With two extremely talented players ranked among the top 150 juniors in the country and another future Division I college player, Kennedy Catholic very likely could be the best high school basketball team in Western Pennsylvania, regardless of classification.
But Kennedy Catholic also might be the most controversial.
Kennedy Catholic is a small school in Hermitage, just outside the WPIAL. The Eagles are the two-time defending PIAA Class 1A champions and the Eagles are getting big-time players from outside the state for various reasons. The situation at Kennedy Catholic is creating even more critics of private and parochial schools that have no geographic boundaries to draw students. But what the Kennedy Catholic situation is proving once again is that different high school governing bodies around the state have drastically different views on the PIAA rule concerning transfers for athletic intent.
If what is going on at Kennedy Catholic occurred at a WPIAL school, such as Central Catholic, there would most likely be a public outcry from teams, coaches and fans. But District 10 (Erie area) has approved the eligibility for Kennedy Catholic transfers.
And Kennedy Catholic coach Rick Mancino says the transfers aren’t for basketball reasons.
“I don’t discuss this a lot because you’re not going to win the argument,” said Mancino. “We don’t cheat or do anything illegal. These kids pay [tuition] just like all of our kids. Or someone pays for them. We don’t give kids anything.
“People make it sound like we’re recruiting. But the thing we have to offer is we have a high rate of students go to college. I think kids like it when they come here. We’re a small school and people treat each other well. I know people don’t want to hear that and I understand people look at the kids coming here. I understand the argument. But we have had a lot of local kids who have made a difference, too.”
It has been well-documented how transferring of schools is rampant among athletes in the Philadelphia area. The PIAA hears many complaints about the Philadelphia schools and those same complaints are now being heard about Kennedy Catholic.
Well, let’s lay out the facts about the situations of two new Kennedy Catholic players and you decide if there is reason for coaches and fans to complain.
• Oscar Tshiebwe transferred to Kennedy Catholic for this school year from Mountain Mission School in Grundy, Va. He is a 6-foot-9 power forward who is ranked the No. 75 junior in the country by Rivals.com and has numerous major-college scholarship offers. According to Mancino, Jeff Kollar and his wife became the legal guardians of Tshiebwe.
The Kollars live near Kennedy Catholic and Mancino said the family likes to take in high school students to help them. It’s merely a coincidence they are basketball players. A few years ago, the Kollars took in the Konate brothers. Sagaba Konate helped Kennedy win a PIAA title in 2016 and is now a 6-8 sophomore starter at West Virginia University. His younger brother, Mohamed, helped Kennedy win a PIAA title last year.
By the way, it has been reported that West Virginia is one of Tshiebwe’s top schools. Coincidentally, West Virginia also is one of Maceo Austin’s top schools. Austin is a 6-5 junior guard at Kennedy Catholic who is ranked among the top 150 juniors in the country. Austin has been at Kennedy Catholic since his freshman year.
• Mattia Acunzo is a 6-8 junior forward for Kennedy Catholic who also is a Division I prospect. Acunzo is from Italy and came to Kennedy Catholic this school year by way of a foreign exchange program. Mancino said Kennedy Catholic always has foreign exchange students.
Oh, by the way. Acunzo played AAU basketball this summer for Bridge City in Pittsburgh. One of his teammates was, coincidentally, Austin. And in another coincidence, Tom Droney, former Sewickley Academy star, is in his first season as a Kennedy Catholic assistant. Droney was one of Bridge City’s coaches.
“I understand the private schools might have a little edge, but there are some [public] schools and Philadelphia schools that get players, too,” said Mancino. “I’m not throwing stones and some people say there should be two divisions for public schools and then everyone else. That’s fine. But you have to look at some public schools in this also.”
Mancino has a good point. Public schools also get players move into their district for whatever reason. But if Kennedy Catholic was in the WPIAL, a player such as Tshiebwe would seemingly have trouble becoming eligible.
“These kids did have a hearing [with District 10],” said Mancino. “They interviewed the kids. They were approved.”
There are those who believe talented players coming from out of state is good for basketball in Pennsylvania and Western Pennsylvania. Maybe, but the point in this whole situation is many public school teams really don’t want to play the Kennedy Catholics of the world. Kennedy Catholic very likely will knock a WPIAL team out of the PIAA playoffs.
This situation isn’t going to change. The PIAA continues to show no desire to change its transfer rules, despite the fact that those rules are applied differently in different areas of the state.
Kennedy Catholic is not going to go away. The Eagles are Class 1A in enrollment, but will play “up” in 6A starting next season. The reason for the change, according to Mancino, is because there won’t be many league games for Kennedy to play during the regular season. That will allow the Eagles to play more games outside the district and outside the state.
“It bothers me when people say I’m breaking the rules,” said Mancino. “We haven’t broken any rules.”
Mike White: mwhite@post-gazette.com and Twitter @mwhiteburgh.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.