Hearing it for the first and only time, I could not keep from tilting my head sideways like a dog hearing its first kazoo.

Cris Collinsworth blurted it out during NBC’s Sunday Night Football broadcast, and it might have been the first time in the history of language, spoken or written, that these four words got themselves arranged sequentially:

“That is fantastic officiating!”

Wait, what?

Advertise with us

Houston’s DeAndre Hopkins had just been stopped at the Dallas 1 by Cowboys safety Jeff Heath, even as it looked to everyone including Collinsworth and venerated play-by-play partner Al Michaels that Hopkins’ momentum and the football had penetrated the end zone.

As they described the apparent touchdown, replay confirmed, as it will, that Hopkins’ progress had actually terminated right where referee Bill Vinovich’s crew said it had, at the 1.

I knew that the NFL, after years of patronizing the argument, now had full-time officials, or at least some, but I never imagined we’d arrive at fantastic officiating so soon after leaving nowhere-near-fantastic officiating.

“First of all, saying these guys are full-time is really a misnomer; they simply are not full-time,” said Terry McAulay, who was an NFL official for 20 years before retiring to take the rules expert gig with NBC this summer. “Most of them have other jobs. Some are retired. But they don’t work as a full-time employee all week. What (the league) got out of it is the ability to bring them into New York or to assign them to OTA’s or minicamp without getting permission from the NFLRA (the officials’ union). It varies as to how many times people go into New York, some go in every week or every other week, some go in once a month.

“I think mostly it’s public relations, to be honest. They get to put out communiqués: ‘Well, we have 24 full-time officials!’ who, unfortunately, make the same mistakes the other 86 make.”

Advertise with us

The league would not make anyone available to explain the genesis or purpose of having nearly 20 percent of its officials be “full-time,” but McAulay at least cleared up something at the root of the primary counterargument, often voiced in this column as “What the hell are they going to do all week?”

Apparently I’d been thinking of the full-time official’s job in the wrong terms (what are the odds?).

I’d pictured somebody having to arrange office space at 345 Park Avenue for dozens of additional employees who’d arrive in Gotham maybe on Tuesday and remain through the day shift Thursday during the season, Monday through Friday thereafter. At the office – and good luck finding parking – they’d not only be doing whatever the league had in mind to improve their performance (that was the point, right?), but they’d be expected to function productively in the office setting, which is always, at best, rife with tedium.

What is veteran line judge Jeff Bergman going to do, for example, if he draws Roger Goodell in the Secret Santa thing? Does long-time back judge Greg Meyer really have to buy some Girl Scout cookies from the daughter of the person in the next cubicle? Does referee Walt Anderson have to start his day deleted email blasts about jammed printers and missing earrings?

How weird is it that the same guys who blew the calls on Sunday are talking about it at the water cooler on Tuesday? Doesn’t seem natural.

Advertise with us

Though the league had pondered the idea of full-time officials for decades, it did nothing formally until securing a new collective bargaining agreement with the NFLRA after a 2012 lockout of more than 100 days.

“Originally, in the CBA, it said the league could do up to 17 folks as far as full-time,” said Scott Green, the longtime official who’s been union president since 2016. “They never did anything. They sort of talked about in ‘13 and ‘14 and it came to fruition I guess two years ago, but we go from the premise that our guys, from July to the Super Bowl, all 121 guys are full time. The amount of time and effort that everybody puts in is certainly comparable to a full-time job. What we see here with this opportunity is generally from the Super Bowl to May 15, a kind of down period for most of our officials. This new approach permits, voluntarily – it’s not compulsory -- guys to provide whatever services the NFL wants.

“The major emphasis is really on the offseason.”

For the 24 officials now designated full-time, the only real impact is that the league can now require their services year-round on 48 hours notice, meaning they can otherwise keep their day jobs as pilots, CEO’s, attorneys, engineers, insurance brokers, sales reps, realtors, educators, financial advisors, CPA’s, athletic directors, developers, technical writers, probation officers, etc.

It’s this offseason emphasis that appears to have the most upside.

Advertise with us

“Maybe they should have some offseason things where some players watch tape with officials and kind of explain the game,” said Steelers All Pro guard David DeCastro, who admitted he was not aware there were full-time officials. “Maybe have some coaches do that. Maybe some calls don’t need to be called because they don’t affect the play, they’re away from the play. Do we really call that? We hold every play, let’s be honest.”

I know. And pass defenders interfere on every play, let’s be honest, even if that group isn’t quite as forthcoming.

“I agree that defensive pass interference is one of the hardest to call,” said Steelers defensive back Mike Hilton, who made a great dog-meets-kazoo face when I asked if he knew there were full-time officials, “but it’s an offensive game. They’re gonna be a little more lenient toward the offense. Defensively, we gotta be smart about how we play. As a defense back, you’ve got to find ways to get around it.”

Count head coach Mike Tomlin among those who were unable to find ways around it last week, blurting “We’ve got to get better as the National Football League. These penalties are costing people games and jobs. We’ve got to get them correct, so I am pissed about it to be quite honest with you but that’s all I will say about it.”

Boom, that’ll be $25,000. The fine Tomlin got from the NFL for those remarks was apparently calculated by a complex disciplinary formula expressed as 31.25 percent of the money allegedly stolen from Antonio Brown’s backpack in April. What’s the name of the penalty, would you guess, for throwing big heavy things from the 14th floor balcony of a luxury condominium, allegedly?

Advertise with us

Uncondo-like conduct, but I digress.

Among the many things for which the league’s game officials need some practice is the touchdown signal, the simple both arms skyward, which few of them seem to want to do any more for fear of replay embarrassment. I’d have them work on that all week, but I’ve been told it’s not necessary.

“Some of us used to kid that the replay book was 10 pages long and now it’s 60,” said Green. “It’s what the league wants and as an official you want to get the play right, (but) if you’re gonna be a good official, you call what you see on the field and you let replay deal with it from replay’s standpoint. It’s a very dangerous place to be if you’ve got somebody out there that’s hesitating on making a call because of replay. And frankly, having been on the field and worked with guys, you’ll sense that from somebody if that’s case. It doesn’t make for a good crew mate, if you will.”

Of course, there’s an easy fix to that problem, expressed most simply as in a long favored platform of this space: Death to Replay!

“The fundamental thing with replay is that if you have a big mistake, you can fix it,” said McAulay. “And I think (Atlanta Falcons president) Rich McKay and the Competition Committee have done a great job trying to leave it there and not expanding it to everything. There’s a pretty good number of people who would like to do that. I think it would be horrible for the game. Once you take these human aspects out of it, and maybe perfect any aspect of it, then what do you talk about on Monday? Who do you blame for the loss? Nobody wants to do that. The humanness of sports is one of the great things ever that make sports great. And while replay can fix some of it, those obvious errors that we need to get right on change of possessions and scores and things like that, going any further would really undermine the game.”

I agree, but the momentum seems irreversible. At some point, so many things will have become reviewable that the game results won’t be known until maybe Wednesday, speaking of which, one of you referees had better bring a cake to the office because it’s Midge’s last day.