question what I'm doing"

The situation simmered. On Nov. 30, Mr. Mortland sent a scathing email about Mr. Piccinini to superintendent Nina Zetty outlining his concerns.

Mrs. Zetty said the administration was already investigating issues -- she termed it a "look-into" -- in the football program that had been raised at the beginning of the season. She would not go into detail.

Mrs. Zetty, Mr. Geyer and the high school principal spoke with Mr. Traber and some assistant coaches. Mrs. Zetty would not identify which ones and refused to say whether any of the 68 players on the football roster or parents were interviewed.

Advertise with us

Asked whether the coach humiliated players, Mrs. Zetty said: "I have not had a parent or student come to me and say, 'The coach treated me this way.' I don't have any victims."

Some challenged the thoroughness of the investigation -- "I just don't take people's words for it," board member William Merrell said -- and questioned whether the vote to rehire Mr. Piccinini was rushed. Each Peters coach is hired for only one year.

"It was laziness on the part of the school board. They didn't want to have to do anything more than they did," parent Michele Bittel said. "Why else would they not have postponed it?"

Board member Sandy Gregg said her constituents spoke clearly in about 10 emails.

"I concluded that the majority of parents that I heard from did not want this coach back in, and that's why I decided to vote against him," Ms. Gregg said.

Advertise with us

The majority board members who supported Mr. Piccinini did not respond to interview requests or declined comment.

Last month, Peters police investigated a complaint referred by Washington County Children and Youth Services that an "alleged perpetrator" allowed children to play sports with concussions or concussion-like symptoms.

Chief Harry Fruecht said he could not "support these allegations with fact" and closed the case.

Going forward, the district is trying to get back to normal.

"If I had a son, I would allow him to play for Coach Piccinini," Mrs. Zetty said.

Advertise with us

Mr. Bianco, however, will not.

"There's no way he will step on the field if he's the coach," Mr. Bianco said.