USC wins state quarterfinal

COVID-19 provided the plot. The Upper St. Clair basketball players – all six of them – gave the story a surreal ending.

Upper St. Clair’s team had a COVID-19 outbreak in the past week and had to play Saturday’s state quarterfinal game with only six players, and without head coach Danny Holzer and three assistants.

But after the game, Holzer talked to his team in the locker room on speaker phone and the coach was literally in tears – because Upper St. Clair won.

COVID-19 has made for some one-of-a-kind stories in sports at all levels – and this one should go down as one of the most remarkable stories in Western Pennsylvania high school sports this school year, Upper St. Clair defeated visiting Erie High, 62-57, in a PIAA Class 6A quarterfinal game. The win moves Upper St. Clair into the state semifinals for the first time in school history. Upper St. Clair (21-1) will play Reading Tuesday.

Advertise with us

Holzer watched the game at home on his laptop on a livestream feed, with his wife downstairs. Carol Holzer needed to pinch her husband afterward so he knew this was for real.

“I started coaching when I was 22 and I’ve been coaching 34 years,” Holzer said in a telephone interview an hour after the game. “This was by far the most surreal day of my coaching career. Nothing else is even close. To watch them perform the way they did with only six kids, I’m just overwhelmed with emotion.”

Greg Wagner, assistant athletic director at Upper St. Clair, came in the locker room after the game and put the whole thing in perspective.

“He told us,” said senior guard Ethan Dahlem, who scored 13 points, “that we’re going to be in a bar years from now talking about this day and this game.”

There were so many unusual sidebars to this story that made the whole situation unique for USC (Unreal Six Cats). This stuff is for real:

Advertise with us

• The guy who took over as interim coach for Upper St. Clair isn’t even old enough to drink alcohol. Tanner Gensler is a 20-year-old sophomore who plays at Muskingum College and came home on some weekends to be a volunteer coach for the Panthers. But he hadn’t been to many practices and hadn’t sat on the bench for even one game before Saturday.

“This is one of the greatest days of my life,” Tanner Gensler said. “In this crazy world, I guess this is what happens.”

• Assistant coach Brandon McClester was supposed to be the interim coach, but during a short team practice Saturday morning learned that his negative test was taken too early last week and he couldn’t coach without another test. He got another one Saturday, it was negative again and he arrived at the game early in the second quarter, only to be told by the officials that he couldn’t stand during the game because Gensler was the head coach.

• The six players for USC included three senior regular starters (David Pantelis, Luke Gensler, Dahlem), a reserve junior (Porter Rauch) and two junior varsity players (freshman Devin Hall and sophomore Matt Gaither). They were allowed to play because they were the only players who tested negative for the virus Wednesday. Gensler is the younger brother of Tanner Gensler.

• The Stellar Six was down to the Fab Five for a few minutes in the second half, because Luke Gensler left with a bloody lip. After the game, he had a band-aid on his lip and an ice bag on his left ankle that he hurt in the final few seconds.

Advertise with us

• Upper St. Clair’s players and coaches had been in quarantine since last Sunday and the team played a 1-3-1 zone defense the entire game that they hadn’t played in one other game this season.

• During the game, Holzer sent a few text messages to Alex Gensler, Tanner’s sister who was sitting behind the Upper St. Clair bench. The text messages were some strategy suggestions and Alex would relay the messages to her brother.

“I just had to put all the trust in their players and they did their thing,” Tanner Gensler said.

McClester said, “This is crazy. But the kids played hard, followed the game plan and played their hearts out.”

The funny thing is, Upper St. Clair was extremely loose before the game – and confident. As Pantelis was warming up, he said, “We’re fine. We’ll be alright.”

Advertise with us

Holzer said, “I talked to Pantelis on the phone in the morning. He’s unbelievable. He says to me, ‘Coach, don’t worry. We got this. We’ll see you at practice Monday.’”

Erie, a school that has been in existence in four years, didn’t have a powerhouse team, but still had an 18-3 record. It should also be pointed out that Upper St. Clair didn’t exactly put six tomato cans on the court. Luke Gensler has been a three-year starter and Pantelis and Dahlem were starters as juniors. This team won a WPIAL championship a week earlier.

Pantelis, a 6-foot senior guard and Yale football recruit, was gigantic in the win, scoring 23 points, pulling down a handful of rebounds and showing a toughness that he and Dahlem have always displayed.

“They’re football boys,” McClester said. “That toughness is an automatic for them.”

Pantelis said, “We kind of had confidence from the beginning of the game that we were going to win.”

Advertise with us

Upper St. Clair totally changed its defensive strategy. A pressing, man-to-man team all season, Upper St. Clair went soft. The Panthers sat back in a passive 1-3-1 zone because they had serious questions about Erie’s shooting ability. USC never even got near a few Erie players if they got the ball within 20 feet of the basket.

“We were just going to let them shoot,” Dahlem said. “The thing is, none of them wanted to shoot.”

Oh, Erie shot 51 times. But if it was behind the 3-point line, it was mostly a brick. Erie shot only 17% from 3-point range (4 of 24).

Erie enjoyed a size advantage with 6-foot-7 Marquell Darnell and 6-4 Jamie Smith. But Erie was stagnant most of the game against Upper St. Clair’s zone.

Upper St. Clair led, 25-24, at halftime. But the Panthers went on a 15-5 run in the third quarter to open up a 40-29 lead. Pantelis scored 18 of his 23 in the second and third quarters.

Advertise with us

Rauch, who had 6 points, scored off a nice pass from Pantelis to give the Panthers a 52-38 lead. Erie came back and sliced the deficit to 58-53 with 23.5 seconds left, but USC hung on for the win. Gensler was only 3 of 14 from the field, but was 13 of 18 from the free-throw line, including 11 of 16 in the final quarter.

“Holzer is always talking about how we’re the toughest team in the WPIAL, we’ve got the most grit and we’re hard working,” Dahlem said. “I think we proved that today.”

Mike White: mwhite@post-gazette.com and Twitter @mwhiteburgh