Chris Dell is the founder of BettingPredators.com, as well as the lead fantasy football and sports betting analyst on ESPN 97.5’s “Late Hits.” He’s also our new sports editor at the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette. In his new weekly “Post-Gazette Fantasy Football Favorites” column, Chris will break down his top fantasy players and strategies to win your leagues, in addition to some prop bets along the way. Please note: This article should be considered opinion, not gambling advice.

Welcome to the Week 5 edition of our ‘Post-Gazette Fantasy Manifesto’ series. The players I write about below will be mainly those I’m significantly higher or lower on vs. the expert consensus rankings (ECR), which includes 200+ analysts across the fantasy football industry.

We’ve discussed different themes each week for this series, and now, as we hit the quarter-point of fantasy football regular season, it’s important to remember one thing: we’ve only just begun …

The same strategies and fantasy principles we’ve applied each week this season still stand strong:

Advertise with us
  1. Don’t worry about the results …
  2. Don’t overreact to Week 1 performances …
  3. Don’t get complacent with your roster …
  4. Don’t underestimate rookie talent …

However, week 5 is now here, which means it's now “don’t get caught holding the bag” week.

Last week, we talked about buying low — and buying high on ascending talents in certain spots, like De’Vone Achane and Anthony Richardson — but it’s even more important to know when to sell.

Case in point: TRADE AWAY D.J. MOORE

Sorry to break it to you, but Moore is not the next coming of Randy Moss. Not even close, actually.

Nor is he on the same level as underperforming fantasy wideouts such as Ja’Marr Chase, Calvin Ridley, Cooper Kupp, Garrett Wilson or Chris Olave — all guys who rank OUTSIDE the top 20 fantasy WRs so far through four weeks of football.

Advertise with us

Moore has been in the league now for 5+ seasons.

We know who he is.

And you’ll never be able to sell Moore for more.

No pun intended.

Seriously, no Moore puns.

Advertise with us

OK, I’m done.

If you’ve got Moore on your roster after Thursday night’s 203-yard, 3-touchdown performance, you’re first inclination is to shout to your league mates, “That’s why I drafted him, I told you!”

Go ahead and shout it. Gloat your face off.

But know this: Moore faces three of the top 10 secondaries during the final four weeks of the fantasy regular season and playoffs (DET, ATL, CLE). And if you can land a top-10 WR option and then some off his sky-high Thursday Night Football spectacle, you simply have to do it.

Don’t look at the box score.

Advertise with us

Don’t overreact to a one-game sample.

Don’t get complacent with fooling yourself into believing that Moore is now a bonafide stud.

He’s good, sure.

But he’s not that good.

The same principle applies to other aging overachievers around the league, like Adam Thielen and Raheem Mostert. History has shown us who they are: good, but not great, assets.

Advertise with us

Sell at the highest price possible, cash in your chips, and get out the hell outta Las Vegas.

Believe it or not, there are 4-0 teams in your league who will miss the playoffs come Week 15.

It’ll be the ones who hang on to guys like Moore and those mentioned above and do not budge with their roster. On the contrary, many 1-3 and 0-4 squads currently dwelling in the fantasy dungeons are just on the precipice of making a run.

It’ll be the ones who trade for Chase, Kupp, Aaron Jones and Austin Ekeler while “buying the dip.”

The NFL is wildly unpredictable.

Advertise with us

So let’s try not to predict things.

Instead, let’s react to what history has shown.

And with that said, let’s get out there again and win some more fantasy games in Week 5 …

Please note: you can view my full list of fantasy rankings — by position and scoring format — as well as my top 200-250 flex players, here, or find them by scrolling to the bottom of this column.

PLAYERS I LOVE (START ‘EM)

QB. Joshua Dobbs (+9):
Dell’s rank QB10
Consensus rank QB19

Advertise with us

I can’t list Anthony Richardson every week here, or can I? Despite showing up for his in a major way as THE QB1 in Week 4, Richardson is still under-ranked by the ECR at QB6 this week (I’ve got him at QB2, as you’ll see noted below). But if you didn’t draft or trade for Richardson just yet, the next best thing is, believe it or not, Sir “Robert Joshua Dobbs.” Arizona’s feel-good story in 2023 has come at the QB position, where Dobbs since Week 1 is the overall QB6 in fantasy points while facing upper-echelon defenses in the Cowboys and 49ers. A big reason for that is his wheels. He ran for a league-high 12 times at his position in Week 4 and added 48 rushing yards on the ground.

On the year, he now ranks fifth in QB rush attempts (24) and fourth in QB rushing yards (141). Dobbs now has 144 rushing yards in his last three games, with five total TDs and zero INTs. And he now faces a Bengals defense that ranks seventh-worst in QB fantasy points allowed, giving up 11.9% more points on average per week to the position. Dobbs isn’t some fluke who just learned how to run either: coming into the 2019 NFL Draft he boasted impressive athletic measurables, which included an 88th percentile 40-yard-dash time, 88th percentile agility score and 83rd percentile burst score, according to PlayerProfiler.

I dropped Dak Prescott for him in one of my leagues, and I feel great about it. I’ve got Dobbs comfortably ranked ahead of Trevor Lawrence, Joe Burrow, Prescott and Jared Goff for Week 5.

Honorable mention: Anthony Richardson QB2, Daniel Jones QB9, Brock Purdy QB14, Dak Prescott QB16

RB. Isiah Pacheco (+6):
Dell’s rank RB9

Advertise with us

Look, if I could list our guy De’Von Achane every week. Achane, like Richardson above, balled out for us in Week 4 to the tune of another 27 PPR fantasy points and an RB5 finish. One spot behind him was this week’s “favorite” running back: the Chiefs’ Isaiah Pacheco. The former seventh-round pick has seen an uptick in touches in four straight weeks, going from 12 in Week 1 to 13-17-23. Those 40 combined touches from Weeks 3-4 have catapulted Pacheco to THE RB5 the past two weeks, and Kansas City shows no signs of slowing down his role any time soon as its lead RB.

Pacheco now finds himself in a game with the highest point total (53) in Week 5, on a fast track against the up-tempo Vikings. Let’s not forget either that Pacheco coming out of Rutgers two years ago sported a ridiculously elite 99th percentile 40-yard dash time of 4.37 seconds, 99th percentile speed score, 93rd percentile bench press and sixth-best yards per carry mark in the nation. It’s no fluke he’s breaking off big runs or hammering in short touchdowns at the goal line. And with Patrick Mahomes under center and Travis Kelce running slant routes for the Swifties in the audiences, opposing defenses will NEVER be able to key in on KC’s RB1 in Isiah Pacheco.

Honorable mention: Tony Pollard RB3, David Montgomery RB4, Kyren Williams RB5, Raheem Mostert RB7, D’Andre Swift RB8, Aaron Jones RB12, James Conner RB15, Saquon Barkley RB16, Breece Hall RB18

WR. Garrett Wilson, Jets (+4):
Dell’s rank WR11

Oh, how the fantasy tides turn so quickly. He made our SIT ‘EM list for two weeks straight in Week 3 and Week 4, and we came away with split results. But last week, something fundamentally changed. And now, we must fundamentally adapt as a result. The Jets — and quarterback Zach Wilson, for that matter — suddenly went from morbid to mediocre. And the number-one beneficiary is Garrett Wilson. He’s now seen his targets increase every week this season (5-8-9-14) and currently ranks top 10 in WR targets over the past three weeks despite facing fellow top-10 secondaries in the Cowboys, Patriots and Chiefs.

Advertise with us

Now Wilson gets the Denver Broncos, who rank dead last in PFF coverage grade and dead last in ESPN’s pass rush win rate metric, as well as in the bottom five in explosive play rates allowed to receivers. Look, we’ve never questioned Wilson’s talent here, only his situation. And that situation will be as good as it EVER gets in Week 5. Start him confidently, or buy low now in a trade before it’s too late. If the Jets can get even slightly below-average QB play for the rest of 2023, Wilson will be a borderline top-10 WR or even higher.

Honorable mention: A.J. Brown WR4, DeVonta Smith WR5, Calvin Ridley WR10, Cooper Kupp WR14, DeAndre Hopkins WR18, Christian Watson WR24, Romeo Doubs WR25, Jakobi Meyers WR26, Tyler Boyd WR31

TE. Luke Musgrave, Packers (+10):
Dell’s rank TE7

The rookie Musgrave was the TE13 in Weeks 1-3, and despite leaving Week 4 early with a concussion, he still ranks second on the Packers in receptions this year with 12. Musgrave now faces a Raiders defense which ranks 25th overall in TE fantasy points allowed, giving up 23.8% more points on average every week to the position. Musgrave’s size (6’6” and 253 pounds) and athleticism (89th percentile 40-yeard-dash, 94th percentile speed score, 87th percentile burst score and 85th percentile catch radius) are undeniable.

The kid’s got talent, and it’s only a matter of time before he breaks out in a big way. Start him with confidence in Week 5 as a top-10 TE in usage with the upside for more. And if he’s still on your waiver wire, add him to the end of your bench before he puts another full game under his belt — his last one resulted in six catches on eight targets in Week 4 against a tough defense in N.O.

Advertise with us

Honorable mention: Mark Andrews TE2, Evan Engram TE5, Tyler Higbee TE6, Irv Smith Jr. TE18

PLAYERS I HATE (SIT ‘EM)

QB. Trevor Lawrence, Jaguars (-5):
Dell’s rank QB15

Lawrence made our ‘dishonorable mention’ list last week and made us look good by turning in a mediocre QB16 performance. He now faces his toughest test of the season in Week 4 with a Buffalo Bills defense which ranks third overall in PFF coverage grade and third in ESPN’s pass rush win rate. Jacksonville’s o-line isn’t doing its QB any favors either, ranking fourth-worst in pass block win rate and third-worst in run blocking.

Lawrence could struggle mightily in this matchup, especially with Von Miller returning for his first NFL action of the 2023 season. Lawrence ranks just QB19 on the year but is still ranked as a borderline top-10 QB weekly. Fade the name on the jersey, and make decisions based on reality here. Better days will come for the Jaguars’ signal-caller, but it likely won’t be until he sees improved blocking in front of him and a better defensive matchup. I’m starting guys like Purdy, Matthew Stafford, Jordan Love and Daniel Jones (yes, that Daniel Jones) ahead of Lawrence in Week 5.

Dishonorable mention: C.J. Stroud QB18, Joe Burrow QB19, Jared Goff QB21, Bryce Young QB24

Advertise with us

RB. Najee Harris, Steelers (-15):
Dell’s rank RB42

Welcome back to the hate list, Najee Harris. The Steelers’ ground-and-pounder had his best game of the season in Week 4, rushing 14 times for 71 yards … and finishing as just the RB19 in the process. While his performance was respectable, given the state of offensive play in Pittsburgh right now, it will be much tougher sledding against Baltimore in Week 5. The Ravens boast PFF’s fourth-best run-stopping grade through four weeks, while the Steelers are bottom-five in run-blocking grade and bottom-four in run block win rate. The massive gap in run-stopping vs. run-blocking between PIT and BAL is the largest of all 14 games in Week 5, and with Najee getting no pass-game work this season, his fantasy value will be rendered useless. Harris is the RB37 on the season in PPR (point per reception) scoring and now faces arguably his toughest run defense test of the year, yet ECR is still ranking him as RB27.

I’ve got him ranked as RB42, right around what he’s done so far this year. Remember that in Week 1, against a similar defensive foe, he totaled just 31 rushing yards and was the RB44. Am I the one with the bold take here, or is it the rest of the industry? In this case, I’ll side with the latter.

Dishonorable mention: Travis Etienne RB18, Alexander Mattison RB25, Rhamondre Stevenson RB26, Jahmyr Gibbs RB28

WR. George Pickens, Steelers (-6):
Dell’s rank WR30

Advertise with us

This isn’t meant to pick on Pittsburgh, I pinky promise. But bad weather is expected at Acrisure Stadium on Sunday, with the current forecast calling for 15+ MPH winds. With Kenny Pickett fresh off a knee injury last week, I expect his mobility to at least be “limited” as well. That all spells bad news for the Steelers' #1 wideout in Pickens, who now faces a Ravens secondary that ranks #1 in the league in PFF coverage and grade.

If we know anything about Mike Tomlin, it’s that he relies on what he knows best when his back is against the wall: run the ball, play defense, and run the ball some more. While I don’t believe those runs will be necessarily effective, I do believe it’s what Pittsburgh will at least try to do early on. Pickens’ seven targets in Week 4 netted him just three catches for 25 yards and a WR75 finish on the week. Outside of his 71-yard TD catch against the Browns in Week 2, he also ranked well outside the top 50 WRs in fantasy points. With likely no Freiermuth or Diontae Johnson in this game, in addition to a less-mobile Pickett and nightmare defensive matchup, all signs point to benching Pickens in fantasy for Week 5.

Dishonorable mention: Courtland Sutton WR35, Jerry Jeudy WR36, Robert Woods WR51, Skyy Moore WR61

TE. George Kittle, 49ers (-3):
Dell’s rank TE8

No one is denying George Kittle’s talent on an NFL football field, but the fact remains that through four weeks this season he’s just the TE19 in overall usage. Kittle ranks just fourth on his team in both receptions and targets this season, and even dating back to 2022 he struggled to be a consistent fantasy option when the likes of Deebo Samuel, Brandon Aiyuk and Christian McCaffrey were all healthy. Now look, you’re probably starting Kittle if you have him. This mention on our hate list should serve more as a “trade him away and sell him if he has a big game” disclaimer.

Advertise with us

It’s hard to trust a guy who's the fourth option at best on his team, and the Dallas defense he now faces in Week 5 is the second-worst matchup for opposing TEs this year. On average, TEs dancing the Cowboys score -77.8% fewer points per game than average, according to FantasyPros, which sets the bar low for Kittle’s outlook here in this spot. I have him as TE8, but below the likes of Musgrave, Sam LaPorta, Tyler Higbee and Evan Engram. He’s no longer the locked-in, top-five tight end fantasy option that we’d come to love.

Dishonorable mention: Dalton Kincaid TE13, Hunter Henry TE16, Kyle Pitts TE21, Chig Okonkwo TE24

SLEEPER OF THE WEEK

(must be ranked outside the consensus top 50 FLEX ranks)

WR. Michael Wilson, Cardinals (+8):
Dell’s rank WR39

I told you to add Wilson in our Week 5 Post-Gazette fantasy fallout column on Tuesday, but 76% of you didn’t listen, as he’s still owned in roughly 23% of ESPN leagues. Hey, at least 21% of you listened! We have to start somewhere, right?

Advertise with us

Wilson, a third-round draft pick out of Stanford, trails Marquise Brown by just yards for Arizona's lead in receiving yards (239 to 237) and is third on the team in both targets (16) and receptions (14).

Wilson’s athleticism, in addition to his imposing 6’1”, 216-pound frame, makes him a go-to target for Dobbs in the red zone, and if the Cardinals continue moving the ball and putting up points, don’t be surprised if you see his name as a regular in the top 20 fantasy WRs week to week. He’s not just worth a waiver wire add or stash for Week 5. He’s also worth a spot start if you need one.

Honorable mention: Braxton Berrios WR52, Wan’Dale Robinson WR45, Allen Lazard WR53, Kadarius Toney WR56

FLEX STASH OF THE WEEK

(must be owned in less than 25% of leagues)

RB. Keaton Mitchell, Ravens (4.9%)

Throw the rookie Keaton Mitchell on the end of your benches before your opponents catch notice. Mitchell ran a blazing 4.37 40-yard dash (99th percentile) despite being undrafted and also sports an 88th percentile speed score in his draft class. He’s undersized at 5’8” and 179 pounds but drew rave reviews out of Ravens camp during the offseason and is now slated to return off IR.

Mitchell’s 7.2 yards-per-carry clip in college was in the top six percent of the country while playing at East Carolina, and Baltimore’s offense is in dire need of an actual play-maker in its backfield. Even in a limited, change-of-pace role, Mitchell could pay significant dividends down the road in fantasy as bye weeks approach and injuries mount.

Honorable mention: Justice Hill 24.9%, Jayden Reed 24.2%, Tyjae Spears 24.0%, Luke Musgrave 23.9%, Michael Wilson 23.6%, Josh Reynolds 21.9%, Rashid Shaheed 17.8%, Rashee Rice 16.7%, Josh Downs 11.4%, Jonnu Smith 8.9%, Latavius Murray 6.4%, Wan’Dale Robinson 4.7%, Rico Dowdle 4.1%, Jalin Hyatt 3.0%, Jelani Woods 1.6%, Tyquan Thornton 1.3%, Trayveon Williams 0.9%, Darnell Washington 0.6%, Emari Demercado 0.2%

D/ST STASH OF THE WEEK

(must be owned in less than 50% of leagues)

Texans vs. Saints, Week 6 (21.0%)

Derek just isn’t right, and it could be multiple weeks until his injured shoulder is fully healed. On the other hand, the Houston Texans have been overall D/ST #5 over the past two weeks while feasting against below-average offensive lines in the Jaguars and Steelers. Enter the New Orleans Saints and the hobbled Carr in Week 6, a squad that ranks dead last in pass block win rate and 30th of 32 teams in PFF pass-blocking grade.

Houston’s #2 rank in pass rush win rate could make this game ripe for an upset, especially with Carr’s career propensity to take sacks at a high level. If you need a solid defense to start with upside next Sunday, then no look further than these young, talented Houston Texans.

Honorable mention for Week 6 stashes:

  • Falcons vs. Commanders
  • Vikings at Bears
  • Seahawks at Bengals

This column is dedicated to the late, great Robin McLaurin Williams …

2023 Fantasy Football Rankings powered by FantasyProsECR ™ - Expert Consensus Rankings

Chris Dell: cdell@post-gazette.com and Twitter @MaddJournalist