Pennsylvania environmental regulators have been criticized for years over delays in issuing permits for earth-moving activities at oil and gas sites. But in a review released this week, the state Department of Environmental Protection found that companies submitting the applications should share some of the blame.
Nearly 60 percent of more than 1,000 applications the department received for expedited erosion and sedimentation control permits between 2014 and 2016 had to be disqualified from the speedier review process because of flaws in the submissions, the review found.
In a cutting conclusion in the report, the department’s oil and gas office said it “cannot rely on licensed professionals to submit technically sound, legally defensible application materials in the very first submission.” It recommended that the agency drop a practice “previously expected by industry” of “unquestioning reliance” on such applications prepared by industry consultants.
The department said it is going to establish clearer and more objective eligibility standards and review procedures for the expedited permits, which are meant to be approved within 14 business days of submission instead of 60 calendar days under a standard review.
Those revisions will happen as the state prepares an updated version of its oil and gas earth-moving general permit, which expires at the end of 2017. The permit applies to earth disturbances of 5 acres or more at oil and gas well sites, processing or treatment operations, and pipelines.
The department started the internal review to evaluate its thoroughness after it faced legal challenges from, and eventually had to pay attorneys fees to, environmental groups who accused the agency of improperly scrutinizing expedited applications.
Scott Perry, DEP deputy secretary for oil and gas management, acknowledged that the agency’s heightened scrutiny of the applications has been a factor in slowing permit turnaround times but said that improper expedited permit applications play a role in backing up the queue.
“The department’s position is that we won’t issue permits that have technical deficiencies. Period,” he said.
The agency rarely sanctions consultants for submitting incomplete or flawed applications — Mr. Perry said it had happened twice during his tenure of less than a decade — but the DEP has given the industry information about frequent deficiencies to help companies avoid them or avoid hiring consultants that keep making them.
The oil and gas industry and several legislators have criticized permit delays for holding up development of infrastructure projects.
In a December memo previewing a state Senate bill that would require the DEP to report to the Legislature on the permitting program’s performance, Sen. Camera Bartolotta, R-Monongahela, said the DEP is not processing erosion permits efficiently and is applying standards inconsistently across regional offices.
“In too many cases, permits that are to be reviewed in 14 days are taking in excess of 100 days,” she wrote.
On Thursday, Ms. Bartolotta questioned the DEP’s assessment of licensed consultants who, she said, “literally put their name on the line for their work.”
“If there are bad actors, put them on the naughty list,” she said.
The DEP’s review makes her more convinced her bill is necessary, she said. “We need a playbook and it’s got to be the same across all of Pennsylvania.”
The DEP is going to continue offering expedited permit reviews for qualified applications, in part because the voluntary program can be revised to offer incentives for innovations that are better for ecosystems and the environment, Mr. Perry said.
The department is also going to increase training for both its permit reviewers and outside consultants to make clearer how to satisfy the permit application requirements.
Mr. Perry emphasized that flaws in the application and review process have not led to environmental problems at project sites once work begins.
As part of its analysis, the department closely reviewed applications for 23 particularly large and complex oil and gas earth-moving projects and performed field inspections at the work sites 47 times. Only one of the inspections revealed an erosion violation.
Laura Legere: llegere@post-gazette.com.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.