Every Monday, Wednesday and Friday leading up to the 2026 NFL Draft’s opening day on April 23 in Pittsburgh, Christopher Carter will provide his review on one of the top prospects the Steelers have taken a look at during the draft process with either a formal NFL combine interview, a top-30 draft visit or a pro day visit.

Jeff Caldwell

Wide receiver, Cincinnati, Senior

Steelers contact

Top 30 visit for Steelers

Combine/Pro day numbers

Height: 6 feet 5

Advertise with us

Weight: 216 pounds

Arm length: 32.625 inches

Hand size: 9.75 inches

40-yard dash: 4.31 seconds (fourth best among wide receivers)

10-yard split: 1.48 seconds (best among wide receivers)

Advertise with us

Vertical jump: 42 inches (second best among wide receivers)

Broad jump: 11 feet, 2 inches (second best among wide receivers)

3-cone drill: N/A

20-yard shuttle: N/A

Bench press: N/A

Advertise with us

Strengths

Caldwell blew up the NFL combine with some of the best testing across the board. His finishing in the top four in speed and explosiveness drills gave him a relative athletic score of 9.99 — the best of the receivers in this draft class. Combine that with his height, long arms and that he added 15 pounds to his frame when he transferred to Cincinnati from Lindenwood in 2025 and didn’t lose any of his speed, and you have a prototypical build for a star NFL receiver.

The Louisville, Ky., native lit up FCS defenses with Lindenwood, with 53 receptions for 1,032 yards and eight touchdowns in 2024. But those numbers dropped off in the Big 12 for just 32 receptions for 478 yards and six touchdowns. Still, Caldwell proved to be a big-play threat with quarterback Brendan Sorsby.

While Caldwell had to adjust to the FBS level, opponents who underestimated his speed gave up big plays. He could line up in the slot or outside the numbers, and his natural speed would allow him to get behind defenders who didn’t press him or weren’t playing deep enough coverage. His 40-yard touchdown reception against UCF was an example of that, when he ran a seam against a disguised Cover 3 shell and neither the slot cornerback — who had underneath coverage in the seam — nor the outside cornerback — who had the deep-thirds zone responsibility on that side of the field — could keep up with him.

Caldwell’s athleticism makes him a player all defenses must be aware of whenever he’s on the field.

Concerns

Despite Caldwell’s impressive athletic profile, he’s a prospect with a skill set that hasn’t refined any particular part of his game. His contested catch numbers have never been strong — even in FCS. In 2025, Pro Football Focus charted Caldwell as only catching five of 13 contested passes — a rate of 38.5%.

Advertise with us

Over his last three seasons, his best contested catch rate was 41.7% in 2023. That’s disappointing for a prospect with his size, especially in his years against FCS talent. When Caldwell’s had the opportunity to show the hand-eye coordination to snag passes in tough spots, his long arms give him the chance to get his hands on the ball, but he rarely brings it down.

Another deep ball chance against UCF in the same game as the touchdown was an example of how he hasn’t progressed in his contested catch skills. After he got an initial step on his defender, he located the ball and got a hand on it but didn’t bring in what was a good enough throw.

The more you watch Caldwell’s tape, the more you see plenty of body catches and missed opportunities to see what his hands can do away from his frame. If he were to improve this aspect of his game, Caldwell would become an even bigger threat in the deep passing game and in the red zone.

But Caldwell also has to develop a better route tree. While he can get to top speed at a good pace, he hasn’t developed the ability to slow down, stop and change direction in his routes. Oftentimes he’ll take several more steps to get into a break during his routes, which gives defenders plenty of time to read his move and react.

Draft position

The Steelers’ interest in Caldwell doesn’t indicate they expect him to go early off the board. But their decision to bring him to the facility showed they wanted to check and see more about one of the biggest performers at the combine.

Advertise with us

Expect Caldwell to be a Day 3 pick — most likely after the fourth round. This year’s receiver class is deep with contested catch specialists, route runners and speedsters. If the Steelers want to take a project receiver whom they can try to develop, Caldwell would give them a player with a uniquely talented athletic profile to work with compared to others in the class. But don’t expect him to be their top option to address the receiver depth chart during the draft.

This story was originally published with images that are no longer available.