HARRISBURG — In a new U.S. Geological Survey map that forecasts the chances of damage from natural and human-caused earthquakes across the nation this year, Oklahoma is smothered by an angry red blob and Pennsylvania — like the rest of the northeastern United States — is a bland, untroubled yellow.
The difference is that wastewater from oil and gas extraction injected into deep underground disposal wells is making normally quiescent Oklahoma earthquake prone. In Pennsylvania, where the handful of active disposal wells operate under very different conditions and depths, it is not.
Scott Perry, Pennsylvania’s head oil and gas regulator, said, “It is our intention to keep it that way.”
The Pennsylvania Department of Environmental Protection is reviving a little-known regulation for the underground disposal of wastes to give added scrutiny to applications for new wastewater disposal wells.
Pennsylvania has eight disposal wells that channel wastewater into deep, porous rock, and at least seven more proposed projects are at various stages of state or federal review.
The idea is not to prohibit the wells, which the department considers safe if they are designed and operated correctly, but to subject them to “a very serious evaluation of the potential risks,” Mr. Perry said.
The scope of the department’s authority to oversee the wells came as something of a surprise to state oil and gas regulators. They learned that a grab-bag chapter of state environmental rules contains 45-year-old restrictions on underground disposal — rules that few people knew about and nobody heeded until residents appealed a state permit for a proposed Pennsylvania General Energy Co. disposal well in Indiana County and pointed out the forgotten rules.
“To be candid with you, I didn’t know that section was there,” Mr. Perry told an advisory board in late March.
Pa.’s long, lost rules on wells
Pennsylvania has long left primary oversight of the state’s wastewater disposal wells to federal regulators at the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency, who evaluate the wells’ geological settings, operating conditions and potential risks to water supplies, then issue and enforce permits.
Pennsylvania regulators’ purview was generally understood to be limited to issuing a separate state well permit and overseeing surface issues, like spill prevention and erosion control around well sites.

PG graphic: Earthquakes in the U.S.
(Click image for larger version)
But Chapter 91 of the state’s environmental regulations contains another set of rules under the heading “Underground Disposal” that, among other things, prohibits waste disposal into underground horizons unless the applicant can show that it is unlikely to harm the public interest.
“It requires a heightened level of review than just relying on the EPA permit,” Mr. Perry said. “There was no getting around it.”
DEP took the unusual step of revoking the Indiana County disposal well permit in March 2015 so that the department could review its obligations. When DEP eventually issues that permit and others, each will likely carry additional conditions to control for risks that regulators identify in their heightened reviews.
At the advisory board meeting where Mr. Perry sketched out the department’s plans, he said the conditions could include a requirement that disposal well operators install seismic monitoring equipment at their well sites, for example.
Other subjects the agency will scrutinize include the structural integrity of the wells; the volume and pressure of the fluids injected underground and how those details are monitored; faults near the geological horizons that accept the waste and past seismic activity in the area — many of which, DEP officials acknowledge, are already studied by the EPA in its permit decisions.
Industry observers are concerned about how the department’s conditions will affect companies whose permit applications have been pending for years in some cases.
“They seem to be making up the rules as they go now,” said Kevin Moody, general counsel for the Pennsylvania Independent Oil and Gas Association. “It’s just not fair to companies.”
Studying quake activity
Pennsylvania regulators have looked to other states — and the commonwealth’s own past rumbling — to understand what is triggering the quakes and adopt measures for avoiding them.
Pennsylvania is not known to be particularly seismically active, but the earth is shaking subtly underneath the commonwealth all the time. A recent master’s thesis by a Penn State graduate student named Kyle Homman catalogued 1,355 seismic events that were picked up by fixed stations and temporary arrays of seismic monitors in the state between 2013 and 2014.
All but 11 of the events were correlated to blasts at coal mines and mineral quarries. One hint — along with proximity and tell-tale characteristics of the seismic signals — was that most of the shaking happened between 8 a.m. and 6 p.m. on weekdays.
The other 11 events appeared to be natural, tectonic quakes. Mr. Homman checked to see if they could be matched in space or time to underground disposal wells or hydraulic fracturing at oil and gas wells. He found no correlation.
“There appears to be little, if any, evidence for seismic events in the catalog caused by hydraulic fracturing or wastewater injection,” he wrote.
But oil and gas-related earthquakes have occurred just over the state’s western border.
A recent U.S. Geological Survey earthquake map highlights 21 areas across the country — including three sites in Ohio — where scientists have linked sharp changes in seismic activity to underground wastewater disposal.
Ohio is not among the states that the USGS forecasts will have an elevated earthquake hazard this year, because the survey’s scientists assume that a recent decrease in human-caused seismic activity there will continue.
More seismic monitors
Ohio regulators have expanded their seismic monitoring network and established a requirement that companies install seismic monitors at horizontal production wells within 3 miles of a known fault or site of a past earthquake, among other steps they have taken in recent years to reduce the chances of damaging earthquakes.
Pennsylvania, too, is enhancing its network of seismic monitors so that scientists can pinpoint the origin and cause of seismic events with greater specificity.
Through a collaboration between the Department of Conservation and Natural Resources, DEP and Penn State, Pennsylvania’s network will expand to include 42 monitoring stations once all of the equipment is installed around June, said Seth Pelepko, chief of DEP’s subsurface activities division.
It should be able to detect seismic events anywhere in the state as small as magnitude 2 — generally below what can be felt by humans on the surface — compared with the magnitude 3 detection coverage of the past network.
Mr. Perry said on-site monitors could be a useful supplement to the state’s improved network by providing immediate information about the depth of an event if tremors originate near a wastewater disposal well.
In past comments to the same advisory board, he also indicated the state and industry have to take strong steps to address seismicity issues if they are to calm what he called “a remarkable groundswell of opposition” to injection wells.
Local governments and residents have taken various, and sometimes creative, steps to try to appeal or block disposal wells from operating in their communities.
“If we were to take the position that we’re not going to worry about this, we’re not going to be proactive about it, I think that would exacerbate local objection,” Mr. Perry said in January.
Laura Legere: llegere@post-gazette.com.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.