Whether state regulators can put conditions on new oil and gas well permits to minimize the impact on nearby public resources may hinge on how courts interpret the words “insofar” and “to the extent.”

Those slippery words appeared in a 2013 state Supreme Court decision that threw out significant parts of Act 13, the state’s update to its oil and gas law. The words were used to signify whether the public resource provisions were so entwined with the rejected sections of the law that they must also fall.

In a case scheduled to be argued in front of the Commonwealth Court tomorrow, the Pennsylvania Independent Oil and Gas Association says the high court was unambiguous when it struck down the sections of the law that require the Department of Environmental Protection to consider the impact of a proposed well on features like public parks, critical species and scenic rivers.

The court’s decision in the case will help define the strength of DEP’s authority to temper oil and gas impacts on protected public spaces and will influence pending state oil and gas rules that are already embattled in Harrisburg.

Advertise with us

The Wexford-based trade group is asking the court to declare that DEP no longer has the authority to mandate that companies applying for well permits coordinate with agencies that manage public resources and prepare detailed plans to protect them.

The state Supreme Court “did not hypothecate” that the public resource section of Act 13 “might be subject to injunction under limited circumstances,” PIOGA wrote in a brief. “The Supreme Court outright stated that [the section] is enjoined.”

DEP argues that the court was unambiguous in a completely different way.

The high court hedged, according to the department, by saying in its lead opinion that the public resource sections had to be voided “insofar as” the sections are tied up with a mandatory waiver of setback distances between wells and streams that the court deemed unconstitutional.

The court hedged again when it concluded that the public resource sections “are not severable to the extent that these provisions implement or enforce those sections of Act 13 which we have found invalid,” DEP contends.

Advertise with us

The public resource sections and the invalidated waiver sections are unconnected, the department argues, so the high court’s qualified statements allow the public resource sections to stand.

“The Supreme Court’s limiting language is clear, unambiguous, and important,” DEP wrote in a brief.

“No logical stopping point”

The Commonwealth Court has already given some indication that it sides with PIOGA’s reading in the debate. In a memorandum opinion in December denying DEP’s attempt to have the case thrown out on procedural grounds, Judge Renée Cohn Jubelirer wrote of the public resource section that “our Supreme Court has already found that provision to be unconstitutional and enjoined its application.”

DEP has proposed several backstops, including authority under other laws and the state constitution, that it says would allow it to continue considering public resource impacts in its well permits even if the court finds that the Supreme Court discarded the relevant part of Act 13.

Advertise with us

PIOGA counters that this would amount to a power grab with “no logical stopping point.”

“DEP's interpretation of the law would impermissibly give DEP discretion to define ‘public resources’ to include any animal, mineral, vegetable, or person, place, or thing of its choosing for the purpose of bringing anything of its choosing — including (but not limited to) any and all wells or well sites — into the orbit of what it sees as an unbridled ‘public resource’ protection power,” the group’s attorneys wrote.

Uncertainty affects rules

The court case has already influenced the contentious debate over DEP’s proposed revisions to its existing oil and gas rules, which are facing legislative scrutiny after being endorsed by an independent state regulatory review board in April.

A resolution disapproving the entire 260-page package of revised rules for the traditional oil and gas and shale drilling industries is pending in the state House of Representatives.

Advertise with us

One of the three reasons the resolution gives to justify barring the rules is that the regulations “disregard that the Pennsylvania Supreme Court enjoined” the two sections of the drilling law that allow DEP to consider a well’s impact on public resources.

Opponents of the new rules had also urged the Independent Regulatory Review Commission to reject DEP’s revisions because the Supreme Court threw out the public resource protection clauses that DEP is seeking to enforce. But the commissioners were not convinced that the high court had ditched that section.

After reading from the court’s opinion, IRRC chairman George Bedwick said in April that it seemed to him that the public resource protection sections “still survive except they cannot be utilized as they relate to the invalid provisions.”

Commissioner W. Russell Faber worried about what would happen if the courts disagreed.

“My concern is that if the court says no, then we don’t have authority to put limitations in” to protect public resources around well sites, he said. “And we are in even worse shape than we are now.”

Laura Legere: llegere@post-gazette.com.