Pennsylvania’s Commonwealth Court today found that environmental regulators can continue to consider how oil and gas wells will affect sensitive spaces and species and tailor well permits to minimize those impacts, dismissing a challenge by an oil and gas industry trade group.
The appeals court ruled 5-2 that the Supreme Court did not throw out the Department of Environmental Protection’s ability to consider how wells might disrupt features like public parks, rare species and historic sites when the high court rejected other parts of the state’s updated oil and gas law in 2013.
The Wexford-based Pennsylvania Independent Oil and Gas Association had argued that the Supreme Court was unambiguous in tossing out the public resource protection sections because they were too entwined with other doomed parts of the law. But the Commonwealth Court ruled today that the high court had inserted specific conditional language — phrases like “to the extent” and “in this respect” — that separated the public resource protections from the enjoined parts of the law and allowed them to survive.
“Just as we are obligated to give meaning to every word in a statute, if possible, so too should we endeavor to give meaning to every word chosen by the Supreme Court when enforcing its mandates,” Judge P. Kevin Brobson wrote in the majority opinion.
Judges Anne Covey and Renée Cohn Jubelirer dissented, writing that the Supreme Court “unequivocally” enjoined the public resource protections.
The ruling is a victory for state environmental regulators who saw uncertainty about this question creep into their development of stricter oil and gas regulations, especially proposed new protocols for how shale gas companies are expected to interact with stewards of public resources to ensure that disruptions to protected resources are minimized.
PIOGA’s general counsel Kevin Moody said the organization will be assessing its options. “We are obviously disappointed with this decision and believe the court erred,” he said.
Laura Legere: llegere@post-gazette.com.



Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.