The Fabulous 5 team was set and all that was left to do was to get the group picture. All five stars had to be present or the picture would be useless. There was one problem:

Fab 5 member Geoff Kestler of Mt. Lebanon was on a family vacation and Kestler wasn’t due to return home for more than a week. The vacation spot for the Kestlers was … in the Caribbean — on the island of Saint Martin. Yeah, man! This was a fabulous dilemma and I’ll never forget the phone call with Kestler’s dad.

“No problem. He’ll be there,” Hal Kestler said. “I’ll just have him come back early.”

What?

Advertise with us

“It’s the Fab 5!” Hal Kestler exclaimed.

Sure enough, Geoff Kestler left his family, got on a plane one day later, cut his vacation short six days and was at the Post-Gazette building for that Fab 5 photo shoot.

That happened 15 years ago, but it’s a story that gives an indication of how big the Post-Gazette Fab 5 has become. And the memories and stories I have of the Fab 5 are many — from all the photo shoots to what people might do to be on the Fab 5. Many years ago, a parent called me at home when he found out his son wasn’t selected, and suggested Bobby Knight might not recruit his son if he wasn’t on the Fab 5. Seriously.

This year marks the 40th anniversary of the first Fab 5, a high school basketball all-star team picked by the P-G and made up of the top five players in the WPIAL and City League. All-star teams had been picked by the newspaper for ages, but a five-player team didn’t have a name until 1980 when the “Fab 5” was born. The Fab 5 was the brainchild of former Post-Gazette high school editor Steve Hecht. Ol’ Hector got me involved when I was a college freshman in 1981. My job was to take Shaler’s Karen Hosek back to her home in Troy Hill after the photo shoot.

Hal Kestler vividly remembers the Fab 5 story about his son and talked about it last week. “I remember you saying to me that maybe you guys could photo shop Geoff into the picture,” Kestler said. “But I knew he’d want to be there for it. We’re a basketball family. The Fab 5 is as big as it gets.”

Advertise with us

I have been heavily involved in helping select the Fab 5 and setting up photos ever since 1985. And oh, the memories. The group photos have always been big. An airport, hospital emergency room, fire station, barber shop, PNC Park, a classroom, a swimming pool and the Post-Gazette photo studio are some of the places where the photos have been taken.

It’s imperative all five players are present. Another favorite story is from 1995 and it’s similar to Kestler’s. Shady Side Academy’s Pete Sauer was at Pirate spring training in Bradenton, Fla., when we wanted to take the group picture. His father, Mark, was the president of the Pirates at the time. Mark Sauer had his son fly in to Pittsburgh just for the Fab 5 photo. He flew him back to Bradenton the next day.

There was the time in 2014 when myself, Hampton’s Ryan Luther, Lincoln Park’s Maverick Rowan and their parents all got stuck on the Post-Gazette photo elevator going to the photo studio.

That same year, New Castle’s Malik Hooker was late for the photo. I was waiting for him outside the Post-Gazette building in Downtown Pittsburgh when Hooker called me.

“I’m here — by the Post-Gazette sign,” Hooker said.

Advertise with us

“So am I, but I don’t see you,” I said.

Hooker told me he was with his brother.

“We just put ‘Post-Gazette’ in GPS and now we’re here,” Hooker said.

I asked Hooker if there were big buildings around him. “Are you in downtown?” I asked.

“No, we’re in Cranberry,” Hooker said.

Advertise with us

Hooker was at a Post-Gazette depot center. We waited for him to show up downtown.

“The group pictures are the big thing,” said former Valley star Tom Pipkins, a two-time Fab 5 pick (1992-93) and the WPIAL’s all-time leading scorer. “I remember we took it one year with me in a limousine. I actually have people to this day find that photo somewhere on social media and send it to me.”

I remember when the wonderful Swin Cash of McKeesport did a photo shoot and P-G photographer Joyce Mendelsohn said afterward, “That Swin girl is something. She could be a model someday.”

There was the time Aliquippa’s Herb Pope came to the P-G building for the photo. A few days later, his coach called and said Pope was insisting we had his uniform. We didn’t. It turns out good ol’ Herb just didn’t want to return his uniform to the school.

There was the time a player refused to show up for the group photo. I won’t name the player to protect the guilty. He was a borderline pick and when the coach told me the player wouldn’t be showing up, we picked another player who was happy to show up for the photo — in an hour.

Advertise with us

It’s not easy picking the Fab 5. Members of the P-G scholastic sports staff pick the team, but we get heavy input from coaches and others. I have been amazed over the years how upset some people get that a certain player hasn’t been selected. This includes coaches, parents and even players.

I still laugh at the time in 1992 when I received a call at home from Mike Bosnic, proud father of Laurel Highlands standout Nick Bosnic. We hadn’t selected Nick to the Fab 5 (he made it a year later) and Dad was a little upset. Mike Bosnic said colleges were showing interest in his son, including the Indiana Hoosiers. “What will these colleges do when he doesn’t make this?” Mike Bosnic said in all seriousness.

I replied, “Mike, somehow I have a hard time believing Bobby Knight will be sitting around next week, saying ‘Hey, that Nick Bosnic didn’t make the Post-Gazette Fab 5. We can’t recruit him.’”

Every year, a handful of players who don’t make the Fab 5 could easily be on the team. But decisions are made and we move on. There have been some memorable Fab 5s — boys and girls. NBA players, WNBA players, NFL players, Olympic gold medalists, college All-Americans … they’ve all been Fab 5 members. Sometimes, we get reminders how big the Fab 5 is. Blackhawk’s Mackenzie Amalia made this year’s girls Fab 5. When I informed her father, Bob, that Mackenzie was selected to the team, he was overjoyed.

“I’m about to cry,” Bob Amalia said.

Advertise with us

How fabulous.

Mike White: mwhite@post-gazette.com and Twitter @mwhiteburgh