Moon’s version of The Return of the Prodigal Son was a big hit two years ago.

Jarrod Simmons grew up in the Moon Area School District and attended Moon schools through eighth grade. But when it came time for high school, Simmons went elsewhere to a private school, only to return to Moon High School a few years later and help the Tigers win a WPIAL basketball championship in 2016.

The Return of the Prodigal Son II is currently making for good theater once again. The script is strikingly similar, except playing the lead role this time is Donovan Johnson. The question is will this saga have the same ending?

Donovan Johnson attended Moon schools through eighth grade, but decided to go to Our Lady of the Sacred Heart in Coraopolis as a sophomore and junior (Simmons attended a prep school in Massachusetts before returning to Moon as a senior). Johnson transferred back to Moon for his junior year and is one of the main reasons Moon has made it to the WPIAL Class 5A championship. Johnson is a 6-foot-7 junior guard-forward who leads the team in scoring at 23 points a game.

Advertise with us

Friday night, almost two years to the day that Simmons led Moon to the championship, Johnson and Moon will play Mars in the WPIAL Class 5A title game, 9 p.m. at Petersen Events Center.

Go ahead and say it. Moon vs. Mars is a championship that’s out of this world. Both teams are 23-1. But coach Adam Kaufman will acknowledge he’s glad Johnson landed at Moon again.

The Tigers would’ve been good this season because of three talented, experienced, senior guards in twins Connor and Austin Ryan, and Jionni Smith. But Johnson has certainly added something to the Tigers.

“It’s huge,” Kaufman said of Johnson’s return. “He’s an efficient scorer, another shooter and gives us length at the rim to protect the basket.”

Johnson, called “Puff” by just about everyone, had 20 points, 14 rebounds and 4 blocked shots in the semifinals against Penn Hills.

Advertise with us

“If we play that game defensively without him, some of those shots that [Penn Hills] was missing, they’re easier to make because we only have a 6-2 guy at the rim,” said Kaufman. “Having 6-7, with a 7-foot wing span, changes a lot, just like when we had Jarrod. I understand people talk about [Johnson’s] offense and his scoring. But people underrate him defensively a little. He makes a huge difference.”

Johnson is a spindly 6-7 player who weighs 185 pounds. But many times, he will guard the opposing team’s big man. Against Mars, the defending WPIAL champion, the Tigers will face a big man unlike any other they’ve seen this season. Michael Carmody is a 6-foot-7, 290-pound junior who is a future major-college lineman in football. Johnson might guard him.

“He’s an excellent player,” said Johnson. “I might have to try and use technique over power.”

Another key matchup in this contest will be the guards. Mars also has a trio of talented, experienced guards in Andrew Recchia, Brandon Caruso and Khori Fusco.

Here is a look at the other WPIAL title games Friday and Saturday at Petersen Events Center:

Advertise with us

Class 6A

Butler has jumped on Ethan Morton’s back and the star 6-6 junior point guard has carried the Golden Tornado to the title game. In the semifinals, Morton scored 40 points as Butler beat a Pine-Richland team that had defeated Butler twice this season. Now, Morton will try to help Butler beat a Mt. Lebanon team that defeated Butler, 87-60, in December. Mt. Lebanon (21-3) plays Butler (20-4) at 9 p.m. Saturday.

Mt. Lebanon is the No. 2 seed and has won two relatively easy playoff games (both by double digits). But with Morton, Butler certainly has a chance.

No, Butler isn’t a one-man team, but Morton can wreck a team’s championship hopes. The most points ever scored in one tournament in the highest classification is 147 by Drew Schifino. The second most is 122 by Latrobe’s Neal Fenton in 1985. Morton needs 32 points to reach Fenton. Morton, who averages 28.1 points, has scored 32 and 40 in the past two games.

Mt. Lebanon is a well-rounded team with Jake Hoffman averaging a team-high 17 points a game. The Blue Devils’ press hurt Butler in the first meeting and Mt. Lebanon shot well. But that’s not that unusual. Mt. Lebanon is an excellent 3-point shooting team.

Advertise with us

Mt. Lebanon is trying to win its third championship under coach Joe David. Butler’s previous title came in 1991 under coach Mark Jula.

This Butler team starts only one senior.

“This team has had to work hard all year,” said Butler coach Matt Clement. “When we were ranked No. 1 [by the Post-Gazette] at the start of the season, I said we’re not near No. 1. I said we could get better because we’re so young. And we have improved. But we still have a long ways to go.”

Class 4A

In more than 100 years of WPIAL basketball championships, only twice have two teams met in a championship game three consecutive years. Coincidentally, both triple plays will include New Castle.

Advertise with us

The first two teams that met in a title game three years in a row were New Castle and Hampton from 2012-14. Saturday at 1 p.m., New Castle (20-4) will meet Quaker Valley (20-3) for the third consecutive year in the 4A title game.

Quaker Valley has defeated New Castle twice this season, but New Castle has defeated Quaker Valley in the past two title games. Maybe it’s a little surprising that New Castle has made it to the title game again, considering the Red Hurricanes have won two WPIAL playoff games without leading scorer Demetris McKnight (13 ppg), who has not played for undisclosed reasons.

New Castle coach Ralph Blundo has won five championships and will try to become only the seventh coach in WPIAL history to win six titles. New Castle also will try to win its 13th title, which would tie Farrell for the most in WPIAL history.

Class 2A

Our Lady of the Sacred Heart lost to Sewickley Academy in the past two WPIAL title games. OLSH is in the championship again, but the opponent is different. OLSH (21-2) will play Serra (20-3) at 5 p.m. Friday.

Advertise with us

If OLSH is to win its first championship in the history of the school, it will have to control Serra’s 6-8 Jimmy Moon, who has scored 34 and 26 points in two postseason games. Moon averages 27 points a game and also double figures in rebounds.

This is Serra’s first championship appearance since 2009 and the Eagles will be after only their second WPIAL title. The other came in 2008.

Besides winning its first basketball title, OLSH can also make a different kind of history. OLSH won a WPIAL football title in November. Only 16 times has a school won basketball and football titles in the same school year. Donora was the first in 1944-45. Aliquippa was the most recent in 2015-16.

Mike White: mwhite@post-gazette.com and Twitter @mwhiteburgh