A new analysis by the state’s Independent Fiscal Office ranks Pennsylvania’s proposed effective shale gas tax rate the highest among other large producers and neighboring states.

Gov. Tom Wolf’s current severance tax proposal equates to an 8.5 percent tax rate over the life of a typical Marcellus Shale well, based on the wellhead price of gas, the IFO said. That’s compared to a lifetime effective tax rate of 5.4 percent in Oklahoma — the next highest among comparison states — and 5 percent and 1.1 percent, respectively, in neighboring West Virginia and Ohio.

Pennsylvania’s current shale well impact fee, approved during former Gov. Tom Corbett’s tenure, is tied with Ohio for the lowest lifetime effective tax rate among the seven comparison states, at 1.1 percent.

The IFO’s analysis also included Arkansas, Louisiana and Texas. It did not include some major gas-producing states, like Wyoming, Colorado and New Mexico.

Advertise with us

The Wolf administration, which wants the new tax to fund education, argues that the fiscal office’s analysis creates an inaccurate impression of drilling companies’ tax burden by failing to consider significant taxes levied by other states that they do not pay here.

Mr. Wolf, a Democrat, proposed and eventually dropped a severance tax from budget negotiations last year amid profound opposition to a tax from the oil and gas industry and many Republican legislators. More GOP lawmakers have since indicated that they may be open to a tax if it can be designed so that it does not discourage drilling companies from operating in the state.

Mr. Wolf’s spokesman Jeffrey Sheridan said oil and gas extraction companies touted paying nearly $14 billion in state and local taxes in Texas in 2014, while the Pennsylvania Department of Revenue calculated that the state taxes paid by drillers here totaled $36.6 million in 2013, the most recent year available. Shale gas companies also paid $226 million in Pennsylvania impact fees for 2013.

The Marcellus Shale Coalition, a North Fayette-based industry trade group that opposes the tax, said the IFO report “demonstrates that Gov. Wolf’s energy tax increase proposal would make Pennsylvania the highest natural gas taxed state in the country, with a tax rate at a whopping 54 percent higher than top gas producing states Texas and Louisiana.”

Mr. Wolf released his newest severance tax proposal in February when he outlined his 2016-17 budget plans. He calls for a 6.5 percent tax on the value of extracted shale gas, with a credit for impact fees that companies already pay for each of their wells.

Advertise with us

The Independent Fiscal Office assumes that a severance tax effective July 1 would start bringing in revenue in November. The severance tax, minus impact fees, would raise $218 million in the 2016-17 fiscal year, it found.

Severance tax revenues would rise in 2017-18, the first full year of collections, to $517 million, and eventually grow to $970 million at the end of the decade, the fiscal office projects.

Modest growth expected

The brief analysis, which was released on April 20 as part of a broader review of revenue proposals in the governor’s budget, contains other assessments of ways a new severance tax and current low natural gas prices are likely to influence gas production and revenue trends.

The IFO assumes that Pennsylvania gas production will grow only modestly in the near term. One factor, the analysis said, is that a new severance tax will increase gas prices for final consumers, most of whom will be in other states. That will, in turn, reduce demand, which will curtail production.

Advertise with us

Independent Fiscal Office Director Matthew Knittel said the office assumes gas production will decline roughly 8 percent in response to the tax as a result of companies plugging marginal wells, putting fewer drilled wells into production or drilling fewer new wells.

The office performed a similar analysis last summer on an earlier severance tax proposal by Mr. Wolf that was structured very differently, but which the IFO found would also have had the highest rate among comparison states.

A well with similar characteristics to the typical well the IFO used this year to calculate lifetime effective tax rates would have had a tax rate of 7.3 percent under the governor’s 2015 plan.

But Mr. Knittel said other variables have changed — especially the way the office now computes the average gas price at Pennsylvania’s sales hubs — so the effective tax rates for the two proposals can’t be compared across the years.

The new IFO report also includes dramatically lower projections for how much shale companies will pay in impact fees for 2016.

Advertise with us

The office expects impact fee revenue will fall to $128 million, a 31 percent decline from the $185.5 million operators are likely to pay for 2015 and just more than half of what the impact fee brought in for 2013, its biggest year.

Last year’s impact fee payments were due to the state Public Utility Commission on April 1, but a public report on the payments usually lags a few months.

Mr. Knittel said the estimated decrease in the impact fee is driven by projections that fewer new wells, which pay the highest rates, will be drilled this year and the average annual price for natural gas will fall, driving down the fee schedule.

Laura Legere: llegere@post-gazette.com.