When he first saw Fox Chapel Golf Club while playing in the Senior Players Championship in 2012, eight-time major champion Tom Watson called it a “hidden gem” and said the shot values that are required at the classic Seth Raynor design are “sensational.”

So why would anyone want to disturb that?

Well, the people in charge at Fox Chapel thought they needed to restore some of the original Raynor design techniques by re-positioning, adding and even unearthing old bunkers that were part of the original design when the course was built in 1923. And it was the club’s vice president, Tom Reading, who is also chairman of the greens committee, who pushed for the restoration shortly after the Senior Players Championship concluded a three-year run at the course.

“We quickly realized we had to re-invest in our golf course,” Reading said.

Advertise with us

So, with the blessing of its membership, the club hired Fazio Design to perform the restoration and hoped its hidden gem would be turned into a crown jewel. Tom Marzolf, Fazio’s senior design associate, was in charge of the project.

“We’ve known for a long time we’ve had something special here at Fox Chapel,” Reading said. “We couldn’t be more thrilled. We’re very enthusiastic with what we’ve done.”

There is always an inherent risk, not to mention some internal squabbling among resistant members, when a course the quality of Fox Chapel wants to undergo a major change. But the object was not to reroute holes or even lengthen the 6,707-yard layout. In fact, the club rejected an offer from the Fazio team to add more yardage to the course. “That’s not what Fox Chapel is about,” said club president James “Lock” Walrath.

If anything, the club did the opposite, adding 18 new forward tees to allow members to play from an even shorter distance, if desired. That became important when Marzolf restored 16 original bunkers to the layout, including unearthing the exact spot of the “Lions Mouth” bunker on No. 9 that had been grown over years ago.

Fox Chapel unveiled its finished product last week to members of the local and national golf media.

Advertise with us

“We hoped people will accept it; we hope people will like it,” Marzolf said. “That can be very subjective.”

The most dramatic additions are at No. 4, the 480-yard par-4 known as the “Road Hole,” where Raynor’s signature greenside bunker was restored to cover an extended portion of the green; and the 421-yard sixth where three cross bunkers were placed in the middle of the fairway to create a bottleneck effect. Thirteen of the 96 bunkers on the course are on that hole, known as “The Bottle.”

Also, the infamous Biarrtiz hole — the 231-yard par-3 17th with the deep swale cutting through an 85-yard-long putting surface — had a new framing bunker added in front of the green.

Marzolf said it can be a delicate task trying to honor Raynor’s original design during a restoration.

“We want people to say that looks like the original architect, not, ‘It looks like Fazio was here,’” Marzolf said. “We wanted to make sure we were building Raynor.”

Advertise with us

Alternating plans

This wasn’t as good as finding out you got into a U.S. Open as an alternate, especially in your hometown, which Mike Van Sickle once did. But getting into a 36-hole sectional qualifier as an alternate — with a chance to go to the U.S. Open — isn’t a bad thing, either. Other than the last-minute preparations.

That’s what happened to Van Sickle, a former Pennsylvania Open and West Penn Open champion who found out Tuesday night he got into a sectional qualifier in Atlanta on Monday as a second alternate.

“I’m hoping for a little 2016 Open magic,” Van Sickle said.

Van Sickle, a mini-tour professional who operates a golf lesson and simulator business called “No Offseason,” missed getting one of the four spots at the 18-hole local qualifier at Butler Country Club last month when he finished sixth. But he won a playoff with Beau Titsworth to finish as the second alternate. Rob McClellan, who lost a playoff with Louis Olsakovsky for the fourth and final spot, was the first alternate.

Advertise with us

The USGA initially contacted McClellan, who is director of golf at Slippery Rock Golf Club, to tell him he was in the field at the Piedmont Driving Club in Atlanta as the first alternate. But McClellan said he declined the invitation because it was logistically difficult at the last minute.

That paved the way for Van Sickle to get in as the second alternate. Van Sickle is the most recent player to advance from a local qualifier in Western Pennsylvania to make it to the U.S. Open, though he did it as a first alternate in 2016 when the championship was held at Oakmont.

Van Sickle thought he missed an opportunity to play in his hometown when he lost a three-man playoff for the final two spots in a sectional qualifier at Woodmont Country Club in Rockville, Md. But he got the call from the USGA on the Sunday before the tournament, telling him he was in.

And he’s not going to pass up this opportunity to get into the U.S. Open that will be played June 17-20 at Torrey Pines South Course in San Diego.

“You never know what can happen,” Van Sickle said. “If I get an opportunity to get in, I’m going to take it.”

Advertise with us

Stiff competition 

Jimmy Ellis didn’t have to worry about a phone call from the USGA to see if he made it to a sectional qualifier. He took care of that when he was the only player under par and medalist at the 18-hole qualifier at Butler.

Now he is in the field at the 36-hole sectional qualifier in Columbus, Ohio, where many PGA Tour players who are competing in the Memorial will try to qualify for the U.S. Open. Among the players in that field are past major champions Jason Day, Keegan Bradley, Jason Dufner, Charl Schwartzel and Padraig Harrington, in addition to PGA Tour winners Rickie Fowler, Charley Hoffman and J.B. Holmes and four members of the U.S. Walker Cup team.

“The field is ridiculous, but it’s going to be fun,” said Ellis, an amateur from South Hills Country Club who is making his first appearance in a sectional qualifier.

Carnegie Mellon teammates Jason Li and Ben Huber, who also qualified at Butler, are in the field at Columbus. Li is paired with Harrington, a three-time major champion and captain of the 2021 European Ryder Cup team; Huber is playing with Korn Ferry Tour player Andres Gonzales and four-time Champions Tour winner Woody Austin.

Advertise with us

Palmer Jackson of Murrysville, who will be a junior at Notre Dame, is also at Columbus. He received an exemption into the sectional after being a quarterfinalist in the 2019 U.S. Amateur.

Quotable

The late, great columnist Jim Murray, describing the trappings that lurk at the Olympic Club, site of the U.S. Women’s Open: “It’s not a golf course; it’s a vampire. Maybe it turns into a bat at midnight.”

Listen to “The Golf Show with Gerry Dulac” every Thursday, 7-830 p.m., on ESPN Pittsburgh