A trade group that represents small and sometimes proudly old-fashioned Pennsylvania oil producers filed a lawsuit today challenging forthcoming state regulations designed to modernize environmental protections around conventional oil and gas operations.

The Bradford-based Pennsylvania Independent Petroleum Producers Association says the rules would be financially ruinous to the state’s traditional drilling industry, which it says has been unfairly swept up in the state’s push to strengthen regulations on sophisticated and deep-pocketed producers tapping the Marcellus and Utica shales.

The group, known as PIPP, views the lawsuit as its last chance to block the rules before April 21, when an independent state regulatory review board is scheduled to vote on the rules in a final step before the regulations can take effect.

Another effort to stop the rules failed yesterday when Gov. Tom Wolf vowed to veto budget-related amendments to the Fiscal Code, saying riders in the bill would have gutted environmental safeguards. One condition in the Fiscal Code would have thrown out the pending rules for conventional drillers and required state environmental regulators to restart the process of drafting the rules that they began five years ago.

Advertise with us

Joe Thompson, a PIPP spokesman, said the timing of the lawsuit was not related to the governor’s veto announcement, although he said the lawsuit would not have been necessary if the Fiscal Code amendments had become law.

A spokesman for the state Department of Environmental Protection declined to comment on the lawsuit.

In its complaint filed in the Commonwealth Court, PIPP argues that DEP violated a provision inserted into the 2014 Fiscal Code that required the agency to publish rules for conventional and shale gas drilling separately.

The state’s environmental rule-making board, the Environmental Quality Board, voted to approve the two regulations together on Feb. 3, and “the vast majority of these rules are the same for both conventional and unconventional operators,” according to PIPP’s complaint.

The trade group says the commingling of the rules made it nearly impossible to stop them because public and political support for regulating the shale gas industry is strong.

Advertise with us

DEP officials have argued that the two rules packages hold the two industries to different standards in many respects, and that the conventional industry’s at-times poor compliance record justifies stricter rules for things like cleaning up spills and checking for underground hazards around well sites.

PIPP is asking the court to void the rules adopted by the EQB and to direct the rule-making board to begin the regulatory process anew if it wants to create new regulations for conventional wells. The trade group also asked for an expedited review of its petition or for the court to stay the board meeting scheduled for April 21.

Laura Legere: llegere@post-gazette.com.