Most everyone agrees that coal companies should cover more of the costs that the Pennsylvania Department of Environmental Protection bears to regulate coal mines.

Right now, permit fees paid by coal mine operators cover about 5 percent of the state’s expenses for authorizing and overseeing the mines, and even that sliver — about $325,000 annually — has consistently come in below DEP’s revenue expectations. Most of the rest of the state’s $12 million annual share is drawn from the taxpayer-funded state General Fund and those allocations have been shrinking.

But when DEP released a draft proposal for discussion last month that laid out how much permit fees would have to increase to fully fund the state’s share of the regulatory program, coal interests came away with sticker shock.

The permit fee for an underground bituminous mine, for example, would have to go from $5,750 to $74,000 — a nearly 1,200 percent increase. Fees for surface mining permits and anthracite underground mining permits would both rise more than 600 percent.

Advertise with us

“We as an industry recognize that we need to make some reasonable contributions to the program,” said Duane Feagley, executive director of the Pennsylvania Anthracite Council. But he cautioned, “If these fees get too high, it is going to negatively impact jobs and environmental reclamation in the area.”

The Pennsylvania Coal Alliance, too, said it “recognizes the need to contribute to a portion of the cost of DEP’s permitting efforts, but any increase in the current fee schedule should be reasonable.”

The full-funding formula described by DEP is not what the groups had in mind.

“A 1,200 percent increase in any program fee is not reasonable,” Pennsylvania Coal Alliance spokeswoman Abby Foster said.

DEP officials say the draft proposal was meant to start a discussion about shifting more of the funding responsibility onto coal operators, but it was not meant to indicate the agency’s firm position.

Advertise with us

Under the fee schedule that has been in place since 2012, mine operators pay for a fraction of the state’s share of the costs of reviewing coal permit applications. They do not contribute to the costs of inspecting mines and ensuring compliance with environmental and safety laws.

“We have to search for other options for sustainable revenues to support the program,” Thomas Callaghan, the director of DEP’s Bureau of Mining Programs, said. “It is an ongoing, collaborative process.”

The state is exploring changing the fee structure in three ways: increasing the current permit fee amounts, charging fees for permit actions that don’t carry a levy now, and adding an administration fee that will be collected every year.

The annual fee would begin to address a fundamental disparity: most fees are paid when a permit application comes in, but enforcement expenses are spread across the life of a mining project.

DEP’s Mining and Reclamation Advisory Board — whose members represent mining industries, the General Assembly and DEP’s Citizens Advisory Council — came back with an alternate proposal: a 50 percent increase in existing fee amounts. The board also raised concerns about higher fees creating a disincentive for re-mining and reclamation projects that DEP officials said they found valuable.

Advertise with us

DEP expects to respond with a revised proposal in April. Because any fee changes will have to go through the rounds of drafts, public comment and committee review required of a new regulation, The state does not expect changes to take effect before late 2017.

Both the industry and regulators recognize that coal production has waned.

Pennsylvania produced 61 million short tons of coal in 2014, a 13 percent increase over 2013, according to the most recent data from the U.S. Energy Information Administration. But the general production trend over the past decade has been steady decline from a high of 67.5 million short tons in 2005 to a low of 54 million short tons in 2013.

Mr. Callaghan said instituting an annual administration fee would provide a fairly sustainable funding source for DEP as long as there are operating mines.

Otherwise, under current law, “Our options are limited,” he said. “We don’t have any additional avenues to generate revenue.”

Laura Legere: llegere@post-gazette.com.