HOLLIDAYSBURG, Pa. — With Mars clinging to a one-point lead in its second-round Class 5A state playoff game against York William Penn and just four seconds left, senior point guard Andrew Recchia stepped up to the free-throw line with an eerie calmness about him — almost as if he has made a few big shots before.

“I saw him go to the line; there was no doubt in my mind he’s going to make them,” Mars senior Khori Fusco said. “That’s Andrew Recchia, that’s Mr. Clutch. He’s always going to make them.”

After his game-winning 3-pointer with 2.6 seconds left in the WPIAL championship game against Moon, it’s safe to say Recchia had already earned that nickname. Recchia’s performance Tuesday night simply reinforced it.

The star senior drained both free throws to finish with a game-high 23 points, and the Bearcats’ desperation 3-point attempt rimmed out at the buzzer as the Planets (26-1) held on for a 60-59 victory at Hollidaysburg.

Advertise with us

“Nobody better to have,” Mars coach Rob Carmody said. “It’s why he’s a college player, it’s why he’s going to be an all-state guy. If you saw us after practice, he’s the guy who always sticks around and shoots 100 free throws.”

Although Recchia wasn’t needed for any last-second heroics this time around, it looked as if he might be called upon to lead another comeback as he did in the WPIAL championship game, when the Planets trailed by 17 points. York William Penn jumped out to a 14-9 lead after the first quarter, and Mars couldn’t get into a rhythm offensively.

By halftime, the Bearcats led 26-22, and Fusco, the Planets senior guard, already had four fouls. Recchia had nine points at the half and senior guard Brandon Caruso had seven, but star big man Michael Carmody had only two points with three fouls and Fusco had yet to score.

“At halftime, Coach Robbie was just telling us to keep our poise,” Fusco said. “I wasn’t playing that well in the first half; I wasn’t really that locked in on defense. I was playing a little lackadaisical. But I got it together in the second half.”

To make matters worse for Mars, Carmody picked up his fourth foul on the first play of the second half and had to sit on the bench for the entire third quarter. So his dad decided to let Fusco go back in the game with four fouls, and the coach’s confidence paid off.

Advertise with us

Fusco made a layup in transition off an assist from Recchia, then followed with an and-one layup to give the Planets their first lead since early in the first quarter. Fusco then jumped in front of a pass and took it all the way in for a fastbreak dunk, igniting the Mars faithful and giving the Planets a 42-37 lead.

“The building just shook,” Fusco said. “It felt good. It felt good just to even get on the board, honestly. It felt like once I scored, everyone was behind me. I was behind myself and I had confidence.”

York William Penn wouldn’t go away quietly, though, and the Bearcats cut Mars’ lead to just one with about a minute left in the fourth quarter. That’s when the 6-foot-7, 290-pound Carmody finally made his presence felt. The big man gathered a pass from Caruso under the hoop and converted a layup while drawing a foul, then made his free throw to give the Planets a four-point lead.

Caruso then made 1 of 2 free throws before Recchia took his trip to the line and knocked both of his foul shots down to keep Mars’ season alive as the Planets seek a return trip to the PIAA championship game.

“The state championship is kind of something that we’re striving for,” Recchia said. “That was our goal from the beginning. I mean, the WPIAL championship, it’s great, and it was great to hit that shot, but at the end of the day, we’re not satisfied. We have more work to do.”

Steve Rotstein: srotstein@post-gazette.com and Twitter @SteveRotstein.