Shale gas leaseholders and their advocates are making a last push to get state lawmakers to act on a bill to cap steep royalty deductions before the current legislative session expires.

Their rallying tactics range from the ordinary to the original, including a resolution passed by a rural township in Bradford County last week that demands natural gas companies cease production from wells in the community that are netting landowners “nothing or nearly nothing” in royalties after “exorbitantly high” post-production costs have been deducted from their share.

“We had to try something,” Wilmot Township supervisor Mark Dietz said. “A little township doesn’t have much ground to stand on.”

The aggrieved landowners are backing House Bill 1391, which would forbid natural gas producers from paying leaseholders a smaller royalty than the state minimum 12.5 percent.

Advertise with us

Natural gas producers commonly deduct a leaseholder’s share of expenses involved in getting gas to market, like processing and transportation costs, but the bill would prohibit deductions that bring a royalty share below the 12.5 percent minimum set by a 1979 law.

The bill was advanced by the House Environmental Resources and Energy committee in late June and then sent to the Rules committee before lawmakers recessed for the summer. The House has scheduled 14 voting days, and the Senate has scheduled nine, before the legislative session ends. After that, the bill would have to be reintroduced and start over.

“There is always a flurry of activity of legislation at the end of the session,” the bill’s prime sponsor, Rep. Garth Everett, R-Lycoming, said. “I think this is our opportunity.”

Industry opposition

“The deduction issue is not limited to any particular geographic region in Pennsylvania,” said Robert Burnett, an attorney with the firm Houston Harbaugh and a NARO-PA board member. “It is a statewide issue and it is an industry-wide issue.”

Advertise with us

The shale gas industry opposes House Bill 1391, saying it would unconstitutionally interfere with current contracts. It says the 1979 Guaranteed Minimum Royalty Act requires companies to pay 12.5 percent royalty on the net proceeds of the sale of gas, after post-production costs are considered.

Those costs average about $0.84 per thousand cubic feet of gas, according to a state Independent Fiscal Office report in July. Subtract post-production costs from the weighted average spot price of natural gas at Pennsylvania trading hubs and the average price last year was just $0.59 per thousand cubic feet, down from $3.40 per thousand cubic feet in 2011, the fiscal office reported.

In a statement, Marcellus Shale Coalition spokeswoman Erica Clayton Wright said frustration about the negative effects of depressed commodity prices is something “we understand and share.”

“Mineral owners are our partners in resource development and share in the success and challenges that the market brings,” she said. “That said, a legislative response to this issue will not bring the relief that some are promising, as a lease is a binding contract and any disputes that may arise will always be most effectively resolved by the courts.”

The issue has fractured relationships between groups that are otherwise allies.

Advertise with us

United Shale Advocates, a more acerbic platform for industry boosters that was launched by the Marcellus Shale Coalition in 2014, picked a fight on Twitter with the president of the Pennsylvania chapter of the National Association of Royalty Owners after she posted an innocuous link to a press release about the royalty bill moving out of committee early this summer.

“Lawmakers seek to swindle landowners into embracing false hope, move unconstitutional legislation out of committee,” the shale advocates tweeted.

When Jackie Root, the president of the royalty owners group, replied that that was “strong language” to direct at mineral owners who have been among the strongest proponents for shale development, the United Shale Advocates declared that “Shale Advocates must stand united” in pressing the legislature to address its priorities: defeating new energy taxes and costly regulations.

“I am afraid that those issues, for thousands of lessors, do not matter much,” Ms. Root retorted, “when their gas is sold and they net $0 or less.”

It is not yet clear whether the full House, and eventually the Senate, will take up Mr. Everett’s bill in the session’s last weeks.

Advertise with us

“We have always sought to protect the interests of Pennsylvania’s landowners in the post-production debate,” House GOP spokesman Stephen Miskin said. Lawmakers are “continuing to try and reach a consensus,” he said, but “there are still concerns among many members because leases are binding contracts, which we are constitutionally prohibited from impairing.”

Mr. Burnett said House Bill 1391 is not unconstitutional. Critics’ argument “rests on a very faulty premise,” he said, “which is that there is a contractual right to avoid and ignore the guaranteed minimum royalty statute. There is no contractual right to violate a statute.”

Taking a stand

Wilmot Township, which hosts 77 unconventional wells, was spurred to act when post-production deductions started to take about 90 percent of what residents were expecting in their royalty checks several months ago, Mr. Dietz said.

“If they had $1,000 that was supposed to come to them, they might get $57,” he said. And then, for several months, the checks stopped coming at all.

Advertise with us

“People were starting to get very uneasy and talking things that they shouldn’t be,” he said. “That’s what we’re afraid of. We don’t want to see any of our citizens do something crazy.”

The Bradford County Commissioners also adopted a resolution last week to urge legislators to pass House Bill 1391. The north-central Pennsylvania county is hosting a town hall tomorrow at a high school to rally citizens to support the bill, and the commissioners hired a firm to film residents’ testimonials to send to legislators.

After the Wilmot Township supervisors passed their resolution last Tuesday, they placed a full-page ad in local newspapers and made plans to run a similar one in the Harrisburg newspaper once lawmakers return to the Capitol next week. It contains the text of their resolution and an appeal to legislators, gas production companies and like-minded communities: “We are the forgotten, vanishing, working middle class. We out here in the rural areas care deeply about what the natural gas industry is doing to us.”

What the industry is doing, Mr. Dietz said, is “thievery.”

“I think it looks heartfelt,” he said of his community’s appeal. “That’s all we have. We don’t have the power, we don’t have the money, we don’t have the influence, but we have the passion.”

Laura Legere: llegere@post-gazette.com.