The commentary below contains opinion. The author’s name has been withheld at the writer’s request.
Keep hearing terrific things about Pirates new manager Derek Shelton. Brilliant baseball mind. Great with players and colleagues. Wonderful combination of old-school baseball and new-school analytics. Terrific family man. Friendly. Personable. Probably even will have a beer from time to time.
Shelton sounds almost too good to be true.
Just one way he could be better:
Is there any chance he can change his first name to Mike?
Pittsburgh is lucky to have its two Mikes as coaches. Mike Tomlin and Mike Sullivan are having strong seasons, so strong that it’s almost impossible to say which one is doing the better job.
Read More
Let’s try, anyway.
Sullivan gets the vote here.
Barely.
That is no knock on Tomlin. He long has been recognized by this column and is doing an especially extraordinary job with the Steelers this season. He didn’t lose any points here with Sunday’s 17-10 loss to the Bills. Maybe the team’s run-pass balance was out of whack, especially with Duck Hodges at quarterback. Certainly the fumble on a clunky wildcat play on first-and-goal from the Bills’ 10 turned out badly. But overall? Without Ben Roethlisberger since the second game? Without Stephon Tuitt, James Conner and JuJu Smith-Schuster for huge chunks of the season? It’s incredible the Steelers can clinch a playoff spot by winning their final two games against the Jets and Ravens.
Tomlin deserves NFL Coach of the Year consideration, even if he doesn’t deserve the award. The three favorites are the Ravens’ John Harbaugh, the Bills’ Sean McDermott and the 49ers’ Kyle Shanahan, in that order.
But as incredible as the Steelers’ 8-6 record is, the Penguins’ 19-10-4 record is even more impressive. Sullivan has kept the team together during a crazy run of injuries. It goes into its game Tuesday night at Calgary with 129 man-games lost. Only Boston, Buffalo and Detroit have lost more.
Sidney Crosby has been out since Nov. 12 after having sports hernia surgery and isn’t expected back before the New Year. The Penguins have gone 9-4-3 without him. That is amazing.
Crosby isn’t the only key player who is out long term. Patric Hornqvist has missed 13 games and counting, Brian Dumoulin 10, Nick Bjugstad 23. Who knows when they will be back?
A sick Evgeni Malkin missed the past two games — the Penguins won both without him and Crosby — and was out for 11 games in October with a lower-body injury. Bryan Rust was hurt twice and missed 14 games, Kris Letang eight and Justin Schultz seven.
A total of 30 players have dressed for at least one game, including goaltenders Matt Murray and Tristan Jarry. There have been nights when Joseph Blandisi, Sam Lafferty and Stefan Noesen have been the fourth line.
Sullivan never blinked.
The Penguins didn’t blink.
“He’s doing an unbelievable coaching job in light of all the injuries,” two-time Stanley Cup winner and AT&T SportsNet analyst Bob Errey said last week. “He’s dealing with different personalities. Guys are coming in and out. It’s not easy.”
Malkin, Letang and Jake Guentzel are expected to play well, and they have. The Penguins also have received huge contributions from Rust (12 goals, 22 points in 19 games), Jared McCann (9 goals, 19 points in 31 games), Brandon Tanev (6 goals, 16 points in 33 games) and Dominik Kahun (8 goals, 15 points in the past 21 games). Rookie John Marino has been a revelation on defense. Jack Johnson has been much-improved.
Sullivan also has handled his goaltenders superbly, giving Jarry eight starts in the past 11 games. Jarry has been the team’s best player. Sullivan showed he’s not afraid to go away from two-time Cup winner Murray, at least for now. It still seems stunning that he pulled Murray in the final minute of the second period in a game against Vancouver on Nov. 27 after Murray allowed four goals on 14 shots.
“He’s got an innate ability to read situations, when to pull a goalie, when to sit a player,” Errey said. “He’s got a passion for it. He doesn’t miss a beat. He’s not always right. No one is always right, but he’s been pretty good.”
The best thing Sullivan has done is get the players to play a defense-first game. It is the only way they can win without Crosby and the other injured players. It’s not the way they played last season, a big reason they were swept out of the first round of the playoffs by the New York Islanders.
“They’re playing on the right side of the puck,” Errey said. “You don’t see the Penguins chasing people up the ice too often toward their zone. They chip the puck in behind the other team’s defense so the defensemen have to turn. Right away, you have them retreating. You’re between their players and your net so they’ve got to go through you. It’s a big difference when you’ve got to go through people. They’ve been doing it all year long. All their changes are better because they’re chipping pucks deep. Their faceoffs have improved. They’re taking less penalties so the star players can play and their defensive players aren’t getting fatigued.
“I just think the attention to the details is better. Everybody has bought in. With winning, everybody will continue to do that. I respect what the guys are doing and the way they’re playing. They’ve definitely become harder to play against. It takes a lot of mental fortitude. You may not get rewarded on the stats sheet as much, but you’re getting rewarded in the win column. That’s all that matters.”
That’s all that matters to Sullivan, for sure. He’s giving Pittsburgh a second legitimate coach of the year candidate.
It really is a good time here to be a Mike.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.