Dear Santa,
I hope this letter finds you well. It’s been quite some time since we last spoke — 22 years if my memory is correct. Thank you, again, for the Antwaan Randle El jersey I asked for that Christmas. It made me the coolest kid in Ms. Leap’s third grade class.
All is merry and bright on my end. I’m enjoying my new role at the Post-Gazette and have found plenty of cool stories to tell. They even let me write a weekly column, one where I share my thoughts on everything that unfolded from the past weekend.
This week’s column, however, might be a little different. I’m sure you’ve received plenty of gift requests from Pittsburgh sports fans over the past few months. To make things a bit easier for your big night ahead, I decided to condense their wishes into one collective list, organized by team.
While I certainly believe in Christmas miracles, I understand that even your powers have a limit. Big asks, such as a new Pirates owner or Steelers head coach, are above your pay grade. Everything listed below should be within reason, all aimed to give our readers — the best group of Pittsburgh sports fans out there — a merry 2026.
Steelers
I’ll be honest, your gifts have been slacking in this area over the past decade. While I was growing up, you regularly delivered deep playoff runs and Hall-of-Fame talents on both sides of the football. What changed? Is the budget tighter? Or have you forgotten the standard is the standard?
Read More
Nonetheless, the good news is that the biggest wish among this group is pretty simple. The best thing you could give Steelers fans this year is a playoff victory. It’s something they’ve been wanting for years — and between you and me, it’s kinda driving some of them crazy. Those used to be a formality. Surely you can help break this dreadful streak, right?
If not, a good alternative would be a new quarterback. Aaron Rodgers has been solid, but he’s been in the NFL since kids were asking you for iPods. It’s time for a new, young signal-caller, and not like the other ones you’ve given Steelers fans since Ben Roethlisberger retired.
Ideally, this new quarterback will boast high upside. He should be able to evade pressure, throw over the middle of the field and further develop over time. He doesn’t need to have a local connection. He just needs to be good. This year’s draft is in Pittsburgh, after all. What better time to usher in a new era of Steelers football than now?
Penguins
Giving this team a new owner for the second time in four years seems a bit disrespectful toward Pirates fans. But then again, their gifts have been the worst among the bunch for over 30 years now.
Getting off on the right foot with the Hoffmann Family would be a great gift for Penguins fans. It seemed like they were never truly appreciated by Fenway Sports Group. While most understand they’ll never have the connection they shared with Mario Lemieux and Ron Burkle, setting the right tone in this dynamic is important. Penguins fans just want to feel like this group’s top priority is creating a winning product in Pittsburgh.
Since their major gift arrived early, perhaps I can give a few stocking stuffer ideas for this bunch.
They could really use some wins, ones like they grinded out in October. Any tips that could lead to more shootout victories would also be great. Penguins fans really seemed to like those draft picks you gifted them last year. Would asking for a few more young talents be too much? They don’t need to turn into stars, just competent youngsters to play alongside Sidney Crosby — the gift you delivered 20 years ago that keeps giving.
Pirates
If you’re going to take any portion of this list seriously, please let it be this one. To quote the late Beano Cook, “Haven’t they suffered enough?”
To be fair, Pirates fans haven’t been entirely neglected. Paul Skenes and Konnor Griffin were great gifts from past drafts. Brandon Lowe, Jake Mangum, Mason Montgomery and Jhostynxon Garcia were nice early gifts this holiday season. But this group deserves more under the tree. It can no longer be “the thought that counts,” either. The price tag absolutely matters.
Pirates fans are tired of opening presents from the clearance section. They never asked for a Rowdy Tellez or a Tommy Pham. They deserve something better, something nice, something expensive that other teams would also love to have.
While the two trades this month have gone over well, fans still want to see their team make a financial commitment toward winning. Their lineup still needs a few power bats, and one of them should come via a lucrative, multi-year deal with a free agent slugger in his prime.
This group isn’t asking for the world. Eugenio Suarez or Ryan O’Hearn would be welcomed additions for most teams, but in Pittsburgh, they’re more desired than an official Red Ryder carbine action, two-hundred-shot, range model air rifle.
Of course, rather than eye safety, it’s simply money that stands between the Pirates and these gifts. Perhaps sending the Ghosts of Christmas past, present and future to Bob Nutting’s home will do the trick. I hear they have a proven track record with his type.
Pitt
As far as football is concerned, keeping Mason Heintschel and Kade Bell on campus should be good enough. Those two should allow Pitt to compete for an ACC championship next year, the greatest gift any Panther fan could realistically ask for.
If there were room for one additional item under their tree — emphasis on room — it would be a new offensive line. I know your bag is full, but please try to leave space for two or three big fellas in the transfer portal.
Pitt basketball, meanwhile, could certainly use a bit more. Would it be too much to ask for this season to simply be canceled?
If not, then I guess we will have to look ahead toward next year. The Panthers’ 2026 recruiting class — currently ranked No. 10 in the country by 247sports — is the program’s last shred of hope. For the sake of the few Pitt basketball fans still out there, please do what you can to ensure the trio of Chase Foster, Anthony Felesi and Jermal Jones pans out.
Penn State
While others wait to open their presents on the 25th, Penn State fans have already had a couple weeks to enjoy their big gift: Matt Campbell. He’s no Grinch — quite the opposite, actually — but he indeed saved Christmas for the many whos in Happy Valley.
Now, he will need recruits to replenish his roster. The Nittany Lions could use more than a few nice gifts whenever the transfer portal opens on Jan. 2.
As far as non-material items are concerned, patience could be a good gift for Penn State’s large fanbase.
Expectations are always high in State College, and for good reason. They have all the resources to compete for a national championship, which has clearly been established as the program’s standard. But those aren’t won overnight. There was plenty of built-up frustration over the James Franklin era. Hopefully, things have reset under Campbell. He deserves some time to build his program.
Final additions
Before I let you go, I figured it couldn’t hurt to throw in a few more items that I’d personally like to see. After all, I’d like to think I’m on the nice list this year. Heck, I went a full baseball season without the Pirates’ manager scolding me on television!
Below are some ideas. Let’s hope you can make just a few of them happen.
• For the PIAA to wise up and return to four classifications. For too long, we’ve sat and witnessed high school sports leagues be spread too thin. Some of our area’s best rivalries have been ruined due to this six-classification nonsense. State championships also feel less meaningful. Convince the PIAA to return to its old format. They can thank me later.
• For the city to have a flawless experience hosting the 2026 NFL draft. Thousands of people will be heading to our town in April, and I hope those running the show are prepared to showcase Pittsburgh’s many great features and qualities.
• For Jalapeno Hannah to receive a life-long ban from the Great Pittsburgh Pierogy Race. She is a known cheater, routinely using her purse as a weapon mid-contest. This city deserves better. Bring back Pizza Penny and send Hannah to Cleveland, where she belongs.
• For all of our readers to have a wonderful holiday season. We can’t thank you enough for consuming our work. Here’s to hoping 2026 gives us even better Pittsburgh sports stories to tell!






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.