Even as the Washington Capitals are doomed to walk the dystopian earth dragging a dusty ox cart loaded with every last volume of their tortured playoff history, not one of them thought to stop and pronounce the end of an error when they acquired Brooks Orpik at the start of the hockey season before this.

Orpik, the splendid American defenseman who’d spent part of 11 seasons with the Penguins helping to write that very history, would now presumably enable an inspiring re-write, the kind where one day the Capitals would vanquish their Pittsburgh oppressors, spring Alexander Ovechkin into a conference final and beyond, maybe even win a Stanley Cup.

It tastes almost too ironic this morning doesn’t it?

Instead of all that, the Penguins used the second colossal Orpik blunder of this series and some overtime heroics by Nick Bonino to crush Washington’s dream for the eighth time in nine playoff meetings.

Advertise with us

So it didn’t take but a split second for Capitals coach Barry Trotz, new this year to the singular dysfunctional post-season relationship that is Penguins-Capitals, to finger the reason his Presidents Trophy-winning club lost Game 6 and the series here Tuesday night.

“Obviously when we took the double penalty,” Trotz said about Orpik’s four-minute sentence for high-sticking Patrick Hornqvist in the second period. “We knew they’d come out with a real good push and we fell behind, but when we took the double minor and they scored two, now you’re sitting at a 3-0 hole.”

The Penguins, winners of this muscular six-game series, had a full wagon of heroes, none bigger nor more unlikely than the 21-year-old rookie Matt Murray, who has backstopped them to within four wins of the Stanley Cup Finals, but no amount of leftover sentiment for Orpik can gloss over his contribution to this latest installment in one of hockey’s most intractable lost causes.

The Capitals were leading this series 1-0 when Orpik first tried to separate Olli Maatta’s head from his shoulders near the Washington net in Game 2, earning a three-game suspension, two of which the Capitals lost.

When he returned last night for Game 6, his teammates anticipated a shift in the balance of power. Down three-games-to-two, they actually figured Orpik to be the stabilizing force that would send this series back to Washington for a Game 7.

Advertise with us

“His leadership is one of his biggest values to our group,” said Capitals goalie Braden Holtby the morning of Orpik’s return, “and that calmness in tense situations.”

What?

Ex-squeeze me.

Like the calm way he battered Maatta into oblivion for the better part of the series? Just for the hell of it?

That leadership?

Advertise with us

So with the Penguins leading 1-0 but generating nothing close to dominance six minutes into the middle period, Orpik put his stick blade into the face of Patric Hornqvist in a manner menacing enough to draw a double minor, handing the Penguins potentially four minutes of power play time that will now live in Capitals infamy.

Before Orpik even had his seat warmed in the penalty box, Phil Kessel, who’d given the Penguins their 1-0 lead with a scalding wrist shot that was behind Holtby before he saw it, rang the puck off the post to Holtby’s right. Seconds later, Kessel had the puck again between the circles, and this time he hit nothing but the back of the net.

Thirty-three seconds later, with Orpik’s stomach doubtless dropping to the floor boards, Maatta launched a slapshot from the right point that Carl Hagelin deflected past Holtby for a 3-0 Penguins lead.

The next tortured volume, Pittsburgh Volume VIII in terms or Capitals playoff exits, had its outline and its goat.

All it lacked was an ending, and for the third time in six games, it was not delivered until overtime.

Advertise with us

Almost as if they couldn’t stand to see their old teammate take the fall for Game 6 and the series, the Penguins set about the business of plotting a third-period pratfall that not only took Orpik off the hook, it nearly turned history inside out.

It was a plot unlike any other – has anyone ever piggy-backed three consecutive delay-of-game penalties (all for knocking the puck out of play)? – and it resulted in the kind of 5-on-3 and 5-on-4 penalty killing that stretched to unmanageable lengths.

“I’ve never seen it in all the years I’ve been around the game,” said Penguins coach Mike Sullivan. “To have three delay-of-game penalties right in a row like that; that’s a tough one to swallow, ya know? But I thought our guys battled hard through it against a very good power play. What I’ve loved about this group is their resilience. They don’t allow the ebbs and flows of the game to affect them and they might have been challenged the most that way tonight in that third period.”

When all three penalties had been adjudicated, Pittsburgh had been short-handed for nearly three minutes and Washington had tacked one power play goal onto the one T.J. Oshie had whipped past Murray late in period two and another Justin Williams had scored in the third. What had been the 3-0 Orpik hole had been completely plastered over.

Plastered, sanded, painted to a high gloss.

Advertise with us

New hockey game, 3-3.

“There’s no quit in our group,” Trotz said. “We lost (defenseman Karl) Alzner early in the game, so our defense, they had to play a lot of heavy minutes. So we made a good push. There was no quit, so I’m proud of that fact, but we didn’t get it done.

“Congrats to the Penguins, super hockey team. Good series. I wish them all the best going forward. I thought they did a terrific job down the stretch, being the hottest team in the National Hockey League, and that carried over to the playoffs, so I think they’ve got a shot at it.”

As the extra period began, both goaltenders turned dazzling saves, with Holtby stopping Trevor Daley twice at close range less than three minutes into the fourth period. Murray answered shortly thereafter, turning away Washington’s Evgeny Kuznetsov.

But by far the better of the offensive pressure in the extra period got generated by Sullivan’s team, and a burst of traffic to the net finally ended with a puck behind Holtby off Bonino’s stick at 6:32 of overtime.

Advertise with us

“It’s the greatest time of year,” Sullivan had reminded his guys earlier in the day. “Let’s have fun.”

We should probably exit this series with a fun fact: All three times the Penguins have won the Stanley Cup, they’ve at one point or another in that historical post-season disposed of the Washington Capitals.

I’m just tellin’ ya.

Gene Collier: gcollier@post-gazette.com and Twitter @genecollier.

CORRECTION: An earlier version of this article misstated how the Capitals scored. They scored two power-play goals and one even-strength goal.