Welcome to Paul Zeise’s weekly mailbag, where the Post-Gazette columnist and 93.7 The Fan radio host answers your questions about sports, life and everything in between. If you want to ask Paul a question, tweet him @paulzeise or email him at pzeise@post-gazette.com. This feature will run each Wednesday, so you have a whole week to submit questions.
Let’s get started:
Carlo Gambino, @Gambino_166: After a promising start to the season it looks like the Pirates will be sellers again this year at the trade deadline. However, I don't think they are that far away. Do you feel that Vasquez is the answer as the closer ? I love Brault setting up Glasnow to close games-thoughts ?
Zeise: The Pirates will probably be sellers. I have always believed they would shed some salary at the trade deadline anyway, but now they definitely will. That’s the beauty of marketing yourself as a “young, hungry, up-and-coming team” — it allows you to justify every move you make away from a veteran player. So, for instance, the Pirates could trade Josh Harrison and say they have now opened up more playing time for Adam Frazier and Max Moroff. We all know it would be to save money, but that isn’t how it will be sold. I think that would have been the case even if they got to the trade deadline in contention. Vazquez is the answer at closer, provided he is healthy. I think there is some evidence which suggests he isn’t healthy, though, and that is a problem. Steven Brault has found his niche, I think, as a middle reliever. It is a role that seems to fit him well.
Marty Cain, Mt. Washington: I will not go to or watch another game that has either Sean Rodriguez or Gregory Polanco in the starting lineup or God forbid, both. Please explain to me what could possibly be the reason behind Clint Hurdle putting those two out there every night? It makes no sense.
Zeise: The Pirates need Gregory Polanco to snap out of this funk and believe he will, so they keep giving him opportunities. I don’t love that, but I can at least follow the logic. If they get Polanco going, it gives them a lot of flexibility and ensures there will be one good outfield/pinch hit option on the bench every night. Sean Rodiriguez is baffling to me. He has to have compromising photos of someone in the organization because it makes absolutely no sense at all that he plays as much as he does. He can’t hit, and now he can’t even field, yet he has 100+ at-bats. That is absurd.
Read More
Larry Ragston, Connellsville: The Pirates bullpen was a strength but now it is a weakness? What happened? It seems like all of their relievers forgot how to pitch at the same time.
Zeise: They are all young. The pitching staff has promise but very little experience, especially with Ivan Nova on the disabled list and George Kontos no longer here. A young staff will struggle with consistency. It is just a part of the growing pains in baseball. It is a long, hard season, and there is nowhere to hide. The Pirates have some good young arms in the bullpen, they just need to learn how to pitch.
Rooster Jones, @RoosterJones3: Is there any chance if the Pirates continue to implode that Hurdle gets fired in season?
Zeise: They just signed him to a four-year extension, so I have a hard time believing he is in any danger of losing his job. Again, when you have a young, inexperienced team and a small payroll, the manager has a built-in excuse for why the team didn’t win enough.
Mike Manning, Homestead: If the Capitals win the Stanley Cup will it change the legacy of Alex Ovechkin significantly? Conversely what would that mean for Marc-Andre Fleury’s legacy? Could Fleury win the Conn Smythe trophy even if Las Vegas loses?
Zeise: A Stanley Cup championship is the one hole in Ovechkin’s otherwise brilliant resume. He has pretty much checked every other box and is a first-ballot Hall of Famer. A championship won’t change that, but it will move him to another level, and he will shed that “best player to never win a championship” label. As for Fleury, he is the reason the Golden Knights are here in the first place. He has been stellar in the playoffs right up until the Stanley Cup final. That’s why he can’t win the Conn Smythe trophy unless Vegas comes back and wins. He has been outplayed by Braden Holtby. If the Capitals win, there is a strong case to be made for Ovechkin, Holtby or Evgeny Kuznetsov.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.