More than a year after the judges on Pennsylvania’s Commonwealth Court heard arguments in a dispute over when low-producing gas wells must pay the state’s Marcellus Shale impact fee, the court has signaled it wants to hear the parties make their cases again.

The appellate court, which has three new judges since the case was last argued in November 2015, has listed the case for another round of oral argument in February.

The case, Snyder Brothers, Inc. v. Pennsylvania Public Utility Commission, concerns so-called “stripper wells,” which the state’s shale gas drilling law, Act 13, defines as unconventional gas wells “incapable of producing more than 90,000 cubic feet of gas per day during any calendar month.” Impact fees are not levied on stripper wells.

The PUC ordered Snyder Brothers to pay nearly $500,000 in impact fees on two dozen wells that the Kittanning-based oil and gas operator considers stripper wells and the PUC does not.

Advertise with us

Snyder Brothers contends that it does not owe the fees on the wells because they produced less than 90,000 cf/d during at least one month of the year. The PUC argues the company owes the fees because the wells did not produce less than 90,000 cf/d every month of the year.

Kevin Moody, general counsel for the Pennsylvania Independent Oil & Gas Association, said it is unusual for the court to hear arguments twice and it is also unusual for the judges not to resolve a case within six months of hearing arguments the first time. The Wexford-based trade group is also a party in the case, which was consolidated with a related case brought by PIOGA.

“I concluded that the court is having a difficult time with this case and, with some new judges, wants it reargued for the benefit of the full court,” Mr. Moody said.

“I welcome the opportunity to try a second time to convince the court that PIOGA’s and Snyder Brothers’ position is correct.”

The PUC declined to comment on the case.

Advertise with us

Vertical wells, like the Snyder Brothers wells at issue in the case, are exempt from the impact fee if they qualify as stripper wells as early as the first year they are drilled. Horizontal wells pay the impact fee for three years regardless of how much gas they produce, but they are exempt from the fee if they qualify as stripper wells beginning in their fourth year.

In 2015, the PUC counted 605 horizontal wells and 644 vertical wells as stripper wells. Another 22 vertical wells were ineligible for the impact fee because they were plugged.

The PUC characterized an additional 35 wells as “disputed vertical” wells. Twenty-two of them are Snyder Brothers wells and 13 belong to Kittanning-based MDS Energy, which is disputing the impact fee levy for the same reason, PUC spokesman Nils Hagen-Frederiksen said. The two companies are separate but are run by members of the same family.

It is unclear how many more wells would be considered stripper wells if the court agrees with Snyder Brothers’ interpretation of the law.

Shale gas companies collectively paid nearly $188 million in impact fees for eligible wells in 2015, down from a high of $226 million in 2013.

Advertise with us

Counties and municipalities that host shale wells received $102 million of the 2015 fee revenue to offset the impacts of drilling on their communities. The rest of the money was distributed to state agencies or placed into a fund that supports environmental and infrastructure projects statewide.

Laura Legere: llegere@post-gazette.com.