Mike White: Here we go. Store is now open for business. Fire away.

Marshall: A question came up about the Fabulous Five. If you have great player on a great team that is only getting the opportunity to play around 20 minutes a game because they are blowing everyone out. Obviously that great player will be putting up less points then perhaps a lesser players that is playing in close games. How do you and the other writers that select the Fabulous Five balance those things.

Mike White: It's not all about points. It's about players. If it were just about points, we'd just take the leading scorers. Right off the top of my head, I'll use two years ago as an example. We put Ramon Creighton of Allderdice on Fab 5. He averaged 13 points a game. In WPIAL there is no team that beats EVERYONE in blowouts. Go look at any of past Fab 5's. It's not all about points.

2AFootballFan: Mike, during the realignment process, any explanation as to why North Catholic got placed in the division they did? A lot of long travel days for the Trojans.

Advertise with us

Mike White: Yep, lot of travel for some other teams in 3A. I'm not saying I agree with everything WPIAL did, but it looks like in 3A they used a little geography and maybe also some competitive balance. Long, long road trips. This is one of by products with 6A. Plus, it makes it a little hard when you have only two conferences in a class.

John: How can the WPIAL justify having two conference teams 91 miles apart when Altoona is no longer a member of the WPIAL?

Mike White: Well, maybe you are talking 3A with Waynesburg and Uniontown. All I would say is this. If you look at Uniontown and I have some figures. Of the other 16 teams in 3A besides Uniontown, nine of them are at least 60 miles from Uniontown. So no matter what, Uniontown was going to have to travel. A few others are at least 40 miles from Uniontown. As for Waynesburg, 11 schools in 3A are at least 58 miles from Waynesburg. So no matter what WPIAL did, Waynesburg was going to have to travel.

Gcc fan: Do u think anyone in AA can beat Sewickley Academy and what do u think about the class A football conferences hands down the Eastern Conference is the toughest

Mike White: Yes, someone "can" beat Sewickley. They are very good for 2A, but no one is unbeatable. Tonight should be interesting. They play AT OLSH, ranked No. 2. I'm not saying Sewickley won't win WPIAL, but they aren't unbeatable.

Advertise with us

High school fan: I think they should split up Jeannette Clairton and Imani Christian them 3 team are the 3 best in class A other than California no one has a chance

Mike White: Well high school fan, some want geogrpahy conferences, some want competitive balance. In this case in Class 1A, WPIAL went mostly with geography. I said "mostly"

WPIAL Lifer: I don't envy the decisions that the WPIAL is faced with regarding football playoffs. Half of the classes now have less than 20 teams which makes a 16-team playoff hard to justify (and downright impossible in 9-team 6A). Here's a suggestion from the peanut gallery: 16-team playoffs for 5A (24 teams), 2A (31 teams) and 1A (23 teams); 8-team playoffs for 6A, 4A & 3A. Let the PIAA brackets then determine how many title games can be played at Heinz. Just so many different factors at play....

Mike White: That's very likely what they will do, except I'm not totally sure there will be 16 in Class A because league has recognized many first-round games in Class 1A are blowouts with 16 teams. Whole key is PIAA playoffs. One thing I would look for, though, is a 16-team bracket in 5A - and th 5A championship might not be at Heinz Field. Possibility of only three title games at Heinz. Question then is where do you put 5A championship?

demosthenes98: How will WPIAL football non-conference games work the next two years? Will teams only be allowed to play other teams in their classification, or what?

Advertise with us

Mike White: It's up to each individual school if they want to play a game in Week 0. School can play whoever they want. Starting in week 1, WPIAL schedules all games, including non-conference. There will be crossover games in conferences. In 6A, there are 9 teams. They need a ninth game. So, WPIAL will schedule them one non-conference game against a 5A team. Tim O'Malley said yesterday no one wants to play Central, Pine or North Allegheny.

Jerry: Mike - with Jeannette and Serra playing a thriller last week that went into double OT, what do you give both their chances of a deep playoff run this season?

Mike White: I think they can go far. But Sewickley is still team to beat. Again, will be interesting what happens in Sewickley-OLSH game tonight.

Stack56 : Mike I know it's only Tuesday but who do you like in the big Westinghouse vs Allderdice game Friday night?

Mike White: Haven't seen The House and 6-11 James Ellis yet. But it's good to see a little resurgence with some teams in City basketball. The House, Carrick having some of best seasons in school history. I'll go with Allderdice in a close one against Westinghouse.

Advertise with us

Jim: I thought that the schoonmaker kid from Washington could of maybe picked up a pitt offer and played there, or is that too far of a stretch?

Mike White: Good player. No knock against him. But I think the MAC is a good level for him.

Wpial hoops: Do you think section 1 in 5a boys is the most competitive ? Trinity and McKeesport are both solid and the lower teams competing for a playoff spot such as LH and W. Mifflin are solid. They both can play w anybody, LH beat Latrobe and WM has kept it close w quality teams like CWNC and Gateway

Mike White: No, I do not. Section 1 is OK, but no way I'd say it's the most competitive. That section has a few bad teams also. West Mifflin can't score. Ringgold and TJ are not good. The Char Valley-Moon-Mars section isn't as strong as last year. I don't think any section in 5A is great this year. 5A isn't as good as last year.

Mixmaster: Is Dan Petcash the best player on Pine Richland?

Advertise with us

Mike White: Might be best basketball player. I don't know if there is another WPIAL junior whose game has gone up so drastically from one season to the next. But I'd never pass on taking Phil Jurkovec in any sports game.

Stack56 : Mike I know Football is king and you did a weekly segment on Starkey and Mueller are they going to have you on to talk basketball? Some of us in Western PA enjoy basketball talk. I wish there was more.

Mike White: Funny you ask. Most likely starting a basketball segment either this week or next week on The Fan. Tentatively Thursdays.

Tony : Lebo, good?

Mike White: Pretty good. Not great. No size. Bunch of guards who press and trap everywhere and shoot lot 3's. Joe David playing a style I don't know if I've ever seen him play. But it's working.

Advertise with us

WPIAL Lifer: Biggest game of regular season in 1A girls this Friday: West Greene at Winchester-Thurston, non-section 1vs2. Any plans this Friday Mr. White?!?

Mike White: Yes, I have plans. But they don't include West Greene-Winchester Thurston.

Stack56 : Tony Lebo plays at Allderdice tomorrow night should be a good one

Mike White: Yes, Dice plays Westinghouse Friday and Mars Monday. Without a doubt, some interesting games.

Big Mac: Does Canon Mac boys bball after years of underperforming have a shot at Section or WPIAL titles?

Advertise with us

Mike White: Underperformed last year?? Made the WPIAL quarterfinals. Gave Pine-Richland a game. I don't think that's underperforming. Big Macs are 10-1 this year. One game behind Lebo in section. I don't think there is a runaway favorite in 6A this year. Penn Hills has to be the favorite right now. But I think things are pretty open. No WPIAL team has chance of winning state title in 6A but the WPIAL playoffs should be interesting because of the balance. No great team. But number of decent teams. Lebo at Canon-Mac next Tuesday.

WPIAL Lifer: Oh well...too far down the food chain! Still, should be good game and potential finals preview. Switching gears....any insight on the college-level potential for Cali Konek now that she's local again?

Mike White: Have not seen her this year. Definitely Div. 1. Already a few offers. Not high Div. 1, though.

WPIAL North: Ambridge vs. Quaker Valley tonight. Huge matchup. Ambridge tough to beat at home especially if they shoot like they did against NC. Hilzendeger has infinite range on his shot.

Mike White: But game is at Quaker Valley. Ambridge resurgence under the venerable Mark Jula. He's Ambridge grad. Quaker Valley has one of best coaches in WPIAL even if a lot of people don't realize it - Mike Mastroianni. I'm anxious to see Hilzendeger. But I'm going QV. In fact, I'm going QV all the way to a WPIAL title. if you're going to QV tonight, get there early. Might be worst place for parking in all of WPIAL. Gotta go to that neighborhood parking.

Advertise with us

WPIAL North: Mother nature always plays a role in spring sports. Amazing how much it is affecting basketball though! Some teams will have three or even four section games in a week. Union plays section games on three consecutive days (from weather combined with the Holy Family bussing fiasco)

Mike White: Yes, but this happens in a number of winters. If Union is playing three section games in three days, that's their fault. They schedule the makeup games.

Mike White: I don't disagree with you, but that ight go a little to the competitive balance angle. Know what I mean? For example, if you take Penn Hills out of conference 3 and place them into conference 1, that puts Woodland HIlls, Penn Hills, Bethel Park, West Allegheny and Upper St. Clair in one conference. That's a killer conference. Then the conference in the north would be a little weak. Plus, you have balance with three eight team conferences. Maybe Penn Hills, Woody High and Gateway can play in non-conference. WPIAL will tell you non-conference is done at random. I say no way.

WPIAL Lifer: Thanks. And how strange/ironic for Southmoreland this year: lose Kevin Stone to out-of-state prep school and get Konek from out-of-state prep school. Unrelated I'm sure, but quite the interesting revolving door nonetheless.

Mike White: You are the most interesting "chatter" on here. Stay thirsty, my friend. But It's Brandon Stone.

Advertise with us

Big Mac: Like the move for North Hills to play up in 6A next year? Shaler choose to not play up? Which would you do if you were in charge?

Mike White: I can see either way for North Hills. Keep some natural rivalries in 6A. If you go 5, you're still doing to have what might be a tough section with Mars, Hampton, Moon, Char Valley maybe. Plus, it's not forever. If they are 5A in two years and they wish, then maybe they can play 5A then.

Ship em: What happened at Perry? you think combining them and the old Oliver would have them dominating, they are getting beat by 35 a game!!

Mike White: It really is unbelievable what has happened to that program? Rod Rutherford is coaching football now, but that program also has long, long way to go. I don't have the answer as to what happened at Perry, except to say this: I've seen Perry basketball play once past couple years (not this year). There isn't anything there in terms of talent.

PJ: I agree PH, Gateway and Woody High have to play non conference, but we all know that when it comes to the WPIAL rivalries don't really matter.

Advertise with us

Mike White: I don't know why you say that? With six classes, rivalries have been lost. But WPIAL didn't pick to go to six classes.

WPIAL Lifer: Always thirsty, if not accurate with first names. Last chatter offering for the week: enjoyed the compilation on shot clock last week. Question: would any shot clock mandate have to come from PIAA level or do Districts have some flexibility, at least during regular season and/or District playoffs?

Mike White: 99 percent sure it has to come from PIAA level. And no way you could "experiment" in playoffs.

wpial guy: Big win for Butler last night, does that win change how you look at how they will finish the season, one of the better in 6A?

Mike White: Well WPIAL guy, they have been in top five since early in season. And they will stay there. Butler beat Central; Central beat Pine; Pine beat Butler. Go figure. Like I said before, I think 6A has a number of good teams this year. Not a great, great team. Butler is one of the good teams and has a chance to make playoff run, mainly because of Ethan Morton. But there is such a fine line with many 6A teams. It wouldn't surprise me if Butler went far in the playoffs, but it also wouldn't surprise me if they lost early or in quarterfinals.

Advertise with us

tigerpaul: Why not use shot clock in tourneys and events like the PGH Basketball Classic, those games are showcases, players and fans would love it, not so sure about the coaches

Mike White: As the story said last week, most coaches want it. But again, we're getting back to costs. Gyms have to have shot clock system., even for experiments.

Big Mac: Morton-Butler, Jurkovec-PR, Carmody-Mars. Who's the best?

Mike White: Well that's easy. Carmody the best player right now. He's a senior. But Morton is the best for the future in WPIAL. Morton and Carmody are different players. But they are alike in that they do so many things for their team.

WPIAL Lifer: TIGER PAUL LIVES!!!

Advertise with us

Mike White: It's a miracle.

Mike White: And bring back Mossie Murphy, too.

WPIAL Lifer: they can play one-on-one and Deuce will keep the book...as long as it's not played in Uniontown!

Mike White: And Ace will officiate.

Mike White: And did you know there is an establishment on Fifth Ave. in Uptown called Ace's and Deuce's. I talked to the owner to change the name to Heberling's and Skurcenski's.

Mike White: And on that one, I'm out of here. Be good, everyone. Next Tuesday at 11.