After more than 10 hours of testimony, Potter Township supervisors went home Tuesday night without a vote on a conditional use permit for the Shell Chemical’s ethane cracker being built on the Ohio River.
It was a grueling and at times contentious hearing that began at 3 p.m. The first six hours were spent on testimony from Shell Chemical Appalachia officials and expert witnesses. The public comment period did not begin until 9:30 p.m. and ended shortly around 11 p.m.
The supervisors will pick up their consideration of the permit at the township’s regular meeting tonight at 6 p.m.
“There are so many people interested in taking part in government today,” said Rebecca Matsco, chair of the board of supervisors at Potter on Tuesday afternoon.
The township hosted the meeting in a hall with a maximum capacity of 147 and a spillover space with a satellite feed at a nearby fire hall, which might have been necessary were it not for the snow that blanketed the area on Tuesday.
A wealth of information
Read More
The courtroom-style process spanned a range of topics. Shell had a handful of attorneys questioning witnesses. The Clean Air Council, an environmental nonprofit that has been critical of the project, had its own lawyers.
The Clean Air Council kicked off the meeting with its request to participate as an opponent in the proceedings — that is, to be able to present its own witnesses and cross examine Shell officials.
To show its standing in the case, the organization presented a witness, Brian Lipinski, a Beaver resident, who said he’s concerned about noise, odor, pollution and property values.
Amy Coles, an attorney with Blank Rome hired to represent Shell, repeatedly asked Mr. Lipinski if he had read the hundreds of pages of information that the company had submitted to the township.
He had not.
She lifted a large volume in each hand to show how much information was filed.
“I’m just a guy who lives on River Road,” Mr. Lipinski said.
There is, in fact, a plethora of information about Shell’s plans included in its applications to local and state agencies. So much is out there that some residents feel it’s overwhelming and inaccessible to them.
One observer at the meeting said the hours of technical testimony by Shell officials serves the same purpose as the dense application packet — to be confusing and deter lay people.
Mr. Lipinski made the same point.
“You cannot tell me if it does or does not stink,” he told Ms. Coles.
“And again, you didn’t review these materials, she said.
“Why don’t we just cut to the chase, will it smell or not?” he fired back.
Ms. Coles said that she was a lawyer, not a witness, and couldn’t provide the answer but assured Mr. Lipinski that it was imminent.
Indeed, at one point during his two and a half hours of testimony, Chris Heitman, external relations manager at Shell, did address the odor issue. He said the plant wouldn’t be processing odorous substances so the only smell that residents might be able to detect would be a musty odor coming from its wastewater treatment process. That would be on rare occasions, he said.
Local impact
Mr. Heitman detailed Shell’s “community sensing activities,” which involved hosting an open house in 2014 for people to learn about the petrochemical complex. At the event, Shell invited attendees to drop tokens into jars labeled with issues to indicate their interest in those topics.
From that tally, Shell concluded that nearly 50 percent of those who cast their tokens — it is estimated that more than 500 attendees “voted” that way — were most interested in the economic impact and jobs stemming from the facility.
“Little interest was expressed at the time with traffic, noise and light issues,” Mr. Heitman said.
“Would you agree with me that the public perception of your project could change in two years,” asked Patrick Auth, an attorney with Fair Shake Environmental Legal Services, who represented the Clean Air Council.
“Considering all the improvements that we’ve made in this area? I would say that it could,” Mr. Heitman replied.
Mr. Heitman also addressed truck traffic — there might be as many as 600 trucks a day on the road at some points in the construction period. Once the plant is operational, there are expected to be between 20 and 30 trucks coming and going during an average day. There will be 100 rail cars arriving and leaving the plant daily, he said.
“The use of township roads is not expected,” he clarified.
He said Shell would have a guard house at each facility entrance, a firehouse for its own fire brigade, and a medical facility on site.
Ms. Mastco asked Mr. Heitman to explain how many pipelines will be supplying the plant, but he said he didn’t have that information. She also wondered what the impact will be on the business development of Route 18 from Shell’s purchase of several neighboring parcels. Ms. Matsco wanted to know what kinds of businesses might locate near the plant, but Mr. Heitman demurred on that as well, saying that some of that is part of commercial discussions between Shell and its potential customers.
Much of the meeting and the testimony of several witnesses presented by the Clean Air Council centered on noise and light impacts. The environmental organization’s experts said there wasn’t enough information in Shell’s application for the township to accurately gauge how much noise and light pollution would emanate from the plant. Shell disputed that.
Air monitors
While the Clean Air Council, in its outreach with Beaver County residents prior to the hearing, focused extensively on air quality issues, those were not addressed by its attorneys on Tuesday. Several residents testified that they were concerned about such impacts, however.
Over the weekend, Beaver County residents received a postcard from Shell outlining its environmental protections for air quality around the plant.
It said the company “will meet the most stringent standard” for emissions of nitrogen oxide and volatile organic compounds, which mix with the air to form ground level ozone.
“The new facility will emit less than half of the NOx emissions” of Horsehead, the company said. Horsehead Corp. was a zinc smelting operation that occupied the site before selling it to Shell.
Shell is working to get Pennsylvania regulators to allow it to swap NOx emission credits, which are easier to get, for VOC credits, claiming the net effect on the air would be the same.
The postcard also said that “Shell’s facility is subject to (Pennsylvania Department of Environmental Protection) oversight and ambient air monitoring from an existing network of local/regional air quality monitors.”
On the back of the postcard, Shell printed a map showing the location of five monitors in the vicinity.
Yet two of the five monitors — in Vanport and Potter — are designed to measure concentrations of lead, a pollutant that Shell won’t be emitting.
A monitor in Beaver Falls, which Shell spokesperson Ray Fisher said is being relocated to the Beaver Valley Mall, downwind of the cracker plant, measures for volatile organic compounds and lead.
A monitor in Brighton Township measures ozone and sulfur dioxide. Another in Beaver Falls has the most comprehensive suite, including ozone, particulates, NOx, NO2 and NO.
DEP spokesperson Neil Shader explained that the monitors at Vanport and Potter take monthly readings, while the other three measure pollutants on an hourly basis.
But, he clarified, “individual hourly readings wouldn’t be used for enforcement because of the many variables when it comes to air quality. It would be impossible to definitively say that a particular reading showing an exceedance was the fault of a particular facility outside the most extreme cases.”
If, however, the department saw consistently high readings coming from a single site, it could trigger some action, including coming up with a plan that would lower emission limits on existing permits.
Anya Litvak: alitvak@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1455.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.