Mike White: Good morning, everyone. Little bit of eventful week with the Clairton-Monessen thing. Playoff pairings for WPIAL announced tonight. City League semifinals tonight. Store is now open for business. Fire away.
Sportsmanship: Why shouldn't Clairton be banned from the playoffs? To borrow an NCAA term, there is clearly a lack of institutional control. Just look at what happened recently with their football coach (getting suspended). To me, they should get a playoff ban this time and any other violations in the next decade means they are out of the WPIAL
Mike White: There are other people who feel the same as you and I can tell you WPIAL board of directors discussed putting Clairton and Monessen both out of the playoffs. But here's the thing. I think you almost have to separate the players fight from the fans. Two players started fighting. Some players came off the benches. If that's all that would've occurred, there would've been ejections and players sitting the next game. But the fans came on the court and some fought. The feeling was that if just the players fought, they wouldn't be banned from playoffs. Why ban the teams because of stupidity from some fans. I think WPIAL got it right with not banning teams from playoffs. But my belief is that neither Clairton or Monessen should be permitted to have any fans (not even parents) through the quarterfinals and maybe semifinals. WPIAL is letting them have 30 tickets through the semifinals. Championship will be open. Just my opinion.
The South Will Rise: Mike, I have been expounding on the strengths of the Peters Girls Basketball Team lately, and how they would beat North Allegheny. I was wrong, you were right. North Allegheny defends the entire court and spreads you out on offense. That girl that was going to play softball at Pitt, she shoots real well but she makes passes like no girl I have seen. That whole NA team is strong, even their bench is strong. I think if Peters gets another crack at them, the results may be different. I had to write you to admit my mistake this time around.
Mike White: It takes a man to admit he was wrong. Ha ha. Yes, NA is good - and if they meet again NA still wins.
Gerald: Who are your coaches of the year for each classification in boys and girls basketball?
Mike White: Way too early. Playoffs matter.
Hoops Expert: Can you justify how all of a sudden Chartiers Houston is getting a bye in 2A boys, when they weren’t even in the Top 5 last week? The Top 4 was the same all year, yet Serra is now a 5? Can you explain? Do their schedules compare?
Mike White: Chartiers-Houston is a section champ. They have had some success. I think Serra might be better team but Char-Houston won a section. I think that's the reason for the No. 4. I don't think it's the biggest deal because Class A is not very good after the top 5 or so. In fact, bottom of it is bad. Plus, 4 and 5 meet in the quarterfinals. Doesn't matter much.
The Dice: If Mars were in 6A this year, how do you think they'd fair in the tough northern section?
Mike White: I think Mars would still be very good. But they might have one or maybe two more losses. But don't kid yourself. Mars played a very good schedule out of the section.
The Dice: Why doesn't the WPIAL have the higher seed host first round games?
Mike White: Because that's not what they do. It has been talked about in past years, but league hasn't pulled the trigger on it. I don't think it would be a bad thing, but I don't know if it's needed.
Pal: Section reconfiguration.....Who do you think is the 8th team in the North Section in 6A girls next year?
Mike White: Haven't really thought about it.
Pal: Continued, Section reconfiguration....These 7 teams have to be in the north next year, 6A girls...SV, NA, NH, Shaler, FC, Butler and PR... Who is 8th in your opinion...Peters? Baldwin? Connellsville?
Mike White: Section alignments for hoops come out Tuesday.
BigMac: Mike, multiple media outlets have Canon Mac as an 8... They're the only team with 20 wins and certainly deserve a pass for the Baldwin defeat... I understand where others may believe that they lost the bye opportunity, but all the way to an 8? As for the strength of schedule, this is high school, they can't really control that... I like them at no less than 6 playing Latrobe...
Mike White: Ahhh, sorry but they can control strength of schedule. Let's be honest. Out of section schedule was not good. That doesn't help. Other teams played a much stronger non-section schedule. Losing to Baldwin didn't help. If they are an 8, I have no problem with it. You can make points in Canon-Mac's favor, but you can also make points for the 7 teams ranked ahead of them.
Guest: Your predictions for girls and boys Wpial champs
Mike White: They'll be in paper tomorrow.
Sleepy: Mike, it's obvious that 6A is loaded... Can you give me a darkhorse? The two teams that arrive in the finals will certainly deserve it... I see you have Pine at the 4 and Fox at the 5... That's a heck of a 2nd round match-up!
Mike White: Foxes were playing as well as anyone in 6A. I know WPIAL doesn't look at all at last night's games, but Central beating Fox Chapel says something. It's what I've been saying all along this season. There are 8 or 9 teams in 6A where it wouldn't surprise me if any one of them made the championship, and it wouldn't surprise me if they lost in the quarterfinals. And that includes the top four seeds.
Mike White: 6A field this year is the result of a lack of a really, really good team, parity ... but also the fact that there are a number of pretty good teams.
Mikey : Possible Butler/Latrobe in Round 1... Holy Crap! What say you?
Mike White: Yes, that's what I have. Really good game. You'll see some really good guards -- Ethan Morton, Reed Fenton, Bryce Butler. Should be one of the top first-round games.
guyin412: What does the WPIAL committee use to determine seeding in the playoffs? section/overall record? strength of schedule/section?
Mike White: All of the above.
WPIAL Hoops Guy: Mike, Who do you feel would be the 1 seed on the boys' side that would have the "best" chance of winning gold at the Pete. Obviously, I know they all would have a decent chance, but is there 1 teams head and shoulders above the others in their classification?
Mike White: Probably Quaker Valley, but no way they are head and shoulders above everyone else. Lincoln Park would be second choice.
WPIAL Hoops Guy: I know the WPIAL Hoops committee met to make new sections yesterday for the '18-'19 and '19-'20 seasons. Do you think there is any chance the "spread the wealth" to try and eliminate power sections? Blackhawk, the 6th place team in Class 4A, Section 2, beat South Fayette (at SF), the 2nd place team in their section. They also beat Seneca Valley. Unfortunately, as the sections stand now they have little chance to make the playoffs.
Mike White: Can't predict what WPIAL will do, but they do try to use geography a lot. But I understand what you're saying.
Concerned Citizen: What is to prevent a Monessen or Clairton fan to go to their opponent's school to purchase a playoff ticket for a game? If someone really wants to get to the game they can still do it.
Mike White: Nothing. But I don't think I'd show up at the ticket window at other school with Clairton or Monessen gear on.
Mike White: My idea was only students from opposing school could buy tickets. They could buy them for their own adults, but a student from that school would still have to purchase them.
Jacob rich : Mike. Where do you see pine Richland and Butler in the playoff seeding tonight ?
Mike White: Pine-Richland 4 and Butler 7, playing Latrobe.
RGW: Wondering which Seneca Valley team is going to show up in the playoffs. The one that barely beat Shaler or the one that went into Pine and Butler and won. I still expect Pine to come out on top in 6A but it looks pretty wide open.
Mike White: Seneca Valley is another one of those teams playing extremely well entering the playoffs. They are healthy now. Watch our for Victor Giannotta "Dry Eye In The House" in the playoffs. I think they are a sleeper.
HSBballFan: I wonder if the WPIAL should do more to address game day logistics such as not having fans seated behind team benches. Thoughts?
Mike White: That's hard to do. Not like these places have 5,000 seats. You put one team's fans on one side and the other team's on the other side. You starting trying to put a line down the middle and have both team's fans on one side, you might have a bigger problem. no need to.
HSBballFan: 30 out of 155 teams in this years boys and girls WPIAL basketball tournament are parochial or public charter schools. Some feel that these schools should be separated from traditional public schools. Your thoughts?
Mike White: The subject has been beaten to death, written to death. Until the PIAA wants to change, nothing is going to change. I don't feel like talking about it again right now.
X: Do you think Pine Richland can be as good (not go as far, be as good) as last year's team? Seems to be a good strategy if the game is tight late against PR would be to put their bigs on the line.
Mike White: I like P-R's chances. In fact, if I had to pick a 6-A favorite right now, I'd pick P-R. Are they as good as last year? I think the playoffs will determine that. I really like the improvement and play of Dan Petcash, especially.
ParticipationTrophy: Mike, not sure I've ever seen the trend that I am seeing this year, teams cutting down the net when they win a section championship. I feel we are really over doing the celebrations now, its a section championship, not a WPIAL or PIAA championship! It should be the expectation, not the end game. Thoughts???
Mike White: Depends on the school. If you haven't won a section title in maybe 30 years, why not? Even though I might not do it. But hey, let the kids have some fun. But if you've won section titles in recent years, I'd say no.
Sportsman: Who is your all-time WPIAL starting 5 if you had to win one game ?
Mike White: Would need time to think. Live chat doesn't leave you time.
The Dice: Who are the WPIALs best shot to win states this year?
Mike White: Class 4A and 2A. I wouldn't expect more than one title, though. Maybe zero. Two would be sensational.
Wonder: Mike, do you believe the Classes that have first round byes will have a similar schedule to last season? I.E. most teams with a first round bye had a 10-11 day layoff
Mike White: Pairings come out tonight, Yes, I bet some teams that finished regular season last Friday will have as much as a two-week layoff. It is what it is. Some coaches have suggested let the regular season go a few days longer and cram the playoffs together more. There is not an easy way to do this.
Ironman: Butler beats PR. PR beats Central and Central beats Butler. I know, I know you believe any team could win it all but the favorite could should and would be PR. Is there any team in the other conferences that could hold against the northern teams. Lebo? Latrobe?
Mike White: No way Pine-Richland deserves No. 1 seed. They didn't win section. I know Jurkovec missed some and Kristofic missed some. But they still didn't win the section. Central did. I believe Pine is the favorite. Doesn't mean they should be No. 1 seed.
Ace Heb: Mr. White, do you think its time to get rid of the antiquated system of the Basketball Playoff Pairings meeting? Brackets were completed yesterday, why have teams all meet a night later to find out who they will play. With online film, shouldn't they just release them online at 9pm on Monday? The football meeting in the fall was very under attended, I will be curious to see if tonight is the same
Mike White: Yes and no. I agree they could've released brackets last night. But there is some housekeeping things sometimes that it's nice to have everyone there. Like ticket packages, giving each team playoff basketballs. Plus, they hand out section championship plaques. But I agree, the brackets could be released on line. But then coaches couldn't complain to Tim O'Malley face to face.
Dartman: Thoughts on follow the leader format to get into PIAA tournament
Mike White: I hate it. Play them off.
WPAsportsfan: What Class A school do you believe really has a chance to make a run this year in the WPIAL boys tournament?
SpartanLife: With the rumors of Tim O'Malley retiring at the end of this year, who is the next in line from the circle of trust? Any way we can talk you in to throwing your hat in the ring? #Mwhite2019
Mike White: First off, WPAsports fan, there are 5 teams or so in Class A. Monessen, VIncentian have to be the top two choices. But don't forget Union. They beat Vincentian. Clairton not bad, either. And I don't know what to think of Propel, Eden and Imani. They tied for section title. And remember, Imani was in championship last year.
Zaza : Does franklin seem like a lock for the 2 seed now?
Mike White: It seems like it. The win against McKeesport last Friday might have done it. FR and Highlands tied for section title, but beating McKeesport might have put FR over the top.
RGW: I'm guessing the only people who know are the ones in the room but any idea what caused the CWNC coaching issue? My feeling is disgruntled parents and the AD jumped the gun on a suspension. If something really bad happened he wouldn't have been back so soon.
Mike White: Apparently some kind of issue with a player. But it's over with now. Coach Long is back. Will he be there next season??? That's a good question.
Joe: Any idea where the semi-final game sites would be for 5a?
Mike White: No idea. Depends who is in them.
Chad : Who do you think is most talented team in the wpial?
Mike White: Well I'm going to say in Western Pa. and I think it just might be Allderdice. As far as WPIAL, that's a tough call. I wouldn't feel comfortable saying one team is the best. I don't think one stands out.
Old Spartan: Mike, a couple weeks ago there was discussion regarding instituting a shot clock in high school. What do you think of the alternatives of the 4 points shot line at 30 feet (I saw that the Globetrotters are doing this) and/or re-instituting the 35 foot line and rule to speed up the game? Both would be a lot less costly.
Mike White: I think free throws should be worth 5 points, 3-pointers seven and half court shots 10. Let's just totally lose our minds. ... But I do think shot clock is a good idea.
WPIAL2k18: Will the WPIAL avoid having Franklin and highlands play in the semis because of the malae that went on last game?
Mike White: Good question, but I don't think it should. It wasn't like Monessen-Clairton. And if you are going to do true seedings, I think they should be 2 and 3.
WPAsportsfan: You mention Propel (Andrew Street) in Class A. It’s only their 2nd year in the WPIAL and already have back-to-back playoff appearances and now a co-section championship. Head Coach and former West Mifflin HS standout Christopher Giles is building something special over there, wouldn’t you say?
Mike White: Special??? Let's take it easy.
Mike White: OK everyone. That's it for now. Check Post-Gazette web site tonight for seedings and news from pairings meeting. Everyone, be good.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.