The Pennsylvania Supreme Court’s decision last week to throw out several contested sections of the state’s gas drilling law rejected some of the good entwined with the bad.

The ruling last Wednesday was a victory for environmentalists, municipalities and a doctor who challenged narrow parts of the law, Act 13, which had been updated in 2012 for the new era of shale gas extraction.

But at several points in its decision the court discarded provisions designed to protect human health and drinking water after chemical exposure or well site spills because it found the law’s limitations on those protections to be unconstitutional.

The decision leaves legislators with the task of filling in the holes and it is not clear whether they will act.

Advertise with us

The court gave the legislature six months to fix a flaw in the current law that required public water supply facilities to be alerted to drilling-related spills without any equivalent protection for the state’s roughly 3 million residents who get drinking water from private wells.

Because the court cannot rewrite the law to extend the notification requirement to private well owners, it had to eliminate the notification requirement for all types of water supplies.

“Given the significant public health ramifications of striking this mandate,” the majority wrote in its opinion, the court put a hold on that part of the decision for 180 days to give the General Assembly “sufficient time to devise a legislative solution.”

Similarly, the court rejected a section of the law that imposed strict limits on the way doctors can use and share trade secret information about the chemicals used in fracking, but it also threw out the surrounding sections of Act 13 that gave physicians access to the confidential information in the first place.

The court did not pause that aspect of its ruling to give lawmakers time to come up with a replacement.

Advertise with us

“It creates this kind of vacuum,” said Barry Furrow, director of the health law program at Drexel University’s Kline School of Law. “What happens to a physician now who wants trade secret information? He doesn’t have to sign a waiver but does he have a right to anything?”

Several state officials said the effect of the ruling is likely milder than it appears.

The Department of Environmental Protection already alerts both public and private water supply owners that might be affected by a spill, DEP spokesman Neil Shader said, and the court’s decision will not change that. The agency “will continue to provide notice where the agency believes there may be a potential impact to water supplies,” he said.

The medical disclosure provisions of the law, meanwhile, might not ever have been used. Stephen Miskin, spokesman for the Republican majority in the state House of Representatives, said no doctor has ever requested the chemical information, at least not that House leaders are aware of.

Raina Ripple, director of the Southwest Pennsylvania Environmental Health Project, a Washington County non-profit that does educational outreach about the health impacts of shale gas drilling, said doctors couldn’t fill out the forms described in the law to get access to information on drilling chemicals because “those forms don’t even exist.”

Advertise with us

“So not only were health professionals working under a restriction about sharing and getting information,” she said, “there isn’t even a system in place that allows them to work under that restriction.”

Mr. Shader said the court’s opinion does not require DEP to notify private water users and it does not direct the legislature to create such a requirement. Instead, it gives the legislature time to come up with a solution of its own design.

It is not clear how the legislature will respond to the advice.

“We are still reviewing,” Mr. Miskin said, “and have to have many discussions with leaders, members, the Senate and administration about our options.”

Senate Republicans also said they are still analyzing the court’s decision, which they said could have “far reaching” environmental consequences. “We are working to determine what those impacts will be,” spokeswoman Jennifer Kocher said. “We will be considering our next steps, if any, in the coming weeks.”

Advertise with us

Jordan Yeager, an attorney for the winning parties in the case, said the promised benefits of the medical disclosure section of the law were always “illusory,” in part because they did not extend to the drilling service companies that actually know the composition of trade-secret fracking fluids.

The removal of that section of the law should be viewed in that context, he said.

“Clearly the legislature recognized the importance of requiring disclosure” when it enacted the law in 2012, he said. “They ought to follow through on ensuring that that’s done in a meaningful way.”

One obstacle to expanding DEP’s obligation to alert water users of potential contamination from spills is that no one knows where all of the state’s private water wells are or who owns them.

The agency’s lawyers had argued in court filings that because the state does not regulate private water supplies, it does not have a reliable inventory of their locations or their owners and neither does anyone else.

Advertise with us

Mr. Yeager said, “The court dissected that and rejected that.” DEP could start by looking to the sampling surveys of private water wells that oil and gas companies submit before drilling new wells, he suggested.

But DEP said its spill notification obligation extends beyond well sites, to well pad access roads, wastewater holding ponds and other drilling support facilities around which companies have less of an incentive to perform sampling.

“You can’t notify people that you don’t know are there,” said Michael Krancer, a former DEP secretary who led the agency during the years when Act 13 was drafted and passed.

He said the idea to require DEP to notify public water suppliers actually came from DEP, because the agency knows where those facilities are and who runs them.

He suggested that legislators could introduce a softer standard, for example, by requiring DEP to try to alert private water well users of spills to the best of its ability.

Advertise with us

Patrick Grenter, Center for Coalfield Justice executive director, said there are ways to improve the state’s information on private water wells and suggested the drilling industry should bear the cost.

“Other states have a much better handle on groundwater well locations, and it would require an investment of time and resources by the state to learn that information and compile a comprehensive database,” Mr. Grenter said. “But the cost should be carried by the industry putting those resources at risk.”

Democrats that make up the minority in the House and Senate signaled they want the legislature to take the opportunity to improve Act 13.

Sen. John Yudichak, a Luzerne County Democrat who serves as the minority chairman of his chamber’s energy and environment committee, said he hopes, with the ruling, “that the legislature will come together to take the necessary action to craft a more balanced law.”

Laura Legere: llegere@post-gazette.com and Don Hopey: dhopey@post-gazette.com, 412-263-1983, or on Twitter @donhopey