Last year, Gov. Tom Wolf signaled that he wanted to begin reversing years of budgets that had made Pennsylvania’s parks department increasingly dependent on natural gas development to pay for its daily operations.

It seemed the shift was going to be gradual, but then tanking natural gas prices forced a more abrupt transition.

Mr. Wolf, a Democrat, is proposing a dramatic swap: He wants to spend $61.3 million more from the state’s general budget fund on the Department of Conservation and Natural Resources in 2016-17 to offset a $51 million reduction in funding for the agency from a significantly diminished special account made up of rents and royalties from natural gas wells in state forests.

The fund was created six decades ago to set aside money from oil and gas development on state lands for conservation, recreation and flood control projects. In recent years, as the fund ballooned with revenue from Marcellus Shale leases and the state faced budget shortfalls, the majority of the money was used instead for short-term purposes, like balancing state budgets or covering DCNR’s operational costs.

Advertise with us

Environmental groups and some Democrats opposed the transfers, saying they violated the fund’s big-picture purpose of investing money gained from impacts on conserved land back into conservation. They also saw a conflict of interest in asking an agency tasked with protecting public lands to rely on the development of those lands for its funding.

But those aren’t the main reasons DCNR’s budget likely will rely much less on natural gas revenue next year. Mostly, the fund is running dry.

“They just used it all up,” said Rep. Greg Vitali, D-Delaware, the minority chairman of the House environmental resources committee. The Oil and Gas Lease Fund started the 2014-15 fiscal year with $114 million, he noted. In July, the governor’s budget projects it will have a balance of less than $3 million.

Flow of money drying up

Royalty payments have dwindled as low prices dragged down the value of the state’s share of the gas and companies largely stopped drilling new wells on their state forest leases.

Advertise with us

Drilling revenues deposited into the fund were down 46 percent in the first six months of the current fiscal year compared to the same period a year ago, from $68.3 million to $36.7 million, according to DCNR.

The eroded condition of the fund and what the Democratic minority on the House appropriations committee called its “dismal revenue projections” are not a surprise.

The appropriations committee in the Republican-controlled Senate has been tracking the fund closely for at least the past year, issuing a warning last September that royalties had “dropped precipitously.” In a report this month, the committee said the state general fund “will be forced to absorb” more DCNR spending in 2016-17.

The state’s Independent Fiscal Office also had a grim forecast when it released its five-year budget outlook last month. The office expects royalties to remain depressed for the next few years, returning to 2014 levels around 2018.

With some continued spending from the fund mandated by state law, lawmakers will have little choice but to shift more of DCNR’s expenses to the general fund. That is especially true because the amount drawn from the Oil and Gas Lease Fund in the 2014-15 fiscal year was “unusually high,” the Independent Fiscal Office’s director Matthew Knittel said.

Advertise with us

“It just can’t maintain that level,” he said.

Trading blame

The Wolf administration blames both lower royalties and the legislature for the fund’s decline. “For years, the Republican-controlled legislature raided the Oil and Gas Fund to pay for expenses the fund was not intended to bankroll,” Mr. Wolf’s spokesman Jeffrey Sheridan said.

Republicans defend the past transfers, which started under former Democratic Gov. Ed Rendell in 2009 in the wake of the recession.

As more public land was opened for gas leases to take advantage of the Marcellus Shale boom, Republicans felt it was wise to use the unprecedented revenues to cover budget shortfalls, said Jennifer Kocher, spokeswoman for Senate Majority Leader Jake Corman, R-Centre.

Advertise with us

“At the time, and given the state of the economy then, the best use was to solve general fund problems rather than to hold the money in a special fund or to provide grants for ‘nice-to-have’ purposes and pass the bill on to taxpayers,” she said. “Nobody could have predicted the decrease in energy prices and its impact on the fund.”

New funding sources

The governor plans to replenish the account by tapping an entirely different source of funding. His budget calls for raising landfill tipping fees for municipal waste to $8 per ton, an increase of $1.75 per ton, and assessing the fee on construction, demolition and residual waste, which are currently exempt.

That new funding source is expected to raise $35 million for the Oil and Gas Lease Fund. It would allow the state to resume full payment to another account that is dedicated to conservation and public infrastructure projects and hazardous sites cleanup.

Eventually, the fund is expected to bounce back, although not all projections are uniformly optimistic.

Advertise with us

Mr. Wolf’s budget proposal assumes the fund will collect just $48 million in rents and royalties next fiscal year, which Mr. Sheridan called a cautious estimate. The Independent Fiscal Office assumes natural gas revenues hit bottom this year and will climb in the next fiscal year to $85 million, based on DCNR’s and analysts’ projections.

For Mr. Vitali, who has pushed for years to make DCNR less reliant on natural gas revenue, the true test will come when there is once again enough money in the fund to satisfy its original conservation purpose.

“The fact that they’re doing it this year doesn’t really signal anybody’s intentions because there’s no money there,” he said. “I will be happy in a year where there is money in it and they still fund DCNR through other means.”

Laura Legere: llegere@post-gazette.com.