Mount the 2017 World Series anywhere you please in the game’s historic pantheon, but know that the perfect gauge of its enduring excellence, of just how compelling and dramatic and competitive it was, crystallized in the 10th inning of Game 5 between the Houston Astros and the Los Angeles Dodgers.

At the throbbing point of practical exhaustion where that game was 5 hours, 16 minutes old, in that riotous 10th last Sunday night, wins were 2-2, runs were 12-12 and a thickening narrative that wouldn’t end for another 72 hours was headed for seven games in which the Astros and Dodgers body-slammed each other to a final composite score of 34-34.

As for the epic Game 5, on the other side of midnight, Derek Fisher had been on the field for all of about 30 seconds, inserted at second base as a pinch runner, when Alex Bregman lined the single that won it.

As it happens, Fisher, from the tiny Pennsylvania coal-mining village of Rexmont, starred at Cedar Crest High in Lebanon.

Advertise with us

“Part of you is just in awe watching that,” said Chris Groff, Fisher’s high school coach, after Derek slid home with the 25th run of the game. “On the biggest stage in baseball, it’s like you’re actually part of it, you feel like you’re actually a dad. He started all four years of varsity ball for me. This was his goal. It’s every kid’s goal, but Derek had two things going for him: he was a heckuva hard worker and he had talent.”

In a climactic event that included gifted players from Japan to the Caribbean, South America, and back, it was still somehow pure Americana.

Unless you would like to have heard Joe Buck refer to John Smoltz as “the Hall of Famer,” more than just a few hundred times, you couldn’t ask much more from a World Series. My only beef: Too bad it ended when it did, because the next person to visit the pitchers mound would have been its 5,000th customer. So no confetti. Bummer.

Yeah, there were 56 pitching changes in those seven games, not to mention 560 pitcher-catcher conferences of varying length and utility. Astros catcher Brian McCann visited the mound more in the first inning of Game 7 (thrice) than Astros pitcher Francisco Liriano visited the mound in the entire postseason (twice).

Houston’s 5-1 victory in Game 7, the one that secured that city’s only baseball championship since the expansion Colt .45’s debuted in 1962, swelled the pride of millions who’d recently taken on 27 trillion gallons of water, the hurricane-ravaged baseball fans in coastal Texas, and of Astros new and old, unforgotten and unremembered.

Advertise with us

“I was rooting for them,” former Pirate outfielder and manager Bill Virdon said into the phone from Missouri this week. “I always liked Houston. I was there seven years.”

Long enough to become the winningest manager in Astros history is all. Virdon has no connection with the 21st century version, but like everyone else he could only marvel at the most recent spectacle once so quaintly called The Fall Classic.

“It was the most exciting series I’ve seen,” Virdon said, “Other than maybe 1960.”

Wait, maybe?

Virdon had a pretty good view of that one, right? His virtuosity in center field scuttled just enough New York Yankee rallies to extend the series to seven games, which, you might be aware, went Pittsburgh’s way in the bottom of the ninth, 10-9.

Advertise with us

The 1960 Pirates and the bombastic Yankees (whose three wins in the series came by a combined score of 38-3) hit a total of 14 homers in those seven games. In the seven games ending this week, the Dodgers and Astros hit 25, a record. The Astros became the first team to have five different players homer in the same game. There were eight homers in Game 2, seven in Game 5. There were four extra-inning homers in a half hour on Oct. 25, as the inimitable Jayson Stark pointed out, after every World Series since its inception in 1903 produced 17 extra-inning homers. Total.

Houston’s brilliant George Springer hit five homers in the Series, matching the record shared by Reggie Jackson (1977) and Chase Utley (2009).

So as the sport pivots toward 2018, after a season in which it set the all-time record for homers and strikeouts, when the only sustained action leading to an incredible World Series seemed to be either the batter slamming his bat in frustration or flipping it in triumph, one barely-halfway-facetious question looms over the big league game’s future:

Should players continue to bring their gloves?

Are they still all that useful?

Advertise with us

Or is this the end of baseball as we’ve known it?

Ok, that would be three questions, but the point is made.

“Strikeouts are the worst they’ve ever been; it’s just a different game,” said long-time manager Jim Leyland, who attended games in Cleveland and Houston in this postseason, including World Series Game 5. “There are just so many more guys swinging for the fences. Really, it’s amazing. That game [Sunday] night, homers were poppin’ out of there like ping-pong balls. There used to be some guys, a lot of guys, who would make an adjustment with two strikes, but these guys aren’t doing that much. They’re still swinging out of their ass on the third strike and it’s just not productive to winning baseball. There’s a time in the game where you’ve got to figure out a way to get a run and let the big boys take care of the homers.”

George Springer reacts after a home run in Game 7 against the Dodgers. (David J. Phillip / Associated Press)

In Game 6, Dodgers outfielder Chris Taylor came up with runners on first and second and nobody out in the bottom of the sixth, his team trailing 1-0 and facing elimination.

Not only did Taylor eschew the bunt (so out of fashion in this century), he took four huge rips at Justin Verlander, fouling off a 1-2 pitch and then lining a double to right to tie the game. Corey Seager than lifted a sacrifice fly to put L.A. on top and on its way to a 3-1 victory, but if the Dodgers lucked out in that sequence, they didn’t in the series.

Advertise with us

As Smoltz (did you hear he’s a Hall of Famer?), pointed out incisively in the Fox broadcast of Game 7, the difference in the series was that the Astros, when required to put the ball in play to move the runner(s), usually did, while the Dodgers usually didn’t. It’s no coincidence that in the all or nothing homers/​strikeouts age, the team that struck out the least this season, the Astros, became the last team standing. The Dodgers averaged more than nine strikeouts per game in this series, more than 10 over the last four games. They had 65 strikeouts in 250 plate appearances. Dick Groat, to drop a name, had 25 strikeouts in 575 plate appearances in 1956.

Steve Garvey, the great Dodgers first baseman of the ’70s and early ’80s, just about lost it on local TV in Los Angeles trying to describe the club’s offensive approach.

“You get up, you take a big swing, you strike out,” said Garvey, who was on Dodgers World Series teams in ’74, ’77, ’78, and ’81. “You don’t try to move the runners over very often. Nobody bunts. Nobody hit-and-runs. We’re a team that has to get guys on and we got five hits?”

What not only saved this series from devolving into a hot plate of tedium presented in seven servings that averaged 3 hours, 42 minutes, but elevated it into the game’s hagiology, was the undeniable, undiluted talent of the participants.

“Look at the young players in this game,” said Jack Zduriencik, the former Seattle Mariners GM and Pirates post-game analyst. “You think of [the Dodgers’ Cody] Bellinger and you got [Corey] Seager and Chris Taylor, then [Houston’s] Springer, [Carlos] Correa, and Bregman, people who are going to be stars for a long time.

Advertise with us

“Plus there was a bit of a perfect storm in this series. It was incredibly hot in L.A. for the first two games, so the ball was flying. Then the ballpark in Houston is a hitter’s dream. Then you have all the evidence of how valuable bullpens are now. They’re the most vulnerable part of your team; it’s very hard to keep one together for two or three years.”

Or two or three innings.

That’s why Game 5, with its five lead changes, came to encapsulate the 2017 World Series.

“Oh my, it was, ‘Whoop, they’re gonna win,’ then it was ‘Whoop, they’re gonna lose,’ then it was ‘Whoop, they’re gonna win,” said Virdon, now 86 and watching baseball pretty hard for only about 80 years. “But that’s why we watch it, you know? Hey, that’s baseball.”

And we’ll miss it like heck for the next five months.

Gene Collier: gcollier@post-gazette.com