The Pennsylvania Department of Environmental Protection is asking a state court for immediate protection against two tiny townships whose local charters claim to allow the communities to fine DEP for issuing permits for oil and gas wastewater disposal wells within their borders.
DEP gave permission to two companies on Monday to convert existing oil and gas wells into injection wells for fluid waste in Highland Township, Elk County, and Grant Township, Indiana County. The agency sued the two townships the same day.
Voters in both communities — each with a population fewer than 800 people — elected to adopt home rule charters in 2015 and 2016 that ban development of wastewater disposal wells in the townships. The charters also prohibit the state DEP from issuing permits for oil and gas waste fluid disposal there and prescribe fines for corporations and governments convicted of violating the charters’ terms.
In its lawsuits, DEP asked the Commonwealth Court to discard and declare unlawful the sections of the charters that attempt to regulate aspects of oil and gas development and waste handling that are under the exclusive jurisdiction of state and federal agencies.
The department also asked the court to temporarily block the townships from enforcing a provision of the charters that makes DEP subject to fines until the court can consider the merits of the case. A preliminary injunction is “necessary to prevent the irreparable, substantial, and immediate harm of the liability imposed upon the department” by the home rule charters, DEP’s lawyers wrote.
Both communities are already mired in lawsuits related to their attempts to ban the injection wells, which residents fear will damage drinking water supplies or trigger earthquakes. The permits issued Monday contained monitoring conditions for detecting and minimizing any tremors related to the wells.
Seneca Resources Corp. sued Highland in federal court in November after residents adopted their home rule charter. Township supervisors there, who did not draft the charter, said in court documents that they believe it is unconstitutional and unenforceable, but they have no power to repeal it.
Pennsylvania General Energy Co. is pursuing at least $340,000 in damages and legal fees against Grant Township after a federal judge threw out a section of a township ordinance in 2015 that barred oil and gas wastewater disposal in the community. Township residents voted to adopt a home rule charter with nearly identical language prohibiting wastewater disposal three weeks later.
Both charters were drafted with the assistance of the Community Environmental Legal Defense Fund.
A hearing on both preliminary injunction petitions is scheduled for April 12 in Harrisburg.
Laura Legere: llegere@post-gazette.com.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.