Spent three days and nights at the ballpark this week trying to excogitate the natural mystery of the 2018 Pirates, with predictably mixed results, because if anything defines Clint Hurdle’s team at the start of what could be a very long baseball summer, it’s mixed results.
But Wednesday, in the middle the most ridiculous episode of a seven-game stretch in which they lost 10-8, won 11-9 and lost 8-7, the Pirates made a play so singularly splendid it again propped up the fading notion that they could cling to relevance.
Sixth inning, one out, Austin Barnes of the Los Angeles Dodgers on first base, Pirates leading 8-7 behind Steven Brault, the second of six Pittsburgh pitchers on a night L.A. would use eight. Pinch hitter Breyvic Valera, he of the .176 career average, sliced Brault’s sixth 3-2 pitch toward the foul line in left field as the players in the Dodgers’ dugout jumped to life. With Barnes running on the pitch, they thought it might tie the game.
Left fielder Corey Dickerson had another interpretation.
Sprinting hard to his right, Dickerson, in one motion, made the catch and fired toward first as Barnes fled desperately in retreat. The throw tailed to the left of first baseman David Freese, who came off the bag for it, then dived back to finish a 7-3 double play the notation of which — DP 7-3 — I don’t believe I’ve ever written on a score sheet.
Second baseman Josh Harrison, with perhaps the best view of all that, wasn’t sure he’d ever seen it either.
Read More
“Not outside of a video game, no, a video where someone just keeps runnin’,” Harrison laughed. “That might have been the fourth time in that at-bat when the runner was going on the pitch. Corey makes that throw on the run quite a bit; he’s got it down, and Freese, him divin’ like that was a game changer.”
Dickerson, who arrived via trade from Tampa with a suspect defensive dossier, had recorded a career-high fifth assist of a thus-far-errorless season. At the plate, he’s taken up residence among the league’s top 10 hitters. In the clubhouse, he’s taken an unofficial and unspoken identity as the best player on this team.
At 29 and in his sixth big league season with three clubs, Dickerson doesn’t see Pittsburgh’s competitive mood swings as a matter of capricious confidence so much as simple accountability.
“I don’t think confidence comes and goes; it’s about executing,” he said. “If you don’t execute, you put pressure on yourself, like the pressure of trying to get three hits in one at bat. Trying to get three strikeouts on one batter. Our job is to play the game and play it the right way. We have to continue growing together, but it’s all good signs from my standpoint. This team is mostly young, and you gotta go through tough patches to learn about yourself and how to compete, how to not worry about yourself, to be a good team player.”
That sounds like a noble pursuit, but for the moment I’d prefer it if Corey Dickerson could play every position. Can he pitch? Well, in three games against the Dodgers I saw 29 pitching changes and 1,005 pitches (no, seriously), so I wouldn’t mind seeing Dickerson take a turn.
Thursday afternoon, Jameson Taillon got the start on the eighth anniversary of the day the Pirates made him the second overall pick, in which Baseball America, the game’s scouting bible, rated him the best pitcher in the 2010 draft. When he left after five innings, he’d allowed eight hits and three runs. Now in his third big-league season, he’s 16-16 with a 4.00 earned run average.
The 2018 draft was conducted this week. Of the Pirates’ 41 picks, 17 were pitchers joining an organization that has produced the fewest Cy Young Award winners of any team in existence since 1956, the first year baseball gave the thing out; just two (Vernon Law in 1960, Doug Drabek in 1990). I mention this partly because the Dodgers have produced 12 Cy Young winners, and partly because 10 pitchers have, by themselves, won more Cy Youngs than the Pirates, but mostly because, of all the macro- and micro-pitching philosophies in play over the past 60-plus years, few have served the Pirates all that well.
“Some guys have been in programs, four years in college, and they have a pitching philosophy — that’s what they got — that’s their DNA, so you let ’em go a little bit,” Hurdle was saying on the topic. “You get the information from them and then maybe along the way you add a little bit or share a thought, or you let ’em know, ‘Here’s what we do. Now this is just so you know, so you’re aware of our pitching philosophy. However, yours seems to be workin’ real well for you right now, so let’s go ahead and keep huntin’ that. Usually over time, experience, other hitters, what they’re facin’, performance, questions get asked, opportunities are there to coach.
“And then, in Instructional League, that’s where we more open the book for them and say, ‘OK , here’s the Pirates pitching philosophy.’”
Every team’s got a fine pitching philosophy, but for this one, any snapshot of its contemporary practicality can be pretty unflattering. The Pirates are in Chicago awaiting the return of Ivan Nova to the rotation. Their Opening Day starter, Nova is 2-5 with an ERA that in May went from 3.32 to 4.96. He’s allowed three earned runs or more in eight of his 11 starts. As soon as he’s fully recovered from a finger sprain, he’ll join Taillon at the top of the rotation.
If the rotation isn’t exactly optimal, the bullpen is closer to pyromaniacal. Closer Felipe Vazquez blew four saves in 12 days, and Michael Feliz, the next best bullpen option until about two weeks ago, went into a free fall in which he allowed one, two, or three earned runs in six consecutive appearances, or a total of 12 runs in 5 2/3 innings, or a May 23-June 7 ERA of 19.05.
Offensively, the Pirates need someone with real production potential to get hot and stay that way, because if Francisco Cervelli is going to lead your club in RBI, that, too, is not exactly optimal. He had 35 by Friday, but he’s never driven in more than 43 and probably won’t have 60 when this season’s over. Same for homers. Cervelli has a team-high nine. Rookie Gleyber Torres, hitting ninth for the Yankees, has 10.
Don’t look to Starling Marte or Gregory Polanco to carry this team. After 12 combined seasons, they are exactly what they appear to be — severe disappointments, relative to potential.
On Thursday, Marte added two strikeouts that bookended his career plight. In the first, facing former teammate Daniel Hudson, he swung and missed a 1-2 pitch headed for the dirt in the opposite batters box. Hudson’s seen that movie. In the seventh, Marte took a called strike three on the outside corner, which is not far enough away to swing at, I guess.
After Thursday, Polanco was hitting .208.
The worse news is that Josh Bell, who looked so promising with those 26 homers and 90 RBI last season at age 24, had four homers through 62 games and started the weekend hitting .234 after a 1-for-20 skid.
“You just gotta focus on what go you here and what kept you here,” said Bell. “Trust in yourself, trust in the process.”
Something will have to change with this club, and just about immediately, lest the process look a lot less inspiring by, say, August.
“The name of this game is consistency, on the mound, at the plate, in the field, all across the board,” Harrison said. “We gotta a lot of guys that are battlin’. When you have those stretches when you’re not as consistent, confidence is something that can waver. Especially with young guys. We’ve done a pretty good job up to now of not letting it get too bad. Baseball is a game that wears on you mentally, physically, but just by trying to show the way, older guys, me, Corey, Freese, Jordy (Mercer), we can help.
“Guys here can play, but they gotta go through learning curves and confidence is the key. We tell them, ‘Hey, keep that confidence because there’s gonna come a point where gonna feel silly about being so down about yourself. You’re always your worst critic. Everybody is.”
Gene Collier: gcollier@post-gazette.com, Twitter: @genecollier.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.