Impact fees from Pennsylvania’s shale gas wells are distributed town by town in sums that range from a few bucks to hundreds of thousands to be saved up or spent on projects like fixing roads or improving public parks.

It is a relatively new system that relies on the accounting and record-keeping expertise of often small local governments to make sure the money is spent in the ways the law allows. It is overseen by an agency that specializes in public utilities, not government spending.

It is, in other words, a tantalizing target for an auditor.

Which is why Auditor General Eugene DePasquale announced last week the start of a long-expected performance audit of the way impact fees are calculated, collected, disbursed and spent.

Advertise with us

Nearly $856 million in impact fees have been assessed on wells tapping the Marcellus and other deep shale layers over four years. The largest share of the revenue is distributed to the wells’ host communities to offset stresses on roads, services and landscapes.

The audit has three goals, Mr. DePasquale said: to look at what is being bought with the money, to make sure the spending complies with the law, and to assess the state Public Utility Commission’s procedures for calculating and distributing the fees and for processing the local governments’ spending reports.

“I’d always said from the beginning that it was important, that at some point I would take a look at it to make sure the money is going to where it is supposed to go,” Mr. DePasquale said.

He moved the audit closer to the top of his office’s priority list after news reports started tallying the portion of impact fees — $33 million over three years — that the PUC characterizes as “not reported” by municipalities in their spending statements.

Nils Hagen-Frederiksen, a spokesman for the PUC, said the agency would have categorized spending as unreported if the statements were missing or contained errors. It was hardest to get accurate and complete information from municipalities the first year the reports were due, when the reporting obligations were still unfamiliar and most reports were submitted on paper, he said.

Advertise with us

The total of unreported spending was highest in 2011, at $20.3 million, then it dropped to $4.3 million in 2012 and rose again to $8.5 million in 2013. The 2014 reports are due on April 15.

The PUC “works vigorously” to remind the more than 1,400 municipalities, state agencies and counties that receive impact fee money of all of their reporting obligations, he said, including reaching out to local governments at least three times a year.

Those efforts, and an online reporting system, have helped to increase compliance and reduce errors, but “the ultimate responsibility for appropriately spending the money and documenting it rests with the municipalities,” Mr. Hagen-Frederiksen said.

He said the PUC welcomes the audit and will make every effort to facilitate it.

The audit will cover a period starting Feb. 14, 2012, and continue through the office’s field work, which Mr. DePasquale said he expects will last several months.

Advertise with us

Auditors will start with the reports submitted to the PUC and work back to the municipalities, picking out a sample of projects to check that the appropriate processes are in place and being followed.

“This will be a challenge because obviously the spending is taking place municipality by municipality and county by county all over the commonwealth,” Mr. DePasquale said.

He vowed to conduct the reviews with an open mind. “Once the audit is done, we’ll give our feedback as to what can be done to make it better,” he said, “or we’ll know it’s working fine.”

Laura Legere: llegere@post-gazette.com.