One energy company’s challenge to the Department of Environmental Protection’s practice of adding up fines for persistent pollution was revived last week, while a second company’s challenge has been settled without resolving the thorny issue.
A state Supreme Court decision on Dec. 29 will give Downtown-based EQT Corp. a new opportunity to challenge environmental fines that continue to mount when pollution keeps leaching out of contaminated soil after a leak is plugged.
EQT contends the fines should stop accumulating when the leak’s source — in this case, a breached liner in a 6-million-gallon wastewater holding pond — is cut off. Otherwise, the company argued in court filings, it would “face massive civil penalties for an indefinite period of time as long as any detectable amount of a substance remains present in waters of the Commonwealth.”
EQT’s interpretation of the Clean Streams Law is shared by Sunoco Logistics Partners, which argued against DEP’s method of tallying fines in a separate case in the state’s Environmental Hearing Board. But DEP and the Delaware County-based company settled that civil penalty case for $750,000 in mid-December.
The final settlement amount is less than one-third the size of the $2.4 million fine the agency initially sought from Sunoco Logistics, whose pipeline plug burst in Murrysville in 2008 causing a 12,000-gallon gasoline spill.
“It became apparent during settlement discussions that a reasonable penalty assessment could be reached and therefore the Department worked with Sunoco to reach the settlement figure in order to avoid prolonged litigation,” DEP spokesman Neil Shader said in an email. “The Department feels that the penalty agreement is appropriate for the release and Sunoco’s response to the incident.”
The settlement won’t spare the department from having judges scrutinize its position that every day that residual pollution seeps into Commonwealth waters can carry another $10,000 penalty under the law.
The dispute hinges on a litany of verbs the Clean Streams Law uses to describe violations.
For example, the law says that no one “shall place or permit to be placed, or discharge or permit to flow, or continue to discharge or permit to flow” any sewage, industrial wastes or other types of pollution into any state waters without a permit.
Despite the accumulation of action words, the law doesn’t necessarily define when a violation ends. “Suffice it to say,” the Environmental Hearing Board wrote in one opinion in the Sunoco case, “that the respective statutes and regulations are nuanced.”
DEP and the companies argue that the law is clear, although they draw entirely different interpretations of its meaning. During one hearing, a DEP attorney memorably told the environmental tribunal that Sunoco’s theory “is exterminated like a vampire exposed to sunlight when it is subjected to the disinfecting light of the text of the Clean Streams Law.”
Michael Krancer, a former DEP Secretary and Environmental Hearing Board judge, said the law is not clear on this point and he is not certain which side is right.
“You would think this has come up before, many times,” he said. “It has not.”
“I remember looking at this and saying, ‘Oh my gosh. This has really never been decided one way or another.’”
The dispute between EQT and DEP will continue in two venues: the Commonwealth Court, which will have to sort out the meaning of all those verbs now that the Supreme Court remanded the case to the lower court, and the Environmental Hearing Board, which has to decide how much to fine EQT for the wastewater leak.
DEP has suggested a penalty of at least $4.5 million. It also wants the judges to tack on up to $10,000 for every day that waste fluids continued to flow into state waters after DEP’s complaint was filed in October 2014.
Laura Legere: llegere@post-gazette.com.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.