Mike White: Good Tuesday morning. Just got back from a little chat with Dwight Clay, who made The Shot that stopped UCLA's 88-game winning streak 44 years ago. Look for Dwight to be featured in our Where Are They Now special in Friday's Varsity Xtra. .... Ok I just turned on the "Open" sign in store. Let's talk.
5A Fanatic: Aside from Mars' Robby Carmody, who are some of the guards in 5A that you think can make an impact on a potential title run?
Mike White: Number of good guards on many teams. I can't sit here and name them all. Guards make things go come playoff time.
Paul MacMurdo: With the new WPIAL alignments, why do you think 3A Section 1's Lincoln Park with a +70 game section win streak, is not moved up to 4A Section 2 with Ambridge, Beaver, Blackhawk, Central Valley, Hopewell, New Castle, Quaker Valley? It seems that it's about time to give the other teams a chance at winning the section.
Mike White: Pretty simple. Because Lincoln Park's enrollment puts them in 3A. It's up to the school if they want to play up. Not up to PIAA or WPIAL. Obviously Lincoln Park doesn't want to play up.
Call It Like I See It: Mike, just a fan of 6A Basketball here. It always seems that Fox Chapel seems to get favorable draws. First, they finish 2nd in their section and end up with the 3 seed. Now, the latest section alignment looks favorable for the Foxes. Could this be that their AD is on the basketball committee? The Foxes have somehow again managed to avoid the northern 6A section. Chuck Crummie recently insinuated that something isn't right. Is there something here?
Read More
Mike White: Yes, Fox Chapel getting No. 3 seed caught the attention of many. Committee said because they played so well down stretch. You can debate that all you want. Truth be told, I don't think it was much difference. I had Fox Chapel as No. 5 seed playing No. 4 Pine in quarters. They are playing each other anyway. Yes, Fox Chapel AD Mike O'Brien is on basketball committee. That is a fact. I know they haven't wanted to play in North section before. Mike O'Brien has told me that. Why? I don't know. I don't think you can say their section was easier this year than the North. I think they might have been even.
WPIALFan1: Hi Mike. Can you provide any insight into how the WPIAL chooses a site for a game? Does it just depend on who wants to host? Does a better seed get a shorter trip? Looking at a few games and it doesn't look like the higher seed gets a closer game. Was just curious. I would like to see first two rounds at home sites, but that is just me. Thanks.
Mike White: Some of the sites sometimes make you scratch your heads. But I will tell you that it's not easy. And no matter what WPIAL does, someone will complain. It's not as easy as picking place in between two schools. Sometimes that place doesn't exist and they pick the place that they think might be best suited to handle the crowd, etc. Higher seed doesn't always get place closer to them. It's very inexact science.
CityKid820: Do you think Dice would win 6A WPIALS?
Mike White: They would be right there but I'm not going to say they would definitely win it. Yes, they could win it, but it's not like they are so much better than every 6A team.
Dice Rolls: I understand the number of 6A schools in the city league but this format to get into the state playoffs makes no sense. 2 years ago Allderdice was ranked 1 in the state and had to travel to play Erie Central Tech to get into the states. They were down two at half. Anything can happen in Erie. This year Dice is ranked in the top ten and have to travel to play Erie Mcdowell or Erie High in Erie. Last year Erie McDowell did come here last year. If Dice wins in Erie they will have to play Altoona in another play in game. That means for Allderdice to win a state title ( which is a long shot) they would have to win 7 games. Wait one second, next year Kennedy Catholic will be 6A and play in Disrict 10. That means Dice, Mcdowell, Erie High or Kennedy will not make the state playoffs. Oh by the way State college which has 3 teams in district 6 gets an automatic berth in to the states.
Mike White: Hold on. The brackets for PIAA are made up way in advance of season. Where team is ranked in state rankings has nothing to do with anything - nor should it. So rankings have nothing to do with this bracket. You just said it. Erie team came down here last year. This year it's City League's turn to travel. This happens in football also. They have these subregionals because of the number of teams in a district. I don't have a problem with it. The brackets are made by the number of teams in a district - not by who the PIAA thinks might be good or not good for upcoming seasons.
Pal: Tell me how many playoff teams will make it from 6A girls next year? I read somewhere, but can't find it now, that only 8 make it, out of 16 teams in 6A Girls. 50% rate!
Yet, I think 12 boys teams make the playoffs in 6A (out of 18), for a 66% clip. I hope I'm mistaken, but what could be WPIAL's reasoning for large difference?
Mike White: Four teams from every section make it - boys and girls. What's wrong with that? There are two sections in girls and three in boys. That's why there is a difference in number of playoff teams. There are only 16 teams in 6A girls. Kind of hard to make three sections out of that. You would have two 5's and a 6?
FAN: Mike, thoughts on 6A match-ups this weekend? Any idea when WPIAL will release sites and game times? Best game- Fox vs. Pine? PCC vs. Penn Hills? Seems to be some really intriguing match-ups... If I may recall, the teams with byes last year really struggled in quarterfinals... Do you see a repeat pattern? These teams have sat for 12-15 days...
Mike White: No idea when WPIAL will release quarterfinal sites. ... Yes, 6A playoffs are most interesting. Said all year that there are 8-9 teams that could make to a championship. With so much balance, you are going to have interesting playoffs. Some teams with byes did not win last year. Some did win. I don't think you can use a bye as an excuse. Teams can scrimmage other teams. They can simulate it to a game. Some may like a bye. Some might not. Some complain about it. Some do not. People like taking 12 teams to playoffs. Well if you're going to like that idea, then you have to have byes.
High school fan: I know it's to early right now but who do you think the 8 best teams are in class A football and class A playoff should be lot better with only 8 playoff teams
Mike White: Haven't really thought too much about it. It's basketball playoffs. But it's pretty safe to go with - in no order - Jeannette, Clairton, Imani, OLSH, Rochester. ... And yes playoffs will be better with only 8 teams. Lot of tomato cans made it in past. Not any more.
High school fan: If Jeannette wins Friday night do you think they can beat olsh
Mike White: No. Absolutely no chance. They should forfeit. It's like the Washington Generals against the Globetrotters. ... C'mon, man. Of course they have a chance.
Clairton fan: I think with class A only taking 8 teams is good and bad because I think the same 8 teams will make the playoffs almost every year and u get these teams the will miss playoff because the are in a tougher conference will use Springdale as a example the will prob never get in the playoff because they're sitting behind Jeannette clairton and imani just me I think 12 teams would if been little better
Mike White: I agree with you wholeheartedly. I had thought 12 would be OK and give a bye to top four. But that would mean four weeks of playoffs. That would mean the title game wouldn't be at Heinz. And WPIAL wants four games there.
WWH: section one 6 A had a surprising tough opening round. butler and seneca both lost and pine richland had a very tough win against a bethel park squad that was just slightly above average. Even USC gave A much better Penn Hills a big scare. Does this give even more credence to the predictions that this is the most wide open and balanced brackets in a long, long time.
Mike White: Yep, that's what everyone has said. USC and Bethel are not bad teams. Decent teams. And just goes to show that there is not a really, really strong team in 6A.
Call It Like I See It: Why hasn't NA hosted any playoff games? Too much bad warmup music or is the WPIAL retaliating for them throwing Phil Jurkovic out of a playoff game earlier this fall?
Mike White: WPIAL brass says NA doesn't want to host games. Why? I don't know. AD hasn't given me an answer yet. But the place was used for loads of games in past. I'm sure NA booster clubs and others who worked the games can't be real happy. But I don't know reason from NA yet.
Mike: Will the 6A teams that get a bye be allowed to schedule a game that week like non-playoff teams do now?
Mike White: I don't know answer to that.
Mike White: I'll take Monessen.
Hshoopsfan: Who do you have winning, monessen or Imani?
Mike White: I'll take Monessen.
hoop fan: I read your articles about North Catholic's coach Dave Long a few weeks ago. Is he coming back next year? If not, who would be a fit for that job?
Mike White: I don't know his status for next year. If he doesn't come back, I think Mike Tomlin or Joey Porter will be the new coach.
Jinx: How soon till we know the sites for 6A games?
Mike White: No idea. Up to the WPIAL. Probably by tomorrow.
Jinx: Next year how many teams from 6A will make playoffs? 4 out of 6 seems watered down
Mike White: In basketball?? Yes four from each section. But if you're going to take four from every other section in every other class, it's hard not to take four from 6A. Other classes have six-team sections. And if you're going to take four from seven-team sections, why not six? I don't have a problem with it. Not hurting anyone.
This guy's blind ^^^: How is traveling all the way to Connelsville in anyone's best interest?
Mike White: Well Connellsville has to be in someone's section. What, do you want them thrown out of the WPIAL because someone doesn't want to travel there?
Jinx: Why not have Fox Chapel in the north and Central in the east for 6A?
Mike White: Good question. But WPIAL hasn't done it that way in a while. Like I said before, Fox Chapel has made it known that it doesn't want to play in the North? Why? Not sure.
Hshoopsfan: Hey mike, who do you see winning, monessen or Imani?
Mike White: Again, I'll take Monessen.
TjDad82 : Mike, what do you know about the Khori Fusco kid from Clairton ? I seen on his AAU teams twitter account he had a unofficial visit to Div1 Mt St Mary’s last week. My son played with him in 8th grade at TJ he was unstoppable at football and basketball. In 9th grade seen him on TV at Heinz field making catches in the wpial title game. Just thought at Clairton he would take the football route.
Mike White: Very good player. Underrated. He's a junior guard. One of better junior guards around. He gave up football. Why? Not sure. It is unusual someone at Clairton giving up football to concentrate on basketball. But good for him if that's his passion.
Mike White: I would imagine you're asking Union boys vs. Eden Christian??? I like Union. Sleeper team in Class A.
WWH: In response to FAN The teams remaining in playoffs are permitted to scrimmage other teams that are stillalive. Sewickley Academy, with a bye, scrimmaged Woodland Hills and Quaker Valley -both with byes-in a three team scrimmage on Monday. Not exactly sitting for 12 - 15 days.
Mike White: Exactly. Two Number 1 seeds also scrimmaged - Mt. Lebanon and Quaker Valley. I know scrimmages still aren't the same as a game. But don't use bye as an excuse.
Pal: back to the the 6A inconsistencies for basketball playoffs...you ask what's wrong is 66% of boys teams qualify for playoffs, yet 50% of girls qualify for playoffs?...you don't see the inequity? I'm not suggesting making a 3rd section of 6A girls, but how about 5 teams per section making playoffs..That's 62.5% of teams making, still lower than boys, but closer...
Mike White: Tell your athletic director to take the idea to WPIAL.
Lavar Ball: I see the Bridgers making a good run at the championship I know they lost a lot of games towards the end but it was only by a few points I say they beat deer lakes and belle Vernon easy and then it’ll be another close one with new castle but I see them winning that matchup again what’re your thoughts?
Mike White: I don't know what to think of Ambridge. Sometimes I think they are one of the top 3-4 teams and then other times I wonder about them. They seem to be one of those teams that it wouldn't be surprising to see them in championship, but it wouldn't be surprising to see them go out in quarterfinals. I think a lot will depend on how they shoot it.
Ralph : When’s allderdice play??
Mike White: Friday most likely against McDowell. Extremely tough game. McDowell has one of the best freshmen in state. William Jeffress, 6-6, averaging 21 a game.
Hugh Jass: What do you think about Randy Cosgrove being hired as the AD at Bishop Canevin ?
Mike White: I don't really have any thoughts about it.
Doug : Why are parents so involved with the game it’s actually ruining sports let the coaches coach and the players play I’m tired of seeing it
Mike White: Because they don't understand - and never will. There are a lot of good sports parents out there, but the knucklehead ones are more and more.
Ralph : Any idea when allderdice will play?
Mike White: Friday
High school fan : Do you like Vincentian as the favorite in 1A?
Mike White: Them and Monessen.
WPIAL Lifer: 5A football gets 16 playoff spots from a pool of 24. 1A gets 8 from a pool of 23. Agreed that seeds 13-16 are not competitive, but different story with 9-10 seeds especially. Case in point: Union (9) defeated Ft. Cherry (8) this season. My vote would've been for 12, but it is what it is. All I can say is 5A games between top 4 and bottom 4 seeds better be competitive or else WPIAL will be applying a different standard for small schools vs bigger schools.
Mike White: I agree. Twelve would've been nice. But it's like I said earlier. WPIAL WANTS four games at Heinz. If they take 12 or 16 to Class 1A playoffs, they wouldn't be able to have championship at Heinz. Heinz drives a lot of this stuff.
High school fan : Top 3 players in class of 21'?
Mike White: Not even going there.
Jake: Your opinion has BBall Officiating got better or worse? Has BBall Coaches' conduct gotten better or worse? I think officiating has been pretty solid and while Coaching conduct is getting better it still needs some work.
Mike White: I think it's what it always has been. Good officiating and bad officiating. Been that way for decades. And coaches getting upset has been that way for decades. I remember covering games in 1980s, coaches would fly off the handle. It's the complaining from the fans that is the all time worst. Every call. And I think I heard for the 20,000th time last week a fan say, "Hey ref, you're missing a good game." Woooo hooo. Tremendous. So original.
Mitch C: Penn Hills not getting a bye is a joke. They beat Fox Chapel, Woody High, Latrobe, Allderdice and twice beat Lincoln park. No other 6A team has that many quality wins
Mike White: I don't have a problem with it. They finished tied for second in section. Fox Chapel played better down the stretch. Who would you bump out of a bye then??? You can say they deserved a bye. That's easy to say. But seriously, who do you bump??? The only one you can debate would be Fox Chapel because they tied in section. I think Pine-Richland has a case for getting a bye maybe even before Penn Hills.
WWH: do you see the wpial eventually going back to two officials. Shortage of refs, shortage of good refs. Two did a good job when the teams were very good back in the day.
Mike White: No way. Hard enough for three. That would make no sense. I agree there is a shortage of officials but going back to two I don't think would make matters better.
WPIAL Lifer: Crazy question, but is there any chance the first level seats will be available at the Pete for the WPIAL title games? It's a great venue but the fans are so far above the action b/c they pull in the sections across from the court level luxury boxes.
Mike White: They were available last year. But they cost more money than other seats and are available only through Pitt. But they were available last year.
Simon: Do you think Allderdice can go all the way?
Mike White: Win the state? No. Make it to the final? I would say they have a chance but won't be easy. Remember, you have to beat an eastern team in semifinals.
Alex: Hi Mike. Do you think the WPIAL football will go back to a 16 team playoff in class A? I feel 8 is a big disadvantage for a lot of schools.
Mike White: Not for the next two years. They just decided this. After two years, they will look at it.
Mike White: OK. Good stuff. We'll do this again next week at 11 on Tuesday. Maybe see you at a game. Be good.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.