Let’s play “what if.” Imagine a college basketball team with two All-American 6-foot-7 players who were absolute beasts on the inside.
Imagine that team with a current NBA player who is one of the best point guards to come out of Western Pennsylvania.
Add a versatile player who was one of the greatest shooters ever for the North Carolina Tar Heels, and also throw in the greatest scorer in WPIAL history who went on to a big college career.
That would make one “fabulous” team. Or the Post-Gazette “all-time” Fab 5.
“I think that team would definitely be a national title contender,” said Dante Calabria, that great North Carolina marksman.
This year marks the 40th anniversary of the first Post-Gazette Fabulous 5, an all-star team picked from all players in the WPIAL and City League. To celebrate the 40 years, the P-G decided to pick an “all-time” Fab 5 team. A committee of 21 current high school coaches, three former coaches and six current and former P-G scholastic sports staff members picked the team, voting in order of preference for the top 20 players from the 40 years.
Read More
Western Pennsylvania doesn’t have a reputation of being a hotbed for high school basketball talent, but take the five who got the most votes, put them on one team in their college days and what would be lacking?
The five are strongmen DeJuan Blair of Schenley and Danny Fortson of Shaler, point guard T.J. McConnell of Chartiers Valley, and shooting guards Tom Pipkins of Valley and Dante Calabria of Blackhawk. Three of them (Fortson, Blair and McConnell) made the NBA. The voting for the top was fairly close with Blair receiving 484 points, Fortson 460 and McConnell 452.
“Honestly, after hearing who made this [all-time Fab 5], I don’t see any reason why that team couldn’t make the Final Four,” McConnell said.
Calabria knows a thing about Final Four teams. He was on two at North Carolina.
“There are a lot of intangibles with this group,” Calabria said. “You have a lot of toughness and a lot of guys who have proven themselves over their careers in tough, meaningful games. … I mean those two tough dudes [Fortson and Blair] don’t get messed with, you have perimeter guys who can shoot and T.J. is a great distributor. You could take this team and play them professionally in Europe and they’d do well.”
Blackhawk’s Sean Miller, who coached McConnell at the University of Arizona, was sixth in the voting and Jeannette’s Terrelle Pryor seventh.
“Good. Wait until I tell coach Miller he has to come off the bench with this team,” McConnell said with a laugh.
Here is the all-time Fab 5, in the order of voting:

1. DEJUAN BLAIR, SCHENLEY (2005-06-07)
In his younger years, he was known as “Big Fella.” In Western Pennsylvania high school basketball annals, Blair is gigantic.
Blair is one of only three players to make the Fab 5 three times (Blackhawk’s Brandon Fuss-Cheatham and current Butler senior Ethan Morton are the others). Blair was a dominating force inside, but also developed a nice shooting touch during his Schenley career and his passing ability was underrated. He averaged a double double as a sophomore, junior and senior and finished his career with 1,563 points.
Blair was the leader of the great 2007 Schenley team that has to go down as one of the best in Western Pa. history. That Schenley team, which won a PIAA title, had three players go on to make big impacts at the major-college level (Blair at Pitt, D.J. Kennedy at St. John’s and Deandre Kane at Marshall and Iowa State). Blair and Kennedy played in the NBA (Kennedy for only two games) and Schenley is one of only four teams in WPIAL or City League history to have two players go on to the NBA. Plus, Blair, Kennedy and Kane were all voted in the top 12 players from the “all-time” Fab 5 teams.
At Pitt, Blair played only two seasons before turning pro. He was an All-American as a sophomore when he averaged 15 points and 12 rebounds. He went on to play seven years in the NBA and averaged 9 points and 5 rebounds for the San Antonio Spurs in 2011-12.

2. DANNY FORTSON, SHALER (1994)
This should tell you enough about Fortson’s talent on the high school level: He is the only WPIAL player ever selected to the McDonald’s All-American Game.
“I don’t know if people realize how good and dominant he was,” said J.O. Stright, who coached Fortson for a number of years with the old Pittsburgh J.O.T.S. AAU team.
Thirteen of the 20 players from the P-G’s “all-time” Fab 5 teams played for the J.O.T.S., which was founded by Stright.
Stright was a longtime adviser to Fortson and helped bring Fortson to Shaler as a junior after Fortson played his first two years at Altoona High. He played in two games as a junior at Shaler before the WPIAL ruled him ineligible the rest of the year for allegedly transferring for athletic intent.
As a senior, Fortson averaged 29 points, 13 rebounds and 2 blocks while shooting 69% from the field. Despite playing only two games as a junior, Fortson still scored 2,331 points between Altoona and Shaler. After high school, Fortson was a first-team All-American at Cincinnati, where he averaged 20 points and 9 rebounds as a sophomore, and 21 and 9 as a junior. He was a lottery pick (No. 10 overall) in the 1997 NBA draft. He played 10 years in the NBA and averaged 11 points and 11 rebounds in two different seasons with Denver and Golden State.
Stright said Fortson now lives in Cincinnati with his longtime girlfriend and the couple’s four children.

3. T.J. MCCONNELL, CHARTIERS VALLEY (2009-10)
Who could’ve predicted an NBA future for McConnell when he was a skinny 5-foot-4 freshman on Chartiers Valley’s varsity? But McConnell is a point guard for the Indiana Pacers and in his fifth season in the NBA (the first four were with the Philadelphia 76ers).
As a senior at Chartiers Valley, McConnell had what could be considered the greatest season by an individual in WPIAL history. Wampum’s Don Hennon (future All-American at Pitt) had been the only WPIAL player to score 1,000 points in a season (1,003 in 1954-55). But McConnell broke Hennon’s record when he scored 1,062 and averaged 34.2 points. McConnell led Chartiers Valley to a WPIAL title and to the PIAA championship game before losing to Neumann-Goretti.
“Growing up, when I started getting closer to high school, I started reading about the Fab 5,” McConnell said earlier this week from Indianapolis, where he and his wife, Val, now reside. “I knew a lot of players took pride in it and I was good enough and lucky enough to make it. It was a big deal. I know it sounds kind of cheesy, but I would’ve rather won four WPIAL and four state championships.”
McConnell scored 2,404 career points at Chartiers Valley, sixth best in WPIAL history, and had 334 career 3-pointers, a WPIAL record at the time. He went on to play at Duquesne University and was the 2010 Atlantic 10 Rookie of the Year. He transferred to Arizona, where he was an all-Pac 12 selection before making the Philadelphia 76ers as a free agent.

4. TOM PIPKINS, VALLEY (1992-93)
No player in WPIAL history scored like Pipkins. His 2,838 career points is still a WPIAL record.
“I can remember being a sophomore and even a freshman, it was one of my goals to make the Fab 5,” Pipkins said. “To not make it as a sophomore, I felt like I underachieved. To make it as a junior and senior, that was a big accomplishment to me.”
At Valley, Pipkins was a guard with exceptional jumping ability. He averaged at least 19 points all four years at Valley, and averaged 26 as a senior. He won a WPIAL title in 1993, went on to a highly-successful career at Duquesne and is still the school’s third all-time leading scorer with 1,828 points. He also made 311 career 3-pointers and averaged 19 points as a senior.
“A lot of people don’t know who I am now and that’s just how it is,” Pipkins said with a laugh. “But there are still people finding out who I am to this day.”
Pipkins is a para-professional in the Quaker Valley School District and lives in Hopewell with his wife and seventh-grade son, Tom Pipkins III. Is there another Tom Pipkins standout on the horizon?
“Yeah, he’s pretty good,” Tom Pipkins said.

5. DANTE CALABRIA, BLACKHAWK (1991-92)
When Dante Calabria was a freshman at Blackhawk, legendary coach John Miller wanted to put Calabria on the varsity team. But the school had a rule against moving ninth graders onto varsity teams. Still, with only three varsity seasons, Calabria scored 2,252 points.
Calabria was a good-sized guard (6-5), a great shooter and a versatile player who averaged 27 points, 8 rebounds and shot 60% from the field as a Blackhawk senior. But one other thing Calabria did a lot in his career was win. Blackhawk was 62-2 his final two years. He won three WPIAL titles and one PIAA title. He was a reserve on a national championship team at North Carolina and a starter on another Final Four team.
“I still remember the times of the Fab 5 pictures,” Calabria said. “I don’t remember the exact setting for one, but I just remember being by a limousine with the other four and spinning a ball on my finger. Those are great memories.”
Calabria holds North Carolina’s record for best 3-point percentage in a season (.496 in 1994-95). One of his biggest moments for the Tar Heels came in 1996 when he tipped in a shot with six seconds left to beat rival Duke.
Calabria enjoyed a long professional career overseas and has been in the coaching business for more than a decade now, coaching on the college level and overseas. Calabria is now an assistant at Barry University, a Division II school in Miami.
FAN VOTING FOR FAB 5
A committee voted current Butler senior Ethan Morton one of the top 10 players in the WPIAL and City League over the past 40 years. Fans agreed.
This is the 40-year anniversary of the first Post-Gazette Fabulous 5 all-star team. To commemorate the anniversary, a committee of coaches, former coaches and P-G scholastic sports staff members picked an “all-time” Fab 5, as well as a top 20. We’ll call the committee selections the “official” all-time Fab 5. But the P-G also wondered what players the fans might think were the best? So, fans had the opportunity to vote for five players in an online poll. Fans were able select their top players, with no order of preference.
A total of 1,046 fans voted and Morton, a Purdue recruit, finished eighth in both fan voting and committee voting. Morton is only the third player to make the Fab 5 three times and is a two-time Post-Gazette Player of the Year. Former Schenley and Pitt star DeJuan Blair, another three-time Fab 5 selection, finished first in both the committee and fan voting. Blair was selected on 79.6% of the fan’s ballots. Chartiers Valley’s T.J. McConnell and Blackhawk’s Dante Calabria are two other players who finished in the top five fan in both the fan and committee voting.
Here are the top 10 players in fan voting, with the percentage of ballots they appeared on:
1. DeJuan Blair, Schenley 79.6%
2. T.J. McConnell, Chartiers Valley 58.8%
3. Sean Miller, Blackhawk 47.4%
4. Terrelle Pryor, Jeannette 41.2%
5. Dante Calabria, Blackhawk 38.3%
6. Danny Fortson, Shaler 37.9
7. Tom Pipkins, Valley 21.9
8. Ethan Morton, Butler 19.3
9. Herb Pope, Aliquippa 15.5
10. Darelle Porter, Perry 15.0
40 YEARS OF FAB 5s
The Post-Gazette started picking a Fabulous 5 boys all-star basketball team in 1980. The team consisted of the top five players in Southwestern Pennsylvania. Here is every Fab 5 boys team over the past 40 years:
2020: Ethan Morton, Butler; Michael Carmody, Mars; Rodney Gallagher, Laurel Highlands; Isiah Warfield, Central Valley; Jake Hoffman, Mt. Lebanon.
2019: Ethan Morton, Butler; Keandre Bowles, Woodland Hills; Donovan Johnson, Moon; Dan Petcash, Pine-Richland; Jackson Blaufeld, Allderdice.
2018: Robby Carmody, Mars; James Ellis, Westinghouse; Coletrane Washington, Quaker Valley; Ethan Morton, Butler; Amante Britt, Woodland Hills.
2017: Andrew Petcash, Pine-Richland; Robby Carmody, Mars; Nelly Cummings, Lincoln Park; Nick Smith, North Hills; Austin Butler, Latrobe.
2016: James Jackson, Allderdice; Josh Creach, Beaver Falls; Nick Smith, North Hills; Nelly Cummings, Lincoln Park; Ramon Creighton, Allderdice.
2015: Matty McConnell, Chartiers Valley; Stephon McGinnis, Aliquippa; Kason Harrell, Hempfield; Cole Constantino, North Allegheny; Daylon Carter, Ambridge.
2014: Malik Hooker, New Castle; Ryan Luther, Hampton; D.J. Porter, Obama Academy; Maverick Rowan, Lincoln Park; Kason Harrell, Hempfield
2013: Ryan Luther, Hampton; Malik Hooker, New Castle; Elijah Cottrill, Beaver Falls; Shawn Anderson, New Castle; Devin Wilson, Montour.
2012: Sheldon Jeter, Beaver Falls; Micah Mason, Highlands; Nolan Cressler, Plum; Nate Snodgrass, Butler; Geno Thorpe, Shaler.
2011: Micah Mason, Highlands; Anthony Dallier, North Allegheny; Jesse Reed, Greensburg Central Catholic; Devon Cottrell, Gateway; Sheldon Jeter, Beaver Falls.
2010: Bill Luther, Hampton; Nate Perry, Hempfield; T.J. McConnell, Chartiers Valley; Evan Pierce, Mt. Lebanon; Tom Droney, Sewickley Academy.
2009: T.J. McConnell, Chartiers Valley; Nick Novak, Franklin Regional; Chris Klimchock, Greensburg Salem; Jeff Yunetz, Latrobe; Tom Droney, Sewickley Academy.
2008: Terrelle Pryor, Jeannette; Deandre Kane, Schenley; Quentin Harding, McKeesport; Brian Walsh, Moon; Antoine Childs, Blackhawk.
2007: DeJuan Blair, Schenley; D.J. Kennedy, Schenley; Herb Pope, Aliquippa; Terrelle Pryor, Jeannette; Jonathan Baldwin, Aliquippa.
2006: Herb Pope, Aliquippa; DeJuan Blair, Schenley; D.J. Kennedy, Schenley; Steve McNees, Shenango; Lance Jeter, Beaver Falls.
2005: Lance Jeter, Beaver Falls; Sean Lee, Upper St. Clair; Ben McCauley, Yough; Geoff Kestler, Mt. Lebanon; DeJuan Blair, Schenley.
2004: Darrelle Revis, Aliquippa; Akida McLain, Penn Hills; Ben McCauley, Yough; Adam DiMichele, Sto-Rox; James Hairston, Connellsville.
2003: Ryan Evanochko, Blackhawk; Darrelle Revis, Aliquippa; Adam DiMichele, Sto-Rox; James Hairston, Connellsville; Byron Knight, Penn Hills.
2002: Ryan Evanochko, Blackhawk; Terrance Vaughns, Uniontown; Bobby Franklin, Plum; Bryant McAllister, West Mifflin; Joey Tutchstone, Kiski Area.
2001: Daren Tielsch, Montour; Bryant McAllister, West Mifflin; Brandon Fuss-Cheatham, Blackhawk; Jack Higgins, Schenley; Allan MacQuarrie, Pine-Richland.
2000: Brandon Fuss-Cheatham, Blackhawk; Drew Schifino, Penn Hills; Yuri Demetris, Shaler; Jon Pawlak, Highlands; Josh Lay, Aliquippa.
1999: Brandon Fuss Cheatham, Blackhawk; Mike Phenizee, Peabody; David Young, New Castle; Drew Schifino, Penn Hills; Desmond Whetzel, New Castle.
1998: David Young, New Castle; Mike Colbert, Chartiers Valley; Aaron Epps, Butler; Dave Freeman, Vincentian; Ricky Richburg, Westinghouse.
1997: Archie Miller, Blackhawk; Courtney Wallace, Perry; Brian Carroll, Schenley; Aaron Lovelace, Franklin Regional; Isaiah Stewart, Chartiers Valley.
1996: Aaron Lovelace, Franklin Regional; Steve Menifee, McKeesport; Chris Kirkland, Sto-Rox; Jim Cantamessa, Blackhawk; Archie Miller, Blackhawk
1995: Pete Sauer, Shady Side Academy; Kevin Covert, Neshannock; Vince Coppola, Seton-LaSalle; Monty Latimer, Sto-Rox; Vince Graham, Belle Vernon.
1994: Pete Sauer, Shady Side Academy; Kevin Price, Duquesne; Shawn Bellis, Butler; Vince Graham, Belle Vernon; Dan Fortson, Shaler.
1993: Tom Pipkins, Valley; Nick Bosnic, Laurel Highlands; Kevin Price, Duquesne; Tino Hunter, Shaler; Mike Keyes, Woodland Hills.
1992: Terry O'Shea, Carlynton; Dante Calabria, Blackhawk; Tom Pipkins, Valley; Derrick Scott, Duquesne; Peca Arsic, Penn-Trafford.
1991: Dante Calabria, Blackhawk; Will Macon, Perry; Gabe Jackson, New Brighton; Malik Hightower, Perry; Bruce Patterson, Langley.
1990: Will Macon, Perry; Yancey Taylor, Ringgold; Norbert Valis, Hampton; Jermaine Morgan, Jeannette; Keith Crosby, Carrick.
1989: Kevin Salvadori, Seton-LaSalle; Myron Walker, Aliquippa; Chris Pipkin, New Brighton; Jeff Gaca, Quaker Valley; Jon Walker, New Brighton.
1988: Jim McCoy, Central Catholic; Keith Tower, Moon; William Herndon, Allderdice; Gravelle Craig, Farrell; Mark Gilbert, Aliquippa
1987: Sean Miller, Blackhawk; Mike Yoest, North Hills; Darelle Porter, Perry; Joe Nethen, Shaler; Dan Aloi, Ellwood City.
1986: Sean Miller, Blackhawk; Major Harris, Brashear; John Rasp, Norwin; Tony Petrarca, Kiski Area; Pete Freeman, Rochester.
1985: Brian Shanahan, Hampton; Shawn Roberts, Farrell; Neal Fenton, Latrobe; Greg Martucci, Springdale; Bill Vernau, Brentwood.
1984: Marvin Woods, Aliquippa; Tyrone Howard, Westinghouse; Marvin Bailey, Lawrenceville Catholic; John Robinson, Peabody; Collins Dobbs, Allderdice.
1983: Mark Beavers, Sto-Rox; Marlon Ferguson, Center; Bill Leonard, McKeesport; Ron Stevenson, Langley; Dean Kartsonas, Shady Side Academy.
1982: Rick Suder, Center; Joe David, Upper St. Clair; Lloyd Moore, Clairton; Mike Masley, Boyle; Jack Mansell, Sharon.
1981: Ron Rowan, Beaver Falls; Pat Farrell, Central Catholic; Lloyd Moore, Clairton; Ken Simril, Belle Vernon; Earl Minor, Uniontown
1980: Frank Dobbs, Allderdice; Marc Marotta, Central Catholic; Hal Bentley, New Brighton; Cleveland Bibbens, Brashear; Dwight Collins, Beaver Falls.



Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.