Gene Collier: The chat room is open here at St. Benedict Hall on the lovely campus of St. Vincent, where Benedictine monasticism annually meets brain-bending violence. You may post questions immediately and I'll join you at noon. Special welcome to Steely McBeam.

Jacque Strap: Hi Gene. So, how does the south of France compare to St. Vincent College?

Gene Collier: That whole South of France vacay caper never came off Strap. Apparently you need an airplane and I try to avoid those. Too many passengers, who are the No. 1 cause of airline delays. If I were County Executive, I'd erect big electronic signs across all roads leading to the airport, and those signs would say No Passengers Beyond This Point.

Jacque Strap: You repeated that line from the end of your last chat. Not that there's a problem with that...

Advertise with us

Gene Collier: Thanks for pointing that out. I try not to be repetitive. I try not to be repetitive.

Jacque Strap: Is there a greater dichotomy anywhere in sports between the excitement fans have towards attending training camp, and the level of tedium involved in the events of camp itself?

Gene Collier: Well yes, probably, but I'm saving those for an upcoming book, Greatest Dichotomies Anywhere in Sports. As for the fan experience, please see Hall of Famer Ed Bouchette's story today about Steelers fans lining up at 5:30 a.m. here. Practice starts at 3. As for tedium, the major sports rank as follows from worst to least-worst (if that's a thing) regarding watching practice. 1) hockey, 2) football, 3, baseball, 4, basketball.

Jacque Strap: Tell Steely to McBeam out of this chat. Nobody likes him.

Gene Collier: Please, on the contrary. I like him. He's quiet in spite of being imposing. Stop the hate.

Advertise with us

ZAck B: If Davis is gonna play the slot role, don't we need more safety help? Maybe re-sign Will Allen?

Gene Collier: That's still a big if. Until further notice, the Steelers need so much secondary help, they could sign Woody Allen.

Jacque Strap: Any good specials on the lunch menu today?

Gene Collier: Haven't been over there yet, but the bison burgers are always good.

Jacque Strap: If I may, I humbly submit "Control What I Can Control" for Trite Trophy consideration.

Advertise with us

Gene Collier: You may, and that's a good one. Anyone on any of these platforms may submit a suggestion for the annual Trite Trophy column, speaking of tedium. In fact, as it happens, an official Post-Gazette laptop switch this summer resulted in the loss of the first five months of nominees, so I'm playing catch-up in a sense. Playing catch-up is another nominee. Obviously a major security breach here for which someone will surely blame Hillary Clinton.

Bill: Can you make the case for why Pirate fans should be excited about the team under the current and old leadership?

Gene Collier: Well sure I can, but it's not as easy after watching two of their best prospects shipped off essentially to avoid paying the balance of Francisco's Liriano's contract. The Pirates have long loved their prospects or at least the idea of having prospects, but apparently they don't love them as much as financial flexibility and controllable years. This smacks of hypocrisy and deceit, and underlines the Nutting Ventured Nutting Gained policy of never overpaying for anything, regardless of whether such a player might actually result in a return to the World Series. Bucs are now celebrating their 37th consecutive World-Series-free year. But they still have prospects and still have major league talent, and they still have a decent management team, albeit with constraints.

Guest: Is Jeff Locke done as a starter, if so will the Pirates go with an all right hand rotation to finish out the season

Gene Collier: I've been a long-time Locke defender, but I think it's probably over for him in Pittsburgh. I don't even look at him as a potentially effective reliever at this point. Has talent, but can't sustain it. Familiar tale.

Advertise with us

Guest: What are the chances that the Pirates can sign Joyce and Freese next year?

Gene Collier: Matt Joyce and David Freese are currently making money for themselves somewhere else, I would think. It's possible the Pirates will sign one of them, but not both. Mind you, the Pirates COULD sign both, they just won't. That might compromise their financial flexibilities, rendering too expensive any years of control. It's just like with Melancon. Huntington kept saying the club controlled him just another two months, but why? You want to control him? Pay him. It's just not in their model.

Gene Collier: One minute left in the chat, one minute. Steely, if you're ever going to say something, this might be the time.

Gene Collier: Steely, if you're ever going to say something, this . . . oh geez I'm doing it again.

Thanks everybody. Chat next week.

Follow Gene Collier on Twitter @genecollier.