The U.S. Army Corps of Engineers calls it an “aquatic staircase.” Every dozen miles or so, the water in the Allegheny, Ohio and Monongahela rivers trips over a dam and falls several feet into a lower channel.

The man-made cascades break the rivers into pools and keep them deep enough for navigation, but the flow and fall of water over the dams has drawn the attention of hydropower developers who see it as an unharnessed source of reliable, renewable energy.

Right now, there are 13 hydroelectric power projects at some stage of federal permitting review on the Allegheny, Ohio and Monongahela rivers in southwestern Pennsylvania. If all of them are built, they would have a combined capacity of 212 megawatts of electricity.

River Town

Advertise with us

This series examines the ways the Pittsburgh region’s defining waterways help shape its economic opportunities.

• Riverfront spaces have become epicenter of city's development

• Bringing life back to a 'mud hole'

• Running a marina on the Allegheny has been an invigorating ride

• Carrie Furnaces attract artists, entertainers and tourists to former mill site

Advertise with us

This summer, Illinois-based Hydro Green Energy received a 50-year license from the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission for a new 5.25 megawatt hydroelectric project at the Braddock Locks and Dam on the Monongahela River.

FFP New Hydro has a more sweeping vision — FERC has granted the Boston-based developer preliminary licenses to build hydropower plants on eight dams on the three rivers. The company, which is majority owned by renewable energy investment firm U.S. Renewables Group, is also in the early stages of exploring putting plants at four more of the rivers’ dams.

“There is normal water that is running over the structures anyway. Why not just send some of that water through a hydro plant to create power?” said Don Lauzon, vice president for regulatory affairs at Rye Development, which manages FFP New Hydro.

Interest in powering the Army Corps-run dams often rises and recedes.

Hydropower plants have operated on five of the 23 locks and dams on the three rivers in the corps’ Pittsburgh District since the 1980s, but interest waned for two decades and surged again around 2010.

Advertise with us

“Ever since then, we’ve had every lock and dam being studied,” said Jeff Benedict, hydropower coordinator for the corps’ Pittsburgh District.

The confluence of big rivers makes the Pittsburgh region attractive to hydropower developers. Mr. Lauzon said his company looks for regions with a concentration of existing dams, then develops several projects at once to save on engineering studies, construction and other costs.

“We’re developing clusters, so we’re able to establish economies of scale,” he said.

Companies have developed — and dropped — grand plans to power the three rivers’ dams in the past, including in 2010 when Massachusetts-based Brookfield Renewable Power abandoned plans to develop hydropower at 14 sites in the Ohio River Basin after deciding the projects were not financially practical.

“We’ve had a lot of licenses that have not worked out,” Mr. Benedict said. “They may come to fruition, but it’s no guarantee, even having a license.”

Advertise with us

Lindsay Baxter, the energy and climate program manager at the Pennsylvania Environmental Council, named two big challenges to broader adoption of hydropower in Pennsylvania: Electricity from competing sources in the commonwealth has historically been relatively cheap, and inexpensive natural gas only reinforces that trend. Also, the process of permitting and licensing hydropower plants is lengthy and complex.

Hydropower projects on existing dams are considered much less environmentally intrusive than construction of new dams, and the environmental group promotes low-impact hydropower that includes stringent permitting requirements that limit ecological and community impacts.

Ms. Baxter said Pennsylvania’s permitting process aligns differently with the federal permitting process than it does in other states, which can add significant time to a project. The time from conceiving a project to generating power can range from five to 10 years.

“Even five years is a long time to be able to find investors who can sink in the capital with no certainty that the project will even get built,” she said. “Developers are able to start the permitting process, start doing the significant number of studies that need to be done, but part way through they just run out of money.”

Two weeks ago, PEC helped to host an invitation-only event with hydropower developers, manufacturers and government officials, including several members of Gov. Tom Wolf’s Cabinet. Government leaders at the event “spoke really honestly about their interest in continuing to grow hydropower development but also some of the challenges to that,” Ms. Baxter said. “The question for everyone is how do we attract more private capital.”

Advertise with us

In August, FFP New Hydro announced it had secured a loan from Texas-based alternative asset management firm Crestline Investors for an undisclosed amount that would enable its development of 21 advanced-stage hydropower projects on existing dams in five states, including the projects planned in the Pittsburgh region.

Mr. Lauzon said FFP New Hydro has already spent $14 million over the past five years on engineering, recreation and environmental studies for its eight advanced and four early-stage southwestern Pennsylvania projects. The company projects it will invest roughly $600 million more if all of them are built.

Laura Legere: llegere@post-gazette.com.