Pop Warner football players who may have a concussion now need written clearance from a licensed medical professional trained in concussion recognition to return to play.
The youth football league, which governs roughly 280,000 players across the country, announced the rule amendment Thursday.
"[Young players] are more susceptible to long-term damage if they get a second injury before the first one heals," said Jon Butler, the executive director of Pop Warner. "If there's any chance that a child has a concussion, then they are on the sidelines until the proper medical supervision signs off on them."
The rules regarding removal in the event of injury stipulate that the head coach is responsible for removing injured players. The updated rules give assistant coaches the ability to remove a player due to injury if the player's parent serves as head coach.
"One of the things we were running into in general, a child gets injured or there's a suspicion of injury, and a parent says, 'Oh he's fine, put him back in,' " Mr. Butler said.
A concussion occurs when a blow to the head or rapid acceleration or deceleration of the head, such as those caused by a hit in football, causes the brain to slide through the fluid that cushions it and slam into the inner wall of the skull, according to the Mayo Clinic's website. The contact results in bleeding and nerve damage.
"One concussion ordinarily can be healed and there won't be any aftereffects," said Julian Bailes, chairman of West Virginia University's department of neurosurgery and an adviser to the National Football League Players Association. "We worry about getting a second one, particularly if the second one comes on top of the first one while the player's still symptomatic."
A literal interpretation of the rule would allow a player to return to the game if, upon examination, he did not have a concussion, but for practical purposes, Mr. Butler said, a player likely won't be evaluated until after the game is over. The rule also extends to cheerleaders affiliated with Pop Warner programs.
The website of the local Pop Warner branch, the Mon River Conference, lists seven teams in four age groups located in places such as Steel Valley, McKeesport and Swissvale. Local officials and coaches could not be reached for comment.
The rule change is based on Washington state's Zackery Lystedt Law, so named for the middle school football player who fell into a coma for 30 days in 2006 after he got a concussion, kept playing and got another one. He has spent the last four years recovering.
In the absence of computerized baseline testing, doctors diagnose concussions based on the existence of symptoms, Dr. Bailes said, meaning coaches and medical personnel need to take precautions when dealing with a possible concussion. Research from the Army and the University of Virginia has made progress toward a blood test that would identify a concussion with a pinprick, Mr. Butler said.
Dr. Bailes, whose Brain Injury Research Institute collects head injury data for the NFL, also serves as the chairman of Pop Warner's Medical Advisory Board, which was formally announced Thursday but has served an advisory role throughout the 2010 season. The board, Mr. Butler said, advised Pop Warner throughout the process of updating the rules.
The rule follows changes made by the NFL, the NCAA and the National Federation of State High School Associations, Dr. Bailes said.
"I think this closes the loop on that," Dr. Bailes said. "When we see guys like [Steelers pass receiver] Hines Ward getting concussions, the effect that recognition and notoriety and publicity of concussions at the NFL level and how it's managed really trickles down."
The youth of the players involved in Pop Warner, whose age groups range from 5 to 16, prevents them from generating enough momentum to cause concussions for the most part, Dr. Bailes said. The inexperience of those involved with the sport and a lack of resources balance that out, however, he said.
"We also face challenges because you're still at a period of time when you're teaching things by primarily volunteer coaches," he said. "They don't always have a full complement of medical and athletic training personnel."




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.