This is not exactly a fair fight today at Heinz Field, not with Ben Roethlisberger having vanished from the ever-shrinking list of healthy Steelers, and especially not in juxtaposition to the fearsome New England Patriots.
All things being equal, it would have been a pivotal moment in the long struggle for home-field advantage through the AFC tournament, but when Bill Belichick’s Patriots are part of the drama, it’s not so much the inequity as the iniquity.
Tom Brady will command the Patriots offense for the third time post-suspension, but that doesn’t mean Deflategate and its implications have been fully bubble-wrapped in the NFL’s vast storehouse of scandalous archives.
"Any time something like that comes up, and it’s a controversial issue, as a player, as a person, it just makes you want to beat them that much more." — Arthur Moats on the Patriots' tactics
“I don’t really like to say ‘scandal,’ “ said veteran Steelers linebacker Arthur Moats, who lets little obscure his smile. “I wouldn’t say it’s a matter of being suspicious. Any time something like that comes up, and it’s a controversial issue, as a player, as a person, it just makes you want to beat them that much more. Because now you’re sayin’, ‘It doesn’t matter what you did. It doesn’t matter whether you had extra films or the balls were altered or anything like that, if we come out and beat you, I don’t care if you had 12 guys on the field, at the end of the day we won, you still weren’t good enough.’ That’s how I feel and a lot of guys in this league feel the same way. That’s how a competitor feels.”
In Deflategate, which isn’t technically over until the Patriots sit out the fourth round of the 2017 NFL draft, just as they sat out the first round in 2016 and Brady sat out the first four games of this season and team owner Robert Kraft paid a cool $1 million in restitution, we have witnessed the very apotheosis of how a competitor feels. Brady, stung by an assault on his reputation after 11 footballs used in the first half of the January 2015 AFC championship came up a little squishy and texts linked him to a New England operative calling himself “The Deflator,” dug in against a league office energized to make an example of the Patriots after badly mishandling Spygate, the previous major scandal emanating from Foxborough, Mass.
The result was a 17-month conflagration by entities way too competitive for their own good, the commingling of which triggered a multi-million dollar legal donnybrook that fell just short of the Supreme Court.
Of the United States.
Welcome aboard Mr. Goodell’s Wild Ride.
One minute you were watching the Patriots topple the Seattle Seahawks in the Super Bowl, the next you’d wandered onto some inescapable sci-fi dreamscape where the ideal gas law battled it out with the pre-temperature law, where theoretical modeling confronted temperature-based deflation, where the Logo Gauge and the Non-Logo Gauge (a coupla gauges that don’t like each other) tried to mitigate the implications of partial temperature-based reinflation.
And the people, oh the people.
There was the MIT prof who lurched onto YouTube to explain how the league’s investigation had technical failures leading to incorrect conclusions. There was the CMU grad student whom the MIT guy cited for his study that wet balls kept in a bag had a slower rate of warming leading to incorrect amplitudes. There were the four doofi protesting Brady’s suspension who handcuffed themselves together in the lobby of NFL headquarters, where NYPD offices were only too happy to arrest them. And there was federal judge Richard M. Berman, who tossed out that suspension, not on the innocence of the quarterback, but due to legal deficiencies in the labor deal between the league and its players.
The league flung the challenge flag at Berman, then turned to the 2nd U.S. Court of Appeals, where Brady was sacked for minus 13. Not a single person on the 13-judge panel even bothered to issue a dissent as the court flatly denied Brady’s argument.
Yeah, good times.
All this over the grip of the football as it relates to air pressure, something virtually indiscernible to 99.9999 percent of the human race.
“Not a chance,” said Steelers long snapper Greg Warren on the likelihood that anyone could tell the difference between a football inflated to 12.5 PSI (the league minimum) and one deflated to 11.08 (the average of the Patriots’ balls tested. “No, not the average person. Now somebody with really strong hands, or that’s dealt with the footballs a lot might be able to say, ‘Yeah, this one maybe.’
“It’s not as uncommon as people think. If you have a ball inside and take it outside, it’s gonna shrink some. Should you be punished for it? I think if you’re found to be doing it on a consistent basis and you know the rule, I guess you should. But I don’t think it’s like trying to film somebody and stealing their plays.”
It’s hard to know, on the big swinging scale of Patriots skullduggery, where exactly ball shrinking falls. For that you’d have to ask someone really, really smart. Maybe some philosophy lecturer and/or sports ethicist, which, of course, we did.
One caveat: He’s a Patriots fan.
“If a team prepares footballs in a way resulting in deflation outside the rule-defined limits and the officials just don’t catch this until after the balls are in play, then that looks like an equipment violation,” said Shawn Klein, a philosophy lecturer at Arizona State University and a blogger at Sportsethicist.com. “If there is more to it — if someone on the team intentionally deflates the footballs below the rule-defined limits and also intentionally and actively works to deceive the officials in order to get the footballs into the game, then that is something ethically worse than an equipment violation. And it’s more than just gamesmanship. I am still not sure where in the litany of rule violations such an act fits best, but the violation in itself seems minor. What would be morally troubling would be the deception of the officials in order to violate the rule. And even more so, if this activity is a concerted and sanctioned effort by the organization, then we get to a much higher level of morally troubling behavior.”
Klein believes that because the scientific intellects that jumped aboard appear to have shredded the reliability of the Wells Report, the product of the league’s “independent” investigation, Deflategate probably lies closer to an equipment violation than it does to moral Armageddon.
Spygate, as Warren suggests, was the far greater offense, unless you’ve forgotten that when the league undertook that investigation in 2007, it found a library of illegally taped video accompanied by hand-drawn diagrams of the Steelers’ signals the Patriots used for the January 2002 AFC title game at Heinz Field.
“Oh they knew; they were calling out our stuff,” Hines Ward told ESPN’s Don Van Natta Jr. and Seth Wickersham for their staggering Sept. 2015 expose. “They knew a lot of our plays. There’s no question that some of their players were calling out some of our stuff.”
Caught five years later with about seven seasons worth of illegal video on the premises, Belichick claimed he didn’t realize filming the opponents’ signals was a violation, which sounded very much like George Costanza’s reaction after the discovery that he’d had sex with the cleaning lady on his desk.
“Was that wrong?”
The Steelers’ impatience with New England sophistry has deep roots and blooms like a perennial. In the last meeting, Sept. 11, 2015, in Massachusetts, Mike Tomlin hadn’t taken even a couple of verbal steps into the post-game presser before this exchange:
Reporter: Mike there was a report that your radio went out?
Tomlin: “That’s always the case.”
Reporter: Here?
Tomlin: “Yes.”
Reporter: So you’re saying every time you play here have have rad…
Tomlin (interrupting): “I said what I said. We were listening to the Patriots radio broadcast for the majority of the first half.”
On the broadcast, the Steelers were on their way to losing 28-21, and it wasn’t nearly that close.
“They prepare at an elite level; you hardly ever see those guys — offense, defense, special teams — out of position,” Moats said. “And even though these controversies have come up, how many times have you seen their opponent make mistakes? I think about us, last year, I felt like we were definitely having success, but then on the long pass to [Rob]Gronk[owski], we had a blown coverage. Then on the fade route [to Gronkowski] we had a missed technique. They’re not going to beat themselves.”
In the wake of Deflategate, new protocols regarding ball security have been implemented. You can no longer take footballs that have just been inspected by the officials, put them in a bag, and take them into a bathroom. Good idea.
It’s harder to legislate out of the game the nefarious proclivities of certain individuals. You’d think after Spygate no one associated with the Patriots would get near anything like Deflategate, but here we are. You think coaches would no longer leave phony play lists in the visiting locker room at Gillette Stadium for low-level Patriots operatives to swipe in the pregame hours, but here we are.
But it appears Brady has pretty much the same grip on things. He’s thrown 75 times in three games, with no interceptions. And he’s not alone. Backup Jimmy Garoppolo, in two starts during Brady’s suspension, threw 60 times with no interceptions. Backup backup Jacoby Brissett, who started the other two, threw 55 times with no interceptions.
Six games into this second season after Deflategate, the Patriots are the only team in the league to have thrown that often without being intercepted.
Until further notice, you can call that elite preparation.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.