Bob Schmetzer calls himself the bull’s-eye.
“Whatever goes wrong, I hear about it,” he said. “And I know it’s coming.”
As president of the council of South Heights Borough in Beaver County, Mr. Schmetzer is expecting an avalanche of calls from constituents stuck in traffic when Shell Chemical Appalachia unleashes some 100 trucks daily through his borough.
The trucks will be carrying materials from storage space in Aliquippa to the petrochemical complex being built in nearby Potter Township.
But Mr. Schmetzer, in South Heights, only found out about the plan to transport the materials in October — months after Shell included it in a voluminous conditional use permit application going before the Potter Township board of supervisors this afternoon. The permit is Potter Township’s final say on construction of the project and, by proxy, the region’s final say as well.
Mr. Schmetzer called his township solicitor.
Read More
There’s nothing the township can do about it, the solicitor said, because the trucks would be traveling on state roads.
He called Hopewell Township, also included in Shell’s proposed truck route, and heard a similar sound of surprise on the other end.
“Potter Township is going to vote on something that impacts South Heights and Hopewell without ever telling us,” Mr. Schmetzer said. “I find that outrageous.”
Others, too, see the Potter Township supervisors as bearing a lot of responsibility on their shoulders.
“We have three supervisors in a township of 500 people controlling the destiny of a whole region,” said Thaddeus Popovich, an environmental activist who is working with the nonprofit Clean Air Council to ask for changes to the permit application.
Last week, citizens and environmental groups delivered a petition to Potter Township asking the supervisors to impose conditions on the requested permit. They want fenceline monitors — air quality monitors placed around the boundary of the plant to gauge the concentration of certain pollutants and send alerts if any exceed safe levels. (Shell has said it’s “agreeable” to the notion, but has not yet agreed to do it.)
They also want limits on how Shell uses incinerators and flares to ensure the company isn’t releasing too many volatile organic compounds.
And they want more information about community effects such as traffic, noise, and light pollution — information that Shell said it has already disclosed in its 200-page permit application.
The petition garnered some 750 signatures, mostly from Potter and neighboring townships, said Matt Walker, a community outreach coordinator for the Philadelphia-based Clean Air Council. He said residents expressed feeling “steamrolled” by Shell and Potter Township supervisors in their efforts to get this permit approved.
Rebecca Matsco, who chairs the Potter Township Board of Supervisors, said residents were properly warned about the meeting and given the requisite amount of time to comment on it.
Mr. Walker conceded that he’s never met a company that has “done it right” — filed its permit applications with enough information to satisfy all his concerns and far enough in advance to consider citizens’ input.
Ultimately, though, it’s up to the township supervisors to schedule meetings and disseminate information to residents to inform them of the issues, he said.
According to Mr. Walker, Potter Township’s officials have failed in both regards — scheduling the permit hearing during the same week as the state Department of Environmental Protection’s hearings for two other cracker-related permits, and doing it in the middle of the holiday season to boot.
“I hadn’t heard that one,” Ms. Matsco said.
She said she has been pleased with the application process so far and that she was looking forward to the hearing, declining to discuss the details of the application until then.
The township, which has about 562 residents according to the latest Census data, keeps in frequent contact with Shell and publishes construction milestones in its quarterly newsletters.
Ms. Matsco said it is the board’s hope that a decision on the permit will be reached by the end of the hearing, but it’s impossible to know that for sure.
She downplayed the weight that many have placed on her shoulders — to represent an entire region through her handling of this application.
“It’s part of what we do,” she said.
Ray Fisher, a spokesperson for Shell, said the company has reached out to other townships, including during a meeting in August “during which elected officials were invited to share with Shell leadership their perspectives on working with Shell.”
Mr. Fisher acknowledged that because there is so much information in the permit — it includes details on various engineering studies, an accounting of plants that will occupy the site, and a schedule for buses that will carry workers from various parking lots to the cracker plant — some of it “does relate to tangential activities that occur in other parts of the county.”
For transportation issues, such as those brought up by Mr. Schmetzer, Mr. Fisher said Shell would work with PENNDOT “and other localities at an appropriate point in the future.”
But he clarified that “the jurisdictional authority for this permit is Potter Township.”
The Clean Air Council, which has opposed numerous energy-related projects in the past, isn’t trying to stop the cracker plant from getting built. Mr. Walker said that doesn’t appear to be what the people want, according to a phone survey of some 800 area residents.
The majority, he said, showed support for the plant. Support and concern.
It’s a stance familiar to Mike Deelo, president of the Beaver Borough Council, which has taken a more active role than some neighboring townships in tracking progress at the plant site and voicing citizens’ worries.
According to council meeting minutes from the past year, Beaver residents have asked their elected officials to look into establishing rent controls to prevent spikes when the plant is operational, and to investigate intersections where increased traffic from the cracker might exacerbate already dangerous conditions.
Some just wanted to know more about the plant or to feel confident that someone they elected is paying attention.
Several months ago, Mr. Deelo said many residents were upset when Shell cleared a bunch of trees along the river in order to build a retaining wall. He brought it up during the August meeting with Shell officials where several township supervisors were offered a five-minute slot to voice concerns.
Shell assured him that once the rail yard was built, the company would replant the area with hybrid chestnut trees, which pleased Mr. Deelo.
But many questions that might be resolved or silenced by Shell’s Potter Township application remain.
Like, will light bleed across the river? How will Shell soften the noise from the large rail yard? The company has said that ethane coming in will be piped, while the plastic pellets that the complex will produce will be railed out of the area.
“So what does this all mean for the borough of Beaver?” Mr. Deelo asked. “It means we’re interested in it, too.”
Anya Litvak: alitvak@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1455.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.