Sometime soon, if it hasn’t happened already, your old electric meter is going to be replaced with a network-connected device known as a smart meter.
A 2008 Pennsylvania law requires the switch, which is seen as one crucial step toward modernizing the electric grid — making it more efficient and responsive.
But smart meters are capable of monitoring the way you use power by minutes or hours, which can reveal a surprising amount about what goes on in your house. A bill endorsed by the state House consumer affairs committee last week tries to limit who gets to look at those details.
As it’s currently written, the law allows utilities to share individual meter data with third parties — like services that help residents manage their power use — only with the customer’s consent.
The bill, sponsored by Rep. Mike Reese, R-Mount Pleasant, specifies that “government agencies” also can’t access meter data without a customer’s approval.
There are exceptions for consent-free access to meters and meter data in cases of life-threatening emergencies, under court order or in aggregated form.
Some consumer watchdogs have said government agencies are probably already covered by the law’s limits on when customer data can be released, but it doesn’t hurt to spell it out.
Mr. Reese says he does not think electric companies are giving out customers’ data now, but he sponsored the bill after he heard from constituents who were worried about how information being collected through the meters could be shared. His bill makes restrictions on data sharing clearer.
“It is just an additional layer of protection for the consumer,” he said.
If the bill becomes law, it probably won’t change much for the region’s electric utilities.
“The bill aligns with our current company policy, which requires a subpoena in order to turn customer data over to law enforcement or government agencies without customer consent,” said Aaron Ruegg, a spokesman for Akron, Ohio-based FirstEnergy Corp., the parent company of West Penn Power and other electric utilities in Pennsylvania.
Similarly, Downtown-based Duquesne Light Co. may disclose customer information if it is required by law or a legal process, like a subpoena, or if a customer authorizes the release, spokeswoman Jessica Rock said.
Smart meters can track electricity use remotely and nearly in real-time, instead of having a meter-reader record the information in person and in bulk each month.
Eventually companies will offer electric rates tied to periods when power demand surges or slackens and let people save money if they run energy-intensive appliances during hours when demand is lowest.
This is the point of smart meters — they allow customers and utilities to manage power use with greater precision — and it is also the thing that can make them seem creepy.
With enough time and data, it would be possible for someone in an office in Virginia to tease out the daily routines of a household in Oakmont based on the revealing details of its energy use.
The bill, known as House Bill 395, is one of four Mr. Reese introduced last year related to smart meters. The others would get rid of the law’s requirement for large utilities to install smart meters and allow customers who do not want smart meters to opt out.
“In the commonwealth of Pennsylvania, it doesn't really matter where you live. Everybody will move to this type of technology,” he said. “In my mind, I think that there should be a choice.”
The other bills have not been brought up in committee and Mr. Reese admits they face long odds. Critics of those bills say it would be prohibitively costly and cumbersome to allow a small fraction of consumers to stick with the old system.
But House leadership has indicated that the bill concerning smart meter privacy will get a vote in the full chamber.
The House voted unanimously for a version of the same bill introduced in the previous legislative session, but the Senate did not consider it.
Mr. Reese thinks this bill has momentum because it’s the least controversial of the package.
“When you are in your home, you have an expectation of privacy with your utilities,” he said. “It’s not a partisan issue in any way.”
Laura Legere: llegere@post-gazette.com.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.