HARRISBURG — State House and Senate energy committees formally disapproved of regulations that would upgrade operating standards for both Marcellus Shale and traditional oil and gas companies on Tuesday, registering legislators’ dissatisfaction with a rule-making process that some members characterized as illegal.
The disapproval votes do not automatically upend the comprehensive revisions to the state’s drilling rules proposed by the state Department of Environmental Protection. But legislators urged the state’s Independent Regulatory Review Commission to reject the rules when it considers them on April 21 in one of the last major steps before the rules can take effect.
DEP has been crafting modernized rules for oil and gas operations for five years through a process that attracted nearly 28,000 public comments during two comment periods and 12 public hearings. The wide-ranging revisions would forbid some kinds of waste pits, add protection for public resources near well sites, enhance clean-up standards for spills and require companies to look for abandoned wells that might become pollution pathways near new wells.
Legislators who want DEP to scrap its rules and start over argued that the agency did not properly differentiate in its standards between sophisticated, large-scale shale operations and traditional, shallow oil and gas wells operated by small businesses, as required by a 2014 law.
They also said DEP failed to comply with laws in other respects, like missing deadlines for publishing forms that will be necessary to fulfill the regulations.
“They blatantly ignored the law,” said Rep. Martin Causer, R-Cameron, as he made the case for his motion to disapprove the rules.
Several Democrats defended the regulations, calling them common sense public health protections that satisfy the law and are long overdue. But the Republican-sponsored motions to disapprove the rules also attracted the support of a few Democrats.
Sen. John Yudichak, D-Luzerne, said he supports strong oil and gas regulations but that the regulatory process was “circumvented in many respects” by DEP.
“We need to be guided by collaboration, communication and consistency,” he said. “Unfortunately, that process was not adhered to.”
In a statement, DEP Secretary John Quigley said the regulations “have been written with an unprecedented amount of public participation” and the final draft reflects public input and the agency’s experience regulating both drilling industries. “I am confident that they will be approved by [the review commission] and ultimately adopted,” Mr. Quigley said.
The Legislature will have an opportunity to vote to block the rules even if the Independent Regulatory Review Commission approves them, but that action would be subject to a veto from the governor.
If the Legislature is ultimately successful in defeating the rules in their current form, it could take as long as two years for DEP to prepare replacement proposals, although many variables could affect the timeline, Mr. Causer said.
At the same time, DEP is facing a legal challenge to the regulations. The Pennsylvania Independent Petroleum Producers Association has asked the Commonwealth Court to stay next week’s regulatory review board meeting. The judge is expected to rule on that request sometime before the April 21 meeting.
Laura Legere: llegere@post-gazette.com.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.