Five days after Pennsylvania adopted strict shale gas drilling regulations, the industry’s powerful trade group filed a legal challenge to specific aspects of the rules that it says are vague, contradictory or exceed regulators’ authority.
The North Fayette-based Marcellus Shale Coalition, whose members include the state’s major shale gas operators and ancillary companies, asked Commonwealth Court late Thursday to halt implementation of the challenged rules, which took effect Oct. 8.
The lawsuit could put a hold on revisions meant to modernize Pennsylvania’s environmental regulations to match the sophistication of a sprawling industry that operates near new neighborhoods and old geologic hazards left by prior eras of resource extraction. The state Department of Environmental Protection calls the new rules some of the most protective in the nation even as they codify practices many operators already follow.
Marcellus Shale Coalition president David Spigelmyer said in a conference call with reporters on Friday that some of the rules go beyond strict to stifling. “The provisions we are challenging impose immediate harm to our industry because they affect our ability to operate and remain competitive,” he said.
In its legal filing, the coalition targeted seven provisions, including many of the most substantial changes to the rules. Specifically, the organization is challenging sections that require its members to:
▪ coordinate with agencies that manage features like state parks and school playgrounds to minimize disturbances when drilling is planned nearby,
▪ identify and monitor nearby active and abandoned wells that might be disrupted by hydraulic fracturing in new wells,
▪ close or rebuild fluid impoundments to satisfy more stringent construction standards,
▪ submit monthly, rather than twice-yearly, waste reports,
▪ and meet stricter standards for processing waste on drilling sites, restoring well sites and cleaning up spills.
The organization said the challenged provisions are illegal, inherently burdensome and are not being implemented gradually. It asked the court for an expedited review of its challenge.
DEP took five years, including several periods for public comment and revision, to adopt the changes. Requirements for surface operations at oil and gas well sites were last updated in 2001.
DEP spokesman Neil Shader said the agency is reviewing the lawsuit, which seeks to strike “many important protections” from the rules.
“The challenged regulations are commonsense protections, necessitated by Pennsylvania law,” he said. The regulations account for new production techniques, he said.
Mr. Shader said the new rules “provide reasonable protections for such things as natural resources, water supplies, endangered species, schools and playgrounds while still encouraging the safe production of natural gas in the commonwealth.”
Former Wolf administration officials quickly took to social media site Twitter to criticize the lawsuit.
“A self-defeating, self-destructive & ill-advised move by the natgas industry,” former DEP secretary John Quigley wrote. “Just plain dumb.”
Mr. Quigley resigned his post in May after he excoriated environmental groups in an email for not defending the rules.
John Hanger, who previously served as secretary of policy and planning for Gov. Tom Wolf, called the coalition’s suit a “brilliant way to destroy public support” for the industry.
While Mr. Spigelmyer said he is concerned that the lawsuit could harm the public’s perception of the industry, he emphasized that the Marcellus Shale Coalition tried to cooperate in developing the new rules and did not challenge all of them.
Furthermore, he said, Pennsylvania already has “a world-class framework of rules” that the industry follows with a high rate of environmental compliance.
Although the coalition has participated in several Pennsylvania court cases since it was founded in 2008, this is apparently the first time the influential organization has directly sued a state agency.
DEP is already facing a legal challenge to the public resource protections in the rules by the Pennsylvania Independent Oil and Gas Association, another state oil and gas trade group. PIOGA asked the state Supreme Court late last month to stop the department from enforcing that part of the law, which it says the high court threw out in an earlier decision.
The state legislature is also considering action to ease some of the contested standards related to waste reporting, fresh water impoundments and site restoration timelines.
Laura Legere: llegere@post-gazette.com.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.