Weak oversight and unclear limits in Pennsylvania’s impact fee law have allowed some local governments to spend the money in ways that have little to do with addressing the natural gas drilling-related pressures the funds were meant to offset, according to a report released Tuesday by Auditor General Eugene DePasquale.

The audit — covering four years of payments between 2012 and 2016 — found that a quarter of the impact fee funds in the 30 counties and municipalities the audit sampled were spent on “questionable costs” that appeared to be outside the scope of the law, like balancing budget deficits, paying salaries at county jails, building community swimming pools or buying fireworks for a holiday celebration.

The state’s impact fee law, Act 13 of 2012, requires shale gas drilling companies to make payments based on how many wells they have drilled into the Marcellus Shale or other unconventional gas-bearing rock layers. About half of the money is dedicated to statewide programs and the other half is sent back to local communities that host the wells to compensate for the development’s stresses on their services, housing and roads.

During the audit period, Pennsylvania collected $856 million in impact fees from shale gas companies and distributed $428 million to local governments, including 37 counties and 1,487 municipalities.

Advertise with us

Act 13 was deliberately broad but it has several flaws, the audit found. Its 13 “vague” guidelines for how local governments can spend impact fees do not clearly delineate what counts as proper use of the funds.

The 10 counties reviewed in the audit spent $19 million, or nearly 29 percent of their impact fee spending, on items the auditor general’s office defined as questionable, while the 20 municipalities in the review spent about $700,000, or about 4 percent of their impact fee spending, on questionable items.

Act 13 does not require any state agency to advise local governments on the appropriate use of impact fee funds, and it does not authorize any state agency to monitor local government impact fee spending, Mr. DePasquale said during a press conference in Harrisburg.

“The General Assembly left interpretation up to local governments. Right now, we essentially have 37 counties and 1,487 municipalities independently interpreting the flawed language in Act 13,” he said.

The audit made eight recommendations to the General Assembly to revise Act 13 to tighten the impact fee spending guidelines, increase oversight and establish stronger reporting rules.

Advertise with us

Jennifer Kocher, a spokeswoman for the Senate Republican majority, said Act 13 was written to allow local control, and county and municipal governments are best positioned to determine local spending within the broad categories that the law defined.

“To the degree that any local municipalities stray from those parameters, that spending should cease,” she said, adding that the Senate leadership is willing to look at those issues and consider whether “minor tweaks” need to be made to the spending portions of the law.

But Senate Republicans disagree with the auditor’s broader criticism of the law. “The fee has generated almost a billion dollars for local and statewide projects, and has been an unqualified success,” she said.

Other audit findings include that the law’s reporting requirements make it difficult to track how money set aside for future projects is eventually spent. About 40 percent of all local government impact fee money during the audit period was initially reported by counties and municipalities as having been put into capital reserve, and the law does not require them to report how they use that money in subsequent years.

The audit also found the Pennsylvania Public Utility Commission accurately calculated each local government’s share of the impact fees based on the information the commission received. But the commission does not verify that each municipality is properly reporting its total budget — which the impact fee law uses as a benchmark to determine the maximum amount of fees each local government should get — so some municipalities received more than they were owed.

Advertise with us

Three of seven municipalities studied in the audit were overpaid a total of $863,514 during the four-year period because they misreported their total budgets. That money would otherwise have been dedicated to affordable housing programs.

Mr. DePasquale said the PUC is not to blame for problems with the administration of the impact fee program, but the audit did give the agency eight recommendations for improvements, some of which the commission is moving to adopt. The commission said other recommendations were outside of its authority.

Mr. DePasquale recommended that oversight of the impact fee program should be transferred to either the Department of Community and Economic Development or the Commonwealth Financing Authority, both of which have significant expertise in administering grant programs.

In a statement, the PUC said it has fulfilled its obligation to distribute impact fees since 2012 and it is working to enhance the training for municipal officials that it already provides.

Laura Legere: llegere@post-gazette.com.