Clint Hurdle often addresses questions about a struggling hitter, or one who just broke out of a slump, in a similar fashion.
Change isn’t always the answer, he contends, because how can the player and coaches know how close they were to breaking through? If a player keeps tinkering, he gets good at tinkering. And as neat and clean as it sounds to find an adjustment that led to a hot streak, to ascribe improvement to something tangible, sometimes a hitter’s luck just turns.
Managing a Pirates lineup in which some key hitters have run aground during the past two weeks forced Hurdle and his hitting coaches, Jeff Branson and Jeff Livesey, to preach patience at times and recommend change in others. The slumps of Gregory Polanco, Josh Bell and Sean Rodriguez have contributed to the Pirates’ .293 on-base percentage and .380 slugging percentage in the past 14 days entering their weekend series against the Chicago Cubs (both 13th in the NL) and a 5.9 percent walk rate that was tied for worst in the league.
First, Hurdle needs to separate signal from noise.

“You’re going to find an indicator to substantiate whatever you want to believe in, truthfully, if you dig that deep,” Hurdle said. “You need to just play what’s real, and I like to play within the strike zone.”
Analyzing what a hitter does on hittable pitches helps Hurdle identify whether a player’s swing is fine, and he needs some balls to find grass; whether a slight adjustment here or there could help; or whether the whole thing has gone awry.
Read More
“When the indicators are lining up — you’re arriving on time, when your front foot’s down your hand are over your back leg, your barrel’s arriving on time, it’s good angle to the ball, you’re not behind, you’re not out in front — you might just be hitting into bad luck,” he said.
Polanco entered Friday on a 6 for 45 stretch with a .212 OBP and 15 strikeouts. He fights a constant battle against his long arms lengthening his swing, but in recent weeks the swing has been less of an issue than where he stands when he does it. Hurdle dropped a hint before Wednesday’s game: “We’re just talking about plate coverage now and distance of the plate, where his stance is right now.”
Hurdle, Branson and Livesey pulled video of Polanco’s starting point in the box since 2015 and found that it varied. They spoke to Polanco Wednesday about standing farther from home plate in the batter’s box. Polanco pinch-hit and lined a double into the right-field corner.
“Clint told me, and I believe it, you have long arms, you have a 34-inch [bat], so you’ve just got to believe it,” Polanco said. “I like it, because in [batting practice] today, my work in the cage, was different. I hit so many balls on the barrel. I can feel the difference.”
Polanco wasn’t sure about covering the outside part of the plate, so he asked for pitches away in batting practice. “And I hit the ball, line drive, line drive. And I’m like, ‘Oh. That’s even better.’ ”
In Bell’s past 17 games before Friday, he went 9 for 60 with 14 strikeouts and a .209 OBP. Bell said he needs to reconnect his upper and lower half: His legs and hips are not synced with his hands.
“Lower half’s going. Hands are staying behind,” Bell said. “It just creates a long swing. A lot of ground balls, a lot of fly outs. Not a lot of balls hit on the screws.”
Can't get enough of our in-depth Pirates coverage?
Support quality journalism. Subscribe today.
The work continues. Bell’s top hand came off the bat on a swing in the second inning Thursday, and he struck out swinging on a breaking ball near his ankles.
“Just continue to work and continue to focus on that ‘A’ swing that comes with staying connected,” he said. “One swing at a time, just got to keep working at it.”
Rodriguez’s issues have persisted all season. He was hitting .167/.286/.314 with 37 strikeouts in 102 at-bats entering Friday. Hurdle spoke with Rodriguez Wednesday about slowing down at the plate with his leg kick and keeping his hands in the hitting position.
“Trying to keep it as simple as possible and keep focusing on the task at hand,” Rodriguez said. “Focus on the process, not the results, as difficult as that is sometimes because it’s a results-based game.”
The talk helped, Rodriguez said, “Especially when it’s coming from the manager.”
When discussing changes, or lack thereof, with his hitters, Hurdle tries to speak their language. Some prefer video. Some like heat mats. Some like to see their slugging percentages for each quadrant of the strike zone. Communicating with the players in their preferred medium helps him reinforce the message: Change only when change is necessary.
“What you don’t want to fall trap to is, well, I’m not getting hits,” Hurdle said. “And that happens. It’s all about result, and then when you’re not getting hits, then you can go and change a stance or a swing or a mindset and before you know it, that’s sometimes when things can get really out of whack. We’ve got to be able to, I do believe, be steadfast in what we do, if what we do is lining up where the things that you’re looking for, you’re arriving on time, you’re not getting beat, you’re not late, you’re swinging at strikes, sometimes you’ve just got to ride it out.”
Bill Brink: bbrink@post-gazette.com and Twitter @BrinkPG.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.