A Pennsylvania judge put a temporary stay on select new rules for Marcellus Shale drilling operations on Tuesday until a court can consider the merits of an industry group’s challenge to the month-old regulations.

Commonwealth Court Judge P. Kevin Brobson sided with the Marcellus Shale Coalition, a North Fayette-based trade organization, and stopped implementation of narrow sections of the rules related to public resource protections, large fluid holding ponds, well site restoration standards and monitoring for underground hazards around fracking operations.

He found that some aspects of the rules might exceed regulators’ authority to impose them and that the costs of complying with those provisions now would cause the industry irreparable harm if the sections are later found to be invalid.

He said pausing enforcement of those provisions “will not adversely affect the public interest.”

Advertise with us

Judge Brobson denied the coalition’s request to stay rules related to spill cleanup, onsite waste processing and monthly waste reporting.

The state Department of Environmental Protection’s new rules for shale operations took effect on Oct. 8 and are meant to modernize standards to keep up with the sophisticated industry. A DEP spokesman said the agency is still reviewing the court’s decision.

Marcellus Shale Coalition president David Spigelmyer said in a statement that the organization is “pleased with the court’s decision to preliminarily stay unlawful, burdensome, and costly portions of the challenged regulations from going into effect until this matter can be fully decided in the courts.”

Judge Brobson enjoined a section of a rule that would have required companies to consider the impact of their operations on nearby playgrounds, common areas of a school’s property and so-called “species of special concern,” which are not officially listed as threatened or endangered.

He let the rest of DEP’s strategy for minimizing impacts to public resources to stand.

Advertise with us

He allowed DEP to continue to require shale gas operators to survey for nearby abandoned and active wells that might be affected by fracking in new wells, but he halted the sections of the rules that would have required companies to monitor and remediate damage to wells owned by others or have no known owners.

He also stayed rules that would have required companies to close existing fluid holding ponds and rebuild them to comply with stronger construction standards, although new impoundments will still have to meet the DEP’s stricter standards.

The Commonwealth Court will now consider the merits of the case, but it has not yet published a briefing or argument schedule.

Laura Legere: llegere@post-gazette.com.