A Pennsylvania hearing board has upheld six permits for shale gas wells drilled near the Mars Area School District in Butler County, finding that environmental regulators satisfied their obligations under the state’s Environmental Rights Amendment when they approved the controversial drilling plans.

Two wells at the heart of the dispute were drilled years ago, beginning in 2015. But the appeal remains relevant as courts slowly sort out the level of review expected of state officials to satisfy the state constitution’s newly rejuvenated mandate to protect clean air and water for current and future generations.

In the case of the Geyer wells drilled by State College-based Rex Energy Corp., the Pennsylvania Environmental Hearing Board found that the Department of Environmental Protection did enough to consider the environmental effects of the wells — by reviewing permit applications, applying existing laws and meeting with concerned residents — even though it did not undertake a site-specific risk assessment, as the environmental groups challenging the permits said was necessary.

“The department certainly took its responsibilities seriously and conducted its review of the permit applications with the care and skill of a person of ordinary prudence dealing with his or her own property,” the board wrote, in a decision on May 11.

Advertise with us

A 2017 state Supreme Court ruling tossed out a longstanding, three-part test that had been used to determine whether state officials met the environmental protection standards spelled out in the Environmental Rights Amendment — Article 1, Section 27 of the state constitution.

Case by case, courts are defining the contours of a new standard.

In its recent decision, the hearing board said it had to determine whether DEP considered the environmental effects of issuing the permits, whether DEP was right in finding that the wells wouldn’t unreasonably degrade the environment and whether DEP acted with “prudence, loyalty and impartiality” as trustee of the state’s natural resources.

On all those measures, the board said the Delaware Riverkeeper Network, Clean Air Council and four neighbors failed to prove that DEP fell short of its obligations.

The board said its understanding of the constitution’s trustee obligations “does not require the department to deny permits to any and all activity that will negatively impact the public natural resources” or the people who use them.

Advertise with us

“To hold otherwise would essentially prevent any permitting activity since it is nigh impossible to have development without some environmental impact.”

The Geyer wells inspired a swell of opposition from neighbors and parents of students in the school district, which has four schools between half a mile and a mile from the well pad.

Opponents challenged a zoning decision that opened most of Middlesex Township to drilling, which spurred a countersuit from gas leaseholders who accused the environmental and parents groups of interfering with their ability to make money from their property.

The Pennsylvania Supreme Court has paused the zoning appeal until it resolves a case out of Lycoming County that raises similar issues.

The environmental groups declined to comment on whether they will appeal the hearing board’s ruling.

Laura Legere: llegere@post-gazette.com.