HARRISBURG — Environmental regulators are beginning to sketch out their multi-pronged plan to limit methane leaks from the natural gas sector by tightening the rules for sites they already supervise.
Gov. Tom Wolf called on the Department of Environmental Protection to cut down on the unnecessary release of the potent greenhouse gas from shale gas well sites, compressor stations and the state’s expanding web of natural gas pipelines.
Methane is the second most common greenhouse gas from human activities, with 84 times the heat-trapping power of the leader, carbon dioxide, over a 20-year period.
The oil and gas industry accounts for a quarter of U.S. methane emissions, with leaks in Pennsylvania alone that state regulators say likely amount to more than $60 million worth of lost product annually.
Regulators are first tackling emissions from new shale gas well sites and compressor stations, which the department oversees now. DEP wants to issue streamlined permits for those facilities by October, Joyce Epps, the director of DEP’s Bureau of Air Quality, said at an advisory board meeting last week when concepts for the new permits were announced.
Regulations for existing oil and gas facilities, and suggestions for leak detection and control along pipelines will take longer to implement.
DEP said it is considering an array of new standards for well pads, among them: quarterly leak inspections with infrared cameras and monthly walk-though screenings; cleaner diesel engines on drilling rigs; quicker repairs once leaks are discovered; 95 percent control of emissions of associated pollutants from storage tanks; and reduced bleed-off from pumps.
Department officials said they are considering similar controls — quicker leak repair, no-bleed or low-bleed controllers, no more venting during cleaning and maintenance — at gas compression and processing sites.
The new standards will be set out in general permits, which establish a baseline of behavior. Instead of applying for an individual permit for every new site it builds, a company agrees to comply with all of the terms of a general permit that have been set in advance for a whole class of similar sites.
As they design the standards, regulators said they are trying to reach a balance: demanding better controls than the ones most companies are using now without being so restrictive that companies skip the general permit and seek a more time-consuming case-by-case evaluation of their sites instead.
“We have an obligation here to make sure that we really have the cutting-edge technology requirements,” said DEP’s chief of its air permits division, Krishnan Ramamurthy. On the other hand, he added later, “I don’t think it would be proper for us to propose something that few people can meet.”
And then there is the persistent question of why some companies have adopted very aggressive leak control strategies and others have not, if — as the department says — most investments to cut methane leaks will pay for themselves almost immediately.
DEP Secretary John Quigley said the agency’s strategy will push “practices and pieces of equipment that provide high return on investment, capturing gas that is not currently getting to market.”
Business and industry groups have long argued that new rules are not necessary for the same reason — companies have a natural incentive not to waste gas they can sell.
Advisory board member Joseph Duckett suggested that DEP talk not only to the best performing companies that have adopted model controls but also to those that aren’t using the department’s favored techniques to find out why.
“It’s pretty rare when something that has minimal cost and pays for itself is avoided by a business,” he said.
In response to a variation on that comment, Mr. Quigley offered this assessment: “Some companies are smarter than others.”
“We cannot sit back and wait for voluntary compliance,” he said, “because it’s not happening.”
Laura Legere: llegere@post-gazette.com.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.