HARRISBURG — Pennsylvania’s Independent Regulatory Review Commission approved a wide-ranging update to the state’s oil and gas drilling rules on Thursday, voting 3-2 that the changes proposed by the state Department of Environmental Protection are in the public interest.
The divided vote capped a seven-hour-long meeting that demonstrated the deep split between oil and gas industry representatives, who believe the new regulations impose unjustified and costly new burdens, and members of environmental and citizens groups, who support the changes even as they push for greater protections.
The long-germinating rules have been in development since 2011 and include separate chapters for the state’s Marcellus Shale operations and smaller, conventional oil and gas companies.
The regulations now face another challenge in the Legislature where energy committees in both chambers are expected to advance a resolution that could block the rules from taking effect. If the Republican-controlled House and Senate pass the resolution, it could be vetoed by Democratic Gov. Tom Wolf, who supports the regulations.
DEP Secretary John Quigley said he was pleased with the vote. “This validates five years worth of tremendous public service by a tremendous group of public servants,” he said.
Scores of representatives from the state’s traditional, shallow oil and gas industry attended the meeting to share their broad disagreement with the substance of the rules and how they were developed. Often flanked by family members who help run their small businesses, they used poster-sized exhibits to illustrate their case that specific aspects of the rules are flawed, harmful or unsupported by facts.
“In order for my son to have a business and for me to pass it on to him, there has to be a regulatory environment that is balanced,” David Clark, a conventional oil driller from northwestern Pennsylvania said as he urged the board to reject the rules.
Members of citizens and environmental groups also used photos — of their school-age children or of well site spills — to make a case for the regulations. “The innocent,” as one advocate called them, pay a cost when regulations fall short, they said.
“Currently there are many costs being borne by the public and individual residents for oil and gas drilling and under-regulated drilling,” said Nadia Steinzor, eastern program coordinator for the environmental group Earthworks.
Ultimately, consensus in such a situation “is difficult if not impossible to achieve,” Independent Regulatory Review Commissioner Murray Ufberg said. But, in voting for the rules, he said DEP demonstrated its intent to balance the interests of the industries and the public good.
Laura Legere: llegere@post-gazette.com.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.